Karnataka's Validation Act Falls — a Statute Cannot Annul a Judgment
The rule is old, but the facts make it unusually clean: the court found corruption, not a procedural flaw, so there was nothing for a validating law to cure, and the State's own counsel conceded as much.
Read the cover storyAlso this week
- 02 Criminal Law: A Consensual Relationship That Ends Is Not Retrospectively Rape
- 03 UAPA: The Foreigner’s Bail Bar Needs Proof of Illegal Entry and Does Not Touch Default Bail
- 04 Elections: “Form 6 Is for Someone Enrolling for the First Time” — the Court Questions the Delhi Revision and Issues Notice on Maharashtra’s
- 05 Tribunals: “The Tribunal Has Gone Haywire” — APTEL’s Review of a Settled Point Is Set Aside With Costs
- 06 Arrest: No Written Grounds, No Prejudice, No Bail — the Grounds-of-Arrest Cases Read Through Prejudice
- 07 Criminal Procedure: A Rape Case Cannot Be Quashed on a Compromise, and the Court Hears the Victim First
- 08 Drug Pricing: “Can You Show Any Justification for This Loot?” — the Court Reserves Orders on Margins Beyond Cancer Drugs
- 09 Banking: Banks Must Indemnify Digital-Arrest Victims Where Their Diligence Failed, the Court Tells the Reserve Bank
- 10 Arbitration: Section 29A Extensions Go to the “Court,” Not the Appointing High Court
- 11 Income Tax: No Section 143(2) Notice, No Reassessment
- 12 Electricity: Theft Disconnections Get the Section 126 Procedure, and Reconnection on Half the Demand — Dakshin Gujarat Vij Co.
- 13 Criminal Justice: ₹6 Lakh for Six Years in Custody on “a Concocted Story,” and the Judgment Goes to the DGP
- 14 RTI: Co-operative Records the Registrar “Can Access” Are Information, and No Inquiry Need Precede Access — Muppathadam Service Co-op Bank
- 15 Land Acquisition: Fraud Reopens an Acquisition Closed by a Division Bench and an SLP Dismissal
- 16 Civil Procedure: A Stranger to a Consent Decree May Appeal With Leave, and Limitation Runs From Knowledge — Girishbhai Patel, With Balakrishna
- 17 Service Law: A Notified Operation Attracts War Injury Pension Unless the Notification Says Otherwise
- 18 Environment: No Blanket Ban, “Our Orders Are Violated More Than They Are Obeyed,” and the Firecracker Order Is Reserved Nine Days Before Diwali
- 19 Anti-Corruption: Kerala Holds the Vijayan Investigation in Abeyance for Four Weeks, With the FIRs Intact
- 20 Religious Endowments: Madras Puts the Chidambaram Nataraja Temple Under a Board Headed by Two Former Judges
- 21 Judges: No Public Meeting Whose Object Is to Target a Sitting Judge, Madras Holds
- 22 Taxation: J&K Strikes Down Water-Usage Charges on Hydropower as a Tax on Electricity Generation the State Could Not Levy
- 23 Arrest: Fifteen Years On, Nagpur Declares Arun Ferreira’s 2011 Arrest Illegal and Awards ₹2 Lakh
- 24 Defamation: Calcutta Orders YouTube, X and Instagram to Take Down the Modi–Adani Documentary
- 25 Environment: Kerala Quashes the Vizhinjam Erosion Committee for Conflict of Interest and Orders a Fresh Panel
- 26 Collegium: Four Chief Justices for Delhi, Gujarat, Telangana and Uttarakhand, and Thirty-One Names for Five High Courts
- 27 Mentioning: Senior Counsel Barred From Oral Mentioning From 2 November, and the Mentions Go Off the Live Stream
- 28 Allahabad: The Bar Accuses Justice Bhanot of Jailing a Lawyer in Court, and a Neighbouring Judge Starts Contempt Against the Protesters
- 29 IBC: Once a Plan Is Before the Tribunal, the Committee Cannot Withdraw It Because the Debtor Got Richer
- 30 IBC: A Lender That “Navigates” the Debtor’s Policy Is a Related Party, and the Test Is Lower Than Control Under Section 29A
- 31 IBC: Real-Estate Insolvency Is Rewritten — Project-Wise Accounts, Project Exclusion, a Choice of Representatives, and RERA at the Table
- 32 Tribunals: “Our Requests Are Directions,” the Court Tells the NCLAT, and Says the Ministry Has “Hijacked” the NCLT’s Staff
- 33 GST: The 57th Council Is Implemented — Three Notifications, Ten Circulars, Rate Changes From 1 November, and an Instruction That There Will Be No Arrests
- 34 Securities: A Carbon-Credit Company’s Promoter Banned for a Year Over ₹197 Crore of Premature Revenue, ₹1 Crore on CDSL, and a Censure for Axis Capital
- 35 Telecom: TRAI Floats Draft Guidelines on Responsible Use of AI in Networks, With Comments by 27 November
Welcome to this week’s issue of the Indian Legal Brief (ILB). Here are the judgments, orders, regulatory changes, and developments that matter to your practice — without the noise.
