XXIII. Submissions of the State of Novaris
Novaris's submissions rest principally on a restrictive construction of the Liability Convention's
scope. It submits that the Convention cannot be read to impose absolute liability for indirect
atmospheric effects that manifest only after the substantially complete combustion of a space
object, and that Article II cannot properly be extended to atmospheric-chemical processes merely
because their downstream consequences subsequently materialize as surface damage. It further
submits that Article III affords no alternative basis of liability on the facts of the present case,
though it accepts that the Convention does not itself preclude the Court's consideration of other
applicable rules of intern ational law while maintaining that those rules, properly applied to the
evidence adduced, do not establish liability. Novaris additionally submits that Astera's independent
corporate conduct cannot be automatically attributed to the State, and that it duly fulfilled its
obligations of authorization and continuing supervision under Article VI of the Outer Space Treaty.
Novaris further contends that it exercised due regard for the interests of other States and adopted
measures that were reasonable in light of the scientific and operational information reasonably
available in June 2032, and that no sufficiently crystallized rule of customary international law
obliged it to undertake the particular atmospheric environmental assessment Arkania proposes. It
submits, moreover, that a precautionary approach cannot operate as a substitute for proof of an
antecedent legal obligatio n or of an established causal connection, and that the thirteen -day
disposal schedule represented a reasonable and proportionate accommodation of competing
orbital-safety and environmental considerations.
On causation and quantum, Novaris submits that Arkania has failed to establish a sufficiently direct
and certain causal nexus between the ORION -7 campaign and the alleged surface -level damage,
and that Arkania's own longstanding industrial pollution constituted a substantial concurrent if not
predominant cause of the observed acidification. It contends that the available scientific evidence
does not permit the Court to determine ORION -7's contribution with the requisite degree of
certainty, and that the environmental, agricultural, fisheries and cultural l osses Arkania attributes
to the campaign have not been substantiated to the requisite evidentiary standard. Novaris
accordingly requests that the Court dismiss Arkania's claims for compensation and all other relief
sought.
XXIV – ISSUES FOR ADJUDICATION
1. Issue I - Liability under the Liability Convention
Whether the atmospheric contamination, acidification, and consequent property and
environmental harm alleged by Arkania, despite no physical component of ORION-7 reaching
the Earth's surface, constitutes "damage" caused by a "space object" under Articles I and II of
the Liability Convention, read in light of Article VII of the Outer Space Treaty and Article VI
of the Liability Convention.
2. Issue II - State Responsibility for Private Space Activity
Whether Novaris discharged its obligation under Article VI of the Outer Space Treaty to
authorize and continuously supervise the activities of Astera Orbital Technologies Ltd., such
that Astera's conduct or Novaris's own regulatory approval and omissions , gives rise to
international responsibility, and whether Article III of the Outer Space Treaty operates to
engage the applicable rules of general international law.
3. Issue III - Environmental Due Diligence
Whether, in light of the scientific information reasonably available before June 2032, Novaris
was required to undertake or mandate an environmental impact assessment or other preventive
measures for the concentrated ORION -7 campaign — assessed against the applicability of
Article IX of the Outer Space Treaty (including the significance of its refe rence to
"extraterrestrial matter") to the alleged atmospheric effects, and against the customary
obligations of prevention, due diligence, precaution, notification, and consultation that were
thereby engaged.
4. Issue IV - Causation and Reparation
Whether the evidence establishes a legally sufficient causal connection between ORION-7 and
the alleged acidified rainfall and resulting damage, notwithstanding pre -existing industrial
pollution, scientific uncertainty and gaps in telemetry; and, if Novari s is found responsible or
liable, what form and extent of reparation is appropriate, including compensation, restoration,
monitoring and remediation.