ANNEX XXIII
REPUBLIC OF NOVARIS
DIPLOMATIC RESPONSE
Date: October 2032
Subject: Response to Arkania's Diplomatic Note of 4 October 2032
The Government of Novaris acknowledged Arkania's allegations but rejected the assertion that
the ORION -7 campaign constituted a breach of international law or that Novaris was
responsible for the environmental effects alleged.
Novaris maintained that:
1. the Liability Convention did not establish absolute liability for the indirect atmospheric
effects alleged by Arkania;
2. the scientific evidence did not establish sufficient causal connection between ORION-
7 and the alleged environmental damage;
3. eastern Arkania had experienced substantial industrial emissions for many years before
the ORION-7 campaign;
4. Astera's private operational conduct could not automatically be attributed to Novaris;
5. Novaris had authorized and supervised the campaign in accordance with the applicable
domestic regulatory framework; and
6. no sufficiently established international rule required the particular atmospheric
environmental assessment proposed by Arkania in 2032.
Novaris further rejected the proposition that the November 2032 legislative amendment
constituted evidence of a prior breach, emphasizing that the amendment operated prospectively.
Nevertheless, Novaris agreed to continue discussions concerning scientific information
exchange, environmental monitoring, preservation of relevant records and future preventive
procedures.
The diplomatic exchange did not result in agreement concerning responsibility, causation or
compensation.