The Supreme Court came back from Dussehra on Monday and pronounced about thirty judgments in five days, most of them from the bench of Justices Pardiwala and Vinod Chandran. The cover is the one that undoes a statute: Karnataka’s 2022 Act validating a recruitment the courts had cancelled for corruption is struck down, with the State’s own senior counsel conceding it could not be defended, and 191 officers appointed under it lose their posts with a one-time chance to compete again. Justice Nagarathna’s bench discharged a man of rape at the threshold because a consensual relationship that ends is not retrospectively a crime, and wrote the caution about genuine cases into the same judgment. Two insolvency rulings fix the position of lenders: a Committee of Creditors cannot withdraw a plan once it is before the Tribunal, and a lender whose covenants let it “navigate” the debtor’s policy is a related party on a test the Court set below the one it uses for resolution applicants. The foreigner’s bail bar in the UAPA needs proof of illegal entry, not just foreign nationality; a grounds-of-arrest objection without prejudice does not unlock bail; a rape case cannot be quashed on a compromise, and the Court spoke to the complainant by video before saying so; APTEL was told it had “gone haywire” and a public-sector intervenor paid costs. In hearings, the Chief Justice’s bench told the Election Commission that Form 6 is for first-time voters and gave the Opposition’s petitions a date, reserved orders on drug margins beyond cancer drugs and on Diwali firecrackers, and told the Reserve Bank that its KYC Directions must make banks indemnify digital-arrest victims. The Collegium named four Chief Justices and thirty-one judges; Senior Advocates may not mention from Monday. Kerala’s Division Bench held the Vijayan investigation in abeyance for four weeks; Madras put the Chidambaram temple under a board of two former judges; Jammu and Kashmir struck down water-usage charges on hydropower as a tax on generation. The Board of Indirect Taxes implemented the 57th Council in three notifications, ten circulars and an instruction that there are to be no GST arrests; the Insolvency Board rewrote the rules for real-estate insolvency; and the Securities Board banned a carbon-credit promoter for a year.
Supreme Court Highlights
Public Law: A Statute Cannot Annul a Judgment — Karnataka’s Recruitment Validation Act Is Struck Down — Srinivasa T. v. State of Karnataka
Bench: Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran — October 29, 2026
In November 2011 the Karnataka Public Service Commission notified recruitment to 362 Group A and B posts; 1,38,307 applied, 1,090 were interviewed. In 2013 the State withheld the final list and ordered a CID inquiry, which found what the judgment calls “rampant corruption and instances of blatant nepotism” at the Commission: call records between candidates and members, identical interview marks for at least 566 candidates, and the replacement of the Commission’s video recorder to destroy evidence. The State cancelled the recruitment. The Administrative Tribunal quashed the cancellation; the High Court, on public interest petitions by unsuccessful candidates, restored it; and the Supreme Court in Avinash C. v. State of Karnataka dismissed the selected candidates’ appeals, refusing to separate the tainted from the untainted. A second attempt, to resume the process from the interview stage, also failed in both courts. Then, in 2022, “after more than a decade from the stage of recruitment, when obviously the political currents kept on changing,” the legislature passed the Karnataka Civil Services (Validation of Selection and Appointment of 2011 Batch Gazetted Probationers) Act, 2022, validating the cancelled selection. One hundred and ninety-one candidates were appointed under it, fourteen of them among the forty-six found tainted. The High Court dismissed a challenge to the Act in what the Supreme Court calls “a cryptic order” of April 2022, and the Tribunal, following that, refused the unsuccessful candidates interim relief.
In Srinivasa T. v. State of Karnataka, 2026 INSC 1173, authored by Justice Vinod Chandran, the Court set the Act aside as unconstitutional, with both High Court orders. Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal, for the State, “candidly submitted that the legislation cannot at all be supported”; Shyam Divan appeared for the appellants and C.A. Sundaram and Anand Sanjay M. Nuli for the appointees. The governing case was Medical Council of India v. State of Kerala, where an ordinance regularising 180 illegal medical admissions on the same plea of hardship had been struck down. A legislature may change the law with retrospective effect and so remove the basis of a judgment; it may not set aside a decision between parties. The Act’s Statement of Objects and Reasons invoked Taylor v. Taylor and the fact that no candidate had been charge-sheeted, “but there is nothing stated as to the irregular manner in which the cancellation was made and in any event the cancellation having been upheld by the High Court and this Court, the power does not lie with the legislature to annul the cancellation, even by a legislation and thus nullify the judgments of the Constitutional Courts.” The Constitution Bench in the Cauvery reference had said that a law overriding a decision against the State “would sound the death knell of rule of law”; S.T. Sadiq that the legislative function is to make law, not to declare what the law shall be in a decided case. Equity could not save the appointees, because the recruitment had been annulled for corruption, not irregularity, and their appointments rested on “a stillborn legislation.” The Court was pointed about the courts below: “We cannot but record, a little bit of surprise and a lot more alarm, insofar as the impugned judgments are concerned. The PIL was cursorily dealt with, and the later Writ Petition was also dealt with in a similar manner, throwing to winds every tenet of law; upholding an enactment clearly beyond the scope of the powers conferred on the law-making authority and bordering on the absurd.”
“It is the shifting stances of the State, depending on the hues and colours in the changing times, we criticised at the outset.”
Fifteen years on, the Court declined to resume the 2011 process and moulded the relief instead. The appointments under the Act come to an end. The State is to notify fresh recruitment to the vacant Group A and B posts under the existing 1997 Rules. The untainted appointees, the six appellants and the petitioners pending before the Tribunal get a one-time age relaxation to compete; if selected, their seniority runs from the fresh appointment, with no back wages or notional date; and serving officers who are reselected will have their years under the 2022 Act counted for pension, though not for seniority. The judgment also records that a public interest petitioner is not dominus litis and may not withdraw without leave, and decides the petition on its merits with the appellants transposed as petitioners. It is marked non-reportable, which for a judgment striking down a State Act is a curiosity of the Registry rather than a measure of its weight.
Why it matters: The rule is old, but the facts make it unusually clean: the court found corruption, not a procedural flaw, so there was nothing for a validating law to cure, and the State’s own counsel conceded as much. The relief is the template for any long-running tainted selection, fresh recruitment with age relaxation, no seniority, no back wages, pension credit for service rendered. And the passage on the High Court’s “cryptic” orders is a warning to every bench asked to wave through a validation statute on a hardship plea.
Criminal Law: A Consensual Relationship That Ends Is Not Retrospectively Rape — Santhosh Kumar N.P. v. State
Bench: Justices B.V. Nagarathna and R. Mahadevan — October 30, 2026
The complainant, a divorcee, went through a temple ceremony with the appellant in Mysuru in 1996 and lived with him until 2003. By her own account his brother told her within months that he was already married with two children. In 2008 she filed a Domestic Violence Act petition, in which his earlier marriage was disclosed; it failed. She then filed a private complaint under Sections 376, 420, 493, 494 and 495 of the Penal Code, which was dismissed for non-prosecution, and a second, near-identical one, which became an FIR in 2011. The Sessions Judge at Thalassery refused discharge in 2015; the Kerala High Court, in May 2025, held that consent under a misconception of marital status would be rape and that seven years’ cohabitation did not undo the initial inducement.
In Santhosh Kumar N.P. v. State, 2026 INSC 1179, authored by Justice Nagarathna, the Court allowed the appeal and discharged the appellant of every offence, R. Basant appearing for him. The standard under Section 227 of the Code, from Prafulla Kumar Samal and Sajjan Kumar, is a limited sifting of whether the material taken at face value discloses the ingredients; it is neither a pre-trial nor deference to the prosecution. On that material, the complainant knew of the earlier marriage within months and stayed seven years; her claim to have believed herself his lawful wife on oral reassurance was “untenable and incredulous.” “Repeatedly” in Section 376(2)(n) denotes separate acts, and the genuine cases under it show an initial assault followed by acts under fear or continued deceit, not a functioning relationship. Section 420 failed for want of any property or valuable security; Sections 493 to 495 because no valid marriage was even prima facie shown and she knew of the first one. “The mere factum of the relationship having turned sour and acrimonious cannot on its own convert earlier incidences of consent to sexual acts into offences of rape.” The Court noted “a worrying trend in recent years wherein consensual relationships that have come to an end are retrospectively combed with a fine tooth,” an approach that “denudes the man of any agency entirely,” and asked: “can it be said that the man had no right to withdraw from the relationship? Can such a decision be termed as deceit or fraud? Clearly not.”
“For every case where the provisions related to rape are misused, there are several cases that never see the light of day. We must emphasise that genuine cases must be pursued with vigour where the facts clearly show sexual assault and violence. But equally, the justice system must not be turned into a tool of vengeance when relationships fail.”
The judgment is careful to keep the other door open. Consent “may stand vitiated if it is subsequently revealed that the woman was genuinely kept in the dark entirely about the true nature of her marriage,” and “there are certainly such genuine cases where trust is betrayed and dignity is compromised”; the principle “must be guided by facts and evidence in each case, and not by mere allegations or moral presumptions.” Adults, it said, “may freely make decisions that are wise or unwise, prudent or reckless,” and “criminal law cannot be used as munitions to settle personal scores.”
Why it matters: The discharge stage, not the trial, is where the Court says a “misconception of marriage” rape charge should be tested against the complainant’s own documents, and it has now done so in a reportable judgment from a bench led by a woman judge, with the balancing passage written in. The readings of Section 376(2)(n) and of Section 420 are directly usable; so is the caution in paragraph 59, which prosecutors will cite back.
UAPA: The Foreigner’s Bail Bar Needs Proof of Illegal Entry and Does Not Touch Default Bail — Union of India v. Mohamed Rifas
Bench: Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M. Pancholi — October 27, 2026
The respondent was one of ten accused chargesheeted by the National Investigation Agency in January 2021 for a conspiracy to disturb communal harmony in Tamil Nadu and free associates in prison. He had been released on default bail under Section 167(2) of the Code on 5 July 2018, the chargesheet not having been filed in time, and no one appealed that order. In November 2019 a separate FIR was registered on his alleged confession to a Village Administrative Officer that he is a Sri Lankan national who entered India on a valid visa in 2009, overstayed, and obtained a voter card, Aadhaar and ration card; he had married in 2011 and has four children. In April 2022 the Union moved to cancel his bail for suppressing his nationality, invoking the bar in Section 43D(7) of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act on bail to foreigners who entered the country illegally. The trial court cancelled bail; the Madras High Court restored it.
In Union of India v. Mohamed Rifas @ Mohamed Rigbas, 2026 INSC 1160, the Court dismissed the Union’s appeal, with Additional Solicitor General Aishwarya Bhati appearing for it and A. Velan for the respondent. Section 43D(7), it held, has three conjunctive conditions, each to be shown prima facie by the prosecution: that the accused is charged under the Act, that he is not an Indian citizen, and that he “entered the country unauthorisedly or illegally.” The third speaks to the moment of entry. “The mere fact that subsequently, such authorization is revoked or the stay becomes illegal will not retroactively convert a lawful entry into an ‘unauthorized or illegal entry’.” The Union’s own FIR recorded entry on a valid visa. Where the three conditions are met, bail may be granted only in “very exceptional circumstances” recorded in writing, and “the burden of showing such ‘very exceptional circumstances’ will solely lie on the shoulders of the accused person”; that bar, the Court said, is “very high.” But its non-obstante clause overrides only sub-sections (5) and (6), not sub-section (2), which applies Section 167 with enlarged periods: “it does not bar the grant of statutory bail.” Cancellation of default bail after a chargesheet, under T. Gangi Reddy, needs “a special and strong ground,” and the fifteen-month delay in moving was unexplained. The Court parted from the High Court on one point: a Village Administrative Officer is not a police officer, so the confession is not hit by Section 25 of the Evidence Act and its weight is for the trial.
“Unless these conditions are satisfied, the statutory bar under Section 43D(7) cannot be invoked.”
Why it matters: This is the first detailed construction of Section 43D(7). The prosecution must prove illegal entry at the time of entry, so a visa overstayer who entered lawfully is outside the bar; and even an accused within it keeps the right to default bail, which the Court has now placed beyond the sub-section’s reach. The restatement of cancellation principles from Gurcharan Singh through Deepak Yadav to Zeba Khan is the other part of the judgment counsel will use.
Elections: “Form 6 Is for Someone Enrolling for the First Time” — the Court Questions the Delhi Revision and Issues Notice on Maharashtra’s
Bench: Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana — October 26–28, 2026
The Delhi hearing was advanced from Friday to Wednesday after Prashant Bhushan mentioned it. His clients’ point was arithmetical: about 47 lakh names on the 2026 roll are missing from the draft, and about 43 lakh of those were marked shifted or absent after a single visit, yet every one of them is told to apply afresh on Form 6, the form for a first-time elector, by 30 October. The bench put the question to the Commission’s counsel, D.S. Naidu. “Form 6 is meant for someone seeking enrolment for the first time,” the Chief Justice said; Forms 6, 7 and 8 are “cast in stone” in the rules, and the Commission’s power is only to add declarations. Justice Bagchi asked whether a voter who did not answer a notice should “forever lose the right” to be on the roll. “Instead of burdening them,” the Chief Justice asked, “why don’t you reach out to them?” The bench’s suggestions, recorded rather than ordered: accept enumeration forms or Form 8 in place of Form 6; publish the list of uncontactable electors with their earlier polling stations; issue a public notice that there is no cut-off for now, Delhi’s elections not being imminent; and “tell that Forms 6 and 8 are still welcome.” The Commission said it would consider extending the deadline and offering a separate form. The matter returns after two weeks.
Justice Bagchi also said, in the course of the hearing, that the Bihar judgment is not a precedent on the “logical discrepancy” category, which the Commission did not use there, and that its legality is undecided: it was allowed in West Bengal “as an interim arrangement.” That matters for Maharashtra, where on Monday the same bench issued notice to the Commission, the Union, the State and its Chief Electoral Officer on Arun Anandagiri’s petition, argued by Arvind Datar, that 1.22 crore deletions have been made under that head; it declined to extend the claims period or stay the final roll without hearing the Commission, and listed it for 5 November. On Tuesday the bench took the Opposition’s bundle: the Commission’s counter-affidavit, filed Monday, says every decision in the revision was unanimous and Form 6 was not amended; Abhishek Manu Singhvi, for Rahul Gandhi and the INDIA bloc, asked for the file notings and internal communications to be preserved, Menaka Guruswamy said the online form had been tampered with, and the Chief Justice said, “We know everything. We will examine.” No preservation order was made; rejoinders in ten days and the batch, including the plea to suspend the Chief Election Commissioner, is listed on 17 November. Notice issued on Dola Sen’s petition on the online Form 6 changes. In West Bengal, the Commission’s affidavit of Monday explains the 16.10 lakh appeals against inclusions as filed by officers of the Chief Electoral Officer’s office as roll authorities under the Court’s own April orders in Mostari Banu. On Friday, in a separate matter, the bench asked the Commission to act against bulk Form 7 deletion applications in Uttar Pradesh.
“Form 6 is meant for someone seeking enrolment for the first time.”
Why it matters: The Court has not yet passed the order it said it was thinking of, and the Commission has been given room to fix the form itself; but the premise of the Delhi exercise, that an existing elector omitted from the draft must apply as a newcomer, has been rejected from the bench, and the Commission’s counsel accepted that a different form will come. The “logical discrepancy” remark is the one with reach: it tells every State revision that the category survives on sufferance, and Maharashtra’s 1.22 crore deletions are the first test, on 5 November.
Tribunals: “The Tribunal Has Gone Haywire” — APTEL’s Review of a Settled Point Is Set Aside With Costs — DVC v. Maithan Alloys
Bench: Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran — October 30, 2026
For the 2009–14 tariff period the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission had allowed the Damodar Valley Corporation to recover both depreciation and its contribution to the sinking fund that redeems its bonds. The Appellate Tribunal for Electricity upheld that in May 2019, relying on the Supreme Court’s own decision in Bhaskar Shrachi Alloys v. DVC, which had upheld the same treatment for the earlier period. Nobody appealed. Maithan Alloys, which had been a party in Bhaskar Shrachi, filed a review; it sat for five years and was allowed in 2024, the Tribunal holding that its earlier bench had not considered “double benefit” and that the Corporation could claim one or the other. The Steel Authority of India intervened to support the review.
In Damodar Valley Corporation v. Maithan Alloys Ltd., 2026 INSC 1178, authored by Justice Vinod Chandran, the Court restored the 2019 order. On the merits, Section 40 of the Damodar Valley Corporation Act, 1948 requires provision for depreciation “and for reserve and other funds” before net profit is struck, a deliberate departure from ordinary accounting kept alive by the fourth proviso to Section 14 of the Electricity Act, and Regulation 43 of the 2009 Tariff Regulations makes both recoverable; Bhaskar Shrachi had considered them together; and the review petition’s own paragraph 7 conceded the point was no longer res integra. On jurisdiction, Kamal Sengupta confines review under Section 122(f) to errors apparent on the face of the record, and an error that needs “long debate and process of reasoning” is not one. The opening sentence sets the tone: “It is not often, but we do come across orders akin to the one impugned, which is in blatant breach of judicial discipline and in clear violation of Article 141 of the Constitution of India. It raises serious doubts in our minds about independence vis-à-vis accountability.” Exemplary costs of ₹2 lakh on Maithan Alloys and ₹1.5 lakh on the Steel Authority, “ill-advised” to have intervened “to add fuel to the fire,” payable within a month with 18 per cent interest on default, in addition to costs of the appeal. Vikas Singh and Abhishek Manu Singhvi appeared for the Corporation, Rajiv Shakdher for the Steel Authority.
“We cannot but observe that the Tribunal has gone haywire; we are apologetic for the expression but we find no substitute to express our angst in allowing the review, that too, when the very same issue, for the earlier years, was settled by this Court.”
Why it matters: Review before a statutory tribunal is not an appeal to a differently constituted bench, and the Court has now said so with costs, including against a public-sector undertaking that supported the exercise. The Article 141 passage, “without which there will be mayhem,” will be quoted well beyond electricity law. On substance, the Corporation’s entitlement to recover both depreciation and its Section 40 funds through tariff is closed for 2009–14 and, in reasoning, for the periods after.
Arrest: No Written Grounds, No Prejudice, No Bail — the Grounds-of-Arrest Cases Read Through Prejudice — State of Rajasthan v. Jhabra Ram
Bench: Justices M.M. Sundresh and Prasanna B. Varale — October 28, 2026
The respondent was arrested on 30 January 2026 at Jaipur on charges under Sections 3 and 9 of the Official Secrets Act and Sections 152 and 238(b) of the BNS, on intelligence that he was passing military information to Pakistani handlers through WhatsApp. He had been served notices under Section 8(1) of the Official Secrets Act before the FIR; an arrest memo setting out the material was read over in the vernacular and signed; his brother was telephoned ten minutes later; and at the remand hearing the next day his counsel opposed custody on the merits without objecting that the grounds had not been communicated, the magistrate recording that the family had been informed and the accused appeared to know why he was held. The Rajasthan High Court granted bail in May on the single ground that written grounds of arrest had not been furnished, relying on Mihir Rajesh Shah.
In State of Rajasthan v. Jhabra Ram, 2026 INSC 1169, a non-reportable judgment authored by Justice Varale, the Court set the bail aside and directed surrender within two weeks. It did not question Pankaj Bansal, Prabir Purkayastha or Mihir Rajesh Shah; it found “substantial and effective compliance” on the record at five stages, and applied the prejudice test from State of Karnataka v. Sri Darshan: the absence of written grounds does not of itself make an arrest illegal “absent demonstrable prejudice.” Grounds, under Kasireddy Upender Reddy and Vihaan Kumar, need to be enough to let the arrestee seek bail or habeas corpus and prepare a defence, not the full case. The High Court had “treated an alleged procedural irregularity as an automatic ground for grant of regular bail, while completely ignoring the gravity of the offences.”
“A hyper-technical objection regarding the form or mode of communicating grounds of arrest cannot be treated as a self-executing, blanket key to unlock regular bail, bypassing the core parameters governing bail jurisprudence.”
Why it matters: For a year the grounds-of-arrest cases have been the defence bar’s most reliable route to release. This judgment, though non-reportable, is the clearest statement yet that for regular bail the question is prejudice, and that a detailed, signed arrest memo plus an unobjected remand will usually answer it. It sits uneasily with Mihir Rajesh Shah’s two-hour written-grounds rule, which it does not overrule; a larger bench will have to say which governs. Read with Nagpur’s Ferreira award this week, the remedy for a defective arrest is moving towards compensation after the fact rather than release during trial.
Criminal Procedure: A Rape Case Cannot Be Quashed on a Compromise, and the Court Hears the Victim First — Gopal Lodhi v. State of M.P.
Bench: Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran — October 26, 2026
The petitioner had come for anticipatory bail in a case under Sections 64(1), 331(2) and 351(3) of the BNS and the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act. On 3 September his senior counsel, Warisha Farasat, told the Court that the matter had been compromised and that the Madhya Pradesh High Court had quashed the complaint under its inherent powers. The bench, “slightly perturbed” that a rape case had been quashed on a settlement, called for the High Court’s record and the compromise, issued notice to the victim with legal aid, and then had her produced by video conference from the District Legal Services Authority at Rajgarh so that it could speak to her directly.
In Gopal Lodhi v. State of M.P., 2026 INSC 1164, the Court recorded what she said: “the victim in the same breath says that she was coerced into settlement, that she is not ready for a settlement and that she requires money for settlement.” Its September order had already gone through the decisions the High Court relied on, Madan Mohan Abbot, Jagdish Chanana, Shiji, Narinder Singh, Anita Maria Dias and Gian Singh, and found that each concerned a personal, civil or commercial dispute and that the three-judge bench in Gian Singh had excluded murder, rape and dacoity from compromise-quashing in terms; Shambhu Kharwar quashed a rape case because the allegations themselves showed consent, not because of a settlement. Quashing a non-compoundable rape case on a compromise alone “would be stepping outside the jurisdiction under Section 482 that too in violation of the power conferred under Section 320.” The Court set aside the quashing order, “though not directly concerned with it,” directed the trial to proceed, and, treating the bail question separately, granted the petitioner anticipatory bail on the trial court’s conditions.
“We are not only concerned with the settlements which could be arrived at on coercion by the accused but also apprehensive of the multiplicity of such false complaints being made, with the lure of a future settlement being arrived it.”
Why it matters: The law was settled in Gian Singh; what is new is the method. The Court did not take the compromise at face value even from senior counsel, and interviewed the complainant through the legal services authority before deciding. High Courts asked to quash sexual-offence cases on settlement now have both a reminder of the rule and a procedure for testing voluntariness, and petitioners should expect the quashing to be undone even in a proceeding that was only about bail.
Drug Pricing: “Can You Show Any Justification for This Loot?” — the Court Reserves Orders on Margins Beyond Cancer Drugs
Bench: Justices Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta — October 27, 2026
The 30 per cent trade-margin cap on 137 anti-cancer drugs, gazetted on 17 October with revised prices from 9 November, came back before the bench with the Centre’s affidavit on hospital margins of “170% to 700% or more.” Additional Solicitor General Aishwarya Bhati appeared for the Union, Mukul Rohatgi for the hospitals and the petitioner, Kishan Chand Jain, in person. The bench put the retail figures on the record: a cancer injection with a price-to-retailer of ₹11,000 sold at ₹1.3 lakh; a drip line bought at ₹15 and sold at ₹250. It asked why the rationalisation stops at cancer drugs, floated a uniform cap of about 16 per cent over the price to the retailer for all non-patented medicines, and, when told that India’s medicine costs are among the lowest in the world, said: “Don’t go into lowest cost.” Of the National Pharmaceutical Pricing Authority, Justice Mehta said, “Your body seems to be defunct, with due respect.” Rohatgi proposed an expert committee. The order is reserved; written submissions in two weeks.
“Don’t take it as a commerce. Treat it as a life of the poorest person of this country.”
Why it matters: The Court has moved from asking the Authority to act on cancer drugs to asking why the Drugs (Prices Control) Order’s paragraph 19 power should not be used across non-scheduled medicines. A reserved order on that question, with a figure already floated from the bench, is a different thing from the monitoring it has done so far, and manufacturers, distributors and hospital chains will want their submissions in before the two weeks run.
Banking: Banks Must Indemnify Digital-Arrest Victims Where Their Diligence Failed, the Court Tells the Reserve Bank
Bench: Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana — October 28–29, 2026
The suo motu matter (SMW (Crl) 3/2025) sat twice. On Wednesday the Chief Justice called the scheme “prima facie digital dacoity,” said those who target senior citizens should be punished “even before trial if the law allows,” heard the amicus on a ₹2.5 crore loss, and refused an accused’s application to club more than thirty cases. On Thursday the bench turned to the Reserve Bank’s draft KYC Amendment Directions, 2026, the instrument that is to carry the mule-account provisions, and directed that they must require a bank to indemnify a victim of cyber fraud in a sum “not less than equivalent to the amount lost” where the bank’s due diligence failed. The Reserve Bank is to file a list of authorised institutions; the Union a compliance affidavit.
Why it matters: The draft Directions, out for comment since September with an effective date of April 2027, now carry a court-dictated term, and it is a liability rule rather than a process rule. If it survives into the final text, the question in every digital-arrest case will be whether the receiving bank’s onboarding and transaction monitoring met the standard, with the bank paying if not. Banks’ compliance and litigation functions should read the Thursday order together.
Arbitration: Section 29A Extensions Go to the “Court,” Not the Appointing High Court — South Bihar Power Distribution v. India Power
Bench: Justices Ujjal Bhuyan and Atul S. Chandurkar — October 28, 2026
A distribution franchise agreement for Bodhgaya provided for three arbitrators. When disputes arose the franchisee’s special purpose vehicle went to the Patna High Court under Section 11, and a sole arbitrator was appointed with the licensee’s consent; the licensee filed counter-claims, consented to a replacement sole arbitrator and to an extension of time, and only when a further extension was sought did it object that the clause required three. The High Court found waiver, held that the vehicle, by then in insolvency, had standing, and extended the mandate itself under Section 29A. The licensee appealed, C.A. Sundaram and Raju Ramachandran appearing for the appellants and Atmaram Nadkarni for the franchisee.
In South Bihar Power Distribution Company Ltd. v. India Power Corporation Ltd., 2026 INSC 1165, the Court affirmed the first two holdings and set aside the third. Participation before a court-appointed sole arbitrator, counter-claims and consent to extensions are acquiescence under Sections 4 and 16(2), following Union of India v. Pam Development. The moratorium under Section 14 of the Insolvency Code “is intended to prohibit debt recovery action against the corporate debtor”; it “would not impair any claim by the corporate debtor, such as, an arbitral claim, which if successful, would only bolster the financial health” of the company. But the power to extend a tribunal’s mandate under Section 29A(4) belongs to the “court” defined in Section 2(1)(e), the principal civil court of original jurisdiction or a High Court with ordinary original civil jurisdiction; under the three-judge decision in State of West Bengal v. Associated Contractors, the Chief Justice or designate acting under Section 11 is not that court, and the Section 11 jurisdiction is exhausted once the tribunal is constituted. The error did not change the outcome because the District Judge at Patna had already extended the mandate in March on the Court’s direction. The embargo on the award was lifted; the arbitrator is to pass it within six weeks.
Why it matters: In every State whose High Court lacks ordinary original civil jurisdiction, Patna among them, the Section 29A application goes to the District Judge or Commercial Court even though the High Court appointed the arbitrator; filing in the wrong forum is a jurisdictional defect, not an irregularity. The insolvency holding is the useful one for resolution professionals: the moratorium is a shield for the debtor, not a bar on its own recoveries, and a committee-approved authorisation is enough to carry on.
Income Tax: No Section 143(2) Notice, No Reassessment — PCIT v. Orissa Mining Corporation, With Two More Tax Rulings
Bench: Justices Sanjay Kumar and Sanjeev Sachdeva — October 28, 2026
Orissa Mining Corporation and an individual assessee had been assessed under Section 143(3) and then reopened under Section 147. In response to the Section 148 notices one asked that its original return be treated as the return, the other refiled the same return; the Assessing Officer then proceeded with Section 142(1) notices and framed the reassessments without ever issuing a notice under Section 143(2). The Commissioner (Appeals) held that participation cured the omission; the Tribunal and the Orissa High Court disagreed.
In Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, Bhubaneswar v. Orissa Mining Corporation Ltd., 2026 INSC 1171, authored by Justice Sachdeva, the Court dismissed the Revenue’s appeals on all three questions it framed. Section 292BB deems service, timeliness and manner of service of a notice the Revenue claims to have issued; “where the Revenue itself contends that no notice was sent, as required under the Act, the provision of Section 292BB will have no applicability,” following Laxman Das Khandelwal. An assessee who adopts its earlier return as the response to a Section 148 notice is bound by it, but that does not relieve the Revenue of its obligation to call for evidence under Section 143(2). And a Section 142(1) letter issued after proceedings have begun “would not cover up the lacuna in the proceedings and would not validate what is non est.”
Two further rulings this week mark the other edge of the reopening power. In Chetan Sabharwal v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, 2026 INSC 1163 (Justices Pardiwala and Vinod Chandran, 28 October; Mukul Rohatgi for the appellants, Nisha Bagchi with Additional Solicitor General K.M. Nataraj for the Revenue), the Court upheld Section 148 notices to the sons of a former Chief Justice over the 2007 sale of shares in two companies for ₹255 crore and a Section 54F claim on a Delhi property: an investigation report prepared after the assessment is tangible material with a live link to the belief; “the only question at the stage of issuing notice is whether there was relevant and credible material on which a reasonable person could have formed the requisite belief”; a Section 143(1) intimation is not an assessment, and a Section 143(3) order that accepts the return without discussing the point founds no change of opinion. The judgment consolidates eleven principles on “reason to believe” and five on change of opinion for the pre-2021 regime. And in Lakshmi Sugar Mills Co. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Delhi-II, 2026 INSC 1162 (Justices Bhatti and Anjaria, 27 October), the Court set aside a Delhi High Court order that had added back ₹69.92 lakh of unpaid excise duty on uncleared sugar under Section 43B: the assessee had never claimed it as a deduction, the stock remained in the bonded warehouse, and “disallowing an amount not treated as an allowance by the Assessee is impermissible under the Act, 1961.”
“A notice under section 143(2) of the Act is sine qua non for a proceeding for reassessment under Section 147 of the Act.”
Why it matters: The three escape routes the Revenue has used to defend a reassessment without a Section 143(2) notice are closed, and the objection can be raised on appeal after full participation. Sabharwal is the counterweight, a checklist that will be cited in every writ against a pre-2021 notice, and most of its principles favour the Revenue at the notice stage. Lakshmi Sugar is a short reminder that Section 43B disallows deductions claimed, not auditor’s remarks.
Electricity: Theft Disconnections Get the Section 126 Procedure, and Reconnection on Half the Demand — Dakshin Gujarat Vij Co.
Bench: Justices Manoj Misra and K.V. Viswanathan — October 26, 2026
Two Gujarat distribution licensees had disconnected consumers for theft and raised supplementary bills. The Gujarat High Court ordered restoration on deposit of half the provisionally assessed amount, with the consumer permitted to object, the Executive Engineer to decide in three weeks and an appeal under Section 127 to lie; in the second matter it remanded for a fresh order. The licensees argued that assessment for theft under Section 135(1A) is distinct from assessment for unauthorised use under Section 126, carries no right of objection or appeal, and is subject only to the Special Court’s determination of civil liability under Section 154(5); half the bill was too lenient a price for reconnection. Senior Advocate Ranjit Kumar appeared for the licensees, Raghenth Basant for the consumers.
In Dakshin Gujarat Vij Company Ltd. v. Vaibhav Metal Crusher, 2026 INSC 1157, the Court dismissed both appeals and, at paragraph 37, stated the law in three propositions. For restoration under the third proviso to Section 135(1A), “the assessed amount” is, absent a specific procedure in the Supply Code notified under Section 181(2)(x) read with Section 50, to be determined by the same procedure as applies to unauthorised use under Section 126, with its provisional order, objection and hearing; the Act has no other assessment machinery and names no assessing officer for theft, and the Gujarat Code uses one formula for both. That amount is subject to appeal under Section 127, but in a theft case the appellate finding is final only for restoration and does not bind the Special Court under Section 154(5); any excess over the civil liability the Special Court finally fixes is refundable under Section 154(6). West Bengal SEDCL v. Orion Metal governs. Theft “undoubtedly would include unauthorized use of electricity, though every unauthorized use of electricity may not constitute theft”; the proviso is “an emergency provision” for a consumer cut off from “a commodity essential for all aspects of life including business.” On Article 226, constitutional power “cannot be totally circumscribed by statutory provisions,” but theft involves mens rea, “adoption of a liberal approach may not be appropriate,” and a High Court may refuse restoration until the full provisional demand is paid; where the provisional assessment is prima facie arbitrary it may, for recorded reasons, order restoration on payment of a sum “which should not be less than 50%,” the floor drawn from Section 127(2).
“In short, a circumspect approach is required while dealing with petitions seeking restoration of supply of electricity disconnected on ground of theft.”
Why it matters: In every State whose Supply Code has no separate theft-assessment procedure, a consumer disconnected for theft is entitled to the Section 126 objection and hearing and a Section 127 appeal before paying for reconnection; the licensee cannot demand the whole supplementary bill as the price of supply. Writ practice now has a stated floor and a stated condition, half the demand and a finding of prima facie arbitrariness, and restoration orders should reserve both the appeal and the Special Court’s determination.
Criminal Justice: ₹6 Lakh for Six Years in Custody on “a Concocted Story,” and the Judgment Goes to the DGP — Arun @ Deepak v. State of U.P.
Bench: Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran — October 26, 2026
The petitioner had been in custody since November 2019 in a kidnapping-and-murder case from Agra in which he was named in no FIR or witness statement and was arrayed on CCTV footage and a co-accused’s confession. In March the Court, hearing his bail petition, noted six years’ custody in a wholly circumstantial case and directed the trial to be completed in three months. He was acquitted. The Court then called for the hundred-page Hindi judgment, had it translated, and examined what the investigation had been. The prosecution examined six witnesses. The “ransom demand” surfaced for the first time in court. The confessions were to the police. The CCTV footage and the call records came without certificates under Section 65B and no attempt was made to identify the SIM subscribers. Bones recovered were never identified as the deceased’s, the DNA result was not produced and the complainant’s sample was never taken, though the radiologist said it was needed. The recoveries were from the co-accused’s house with no statement under Section 27, and the complainant said the police led everyone to the spot.
In Arun @ Deepak v. State of U.P., 2026 INSC 1150, authored by Justice Vinod Chandran, the Court called it “a classic case of how an investigation should not be proceeded with.” It directed the State to pay ₹6 lakh within a month, with 18 per cent interest on default, and sent the judgment to the Director General of Police and the Home Secretary. “The State Police would do well to educate their officers in the process of investigation,” it said; “six years have been erased from the life of a man on the strength of a concocted story built on mere surmises and conjectures.” Investigators “should recognize themselves to be essential stakeholders in the justice delivery system, ensuring justice, not only to the victim, the de facto complainant and the injured but also to the accused.”
Why it matters: A bail petition that had become infructuous was used to award reparation to an acquitted undertrial, with an interest clause and a direction to the police chief, and the judgment is reportable. The paragraph-by-paragraph list of what was missing, Section 65B certificates, Section 27 statements, DNA identification, inquest witnesses, is a cross-examination template for any circumstantial case, and the compensation is a precedent for the next one.
RTI: Co-operative Records the Registrar “Can Access” Are Information, and No Inquiry Need Precede Access — Muppathadam Service Co-op Bank
Bench: Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran — October 26, 2026
A member of a Kerala service co-operative bank asked the Joint Registrar of Co-operative Societies, under the Right to Information Act, for two documents the bank held: its construction agreement with a labour co-operative and the minutes of its last general body meeting. The bank relied on Thalappalam, which holds that co-operative societies are not public authorities, and argued that the Registrar can reach a society’s records only after recording satisfaction to hold an inquiry under Section 65 of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act; it also pleaded the exemptions for commercial confidence and personal information. The State Information Commission and the Kerala High Court, in two rounds, ordered disclosure.
In Muppathadam Service Co-operative Bank Ltd. v. State Chief Information Commissioner, 2026 INSC 1153, authored by Justice Vinod Chandran, the Court dismissed the appeals, Senior Advocate S.P. Chaly appearing for the bank and the member in person. Section 2(f) covers “information relating to any private body which can be accessed by a public authority under any other law,” and the words “refers to access being statutorily provided. The power cannot be fettered at all.” Thalappalam itself preserves the Registrar’s right to seek information from societies under his supervision and pass it to an applicant, subject to Section 8(1). Under Section 65 an inquiry may be suo motu or on an application, and sub-section (2) gives the Registrar free access to a society’s books; since the satisfaction whether to inquire cannot be formed “in a vacuum,” “access simpliciter, thus cannot be conditioned with a prior satisfaction, since without such access, the Registrar cannot enter upon a satisfaction.” Section 66 independently confers inspection powers exercisable as often as the Registrar thinks necessary. The exemptions failed: the bid was over and the contract concerns every member; and as between a society and its member, a contract and general body minutes are not personal information, though “the position would definitely be different if a third party not connected with the Society raises an identical request.” The Joint Registrar is to obtain and supply the documents within two weeks.
Why it matters: This is the working route around Thalappalam. A member cannot apply to the society, but can apply to the Registrar, who cannot say no inquiry is pending; and the same “can be accessed” reasoning reaches any regulator with statutory inspection powers over a private body. The express caveat about strangers to the society is the line both sides will argue next.
Land Acquisition: Fraud Reopens an Acquisition Closed by a Division Bench and an SLP Dismissal — N. Arasappa v. State of Karnataka
Bench: Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran — October 26, 2026
Fifty-nine acres at Nelakadiranahalli, north of Bengaluru, were acquired in 1988–92 for a house-building co-operative, the Karnataka Gruha Nirmana Sahakara Sangha. Three days before the 1984 amendment that made co-operative housing a public purpose under Section 3(f)(vi) of the Land Acquisition Act, the society had signed an agreement with a firm called Bhagya Enterprises under which the firm undertook to get the land acquired, for a fee per square foot payable in tranches keyed to the Section 4, Section 5A and Section 6 stages. A statutory inquiry had found gross irregularities, including admissions that bribes were paid to acquisition officers. An earlier challenge by other owners had failed before a Division Bench in Karithimmaiah in 2002, and the special leave petition was dismissed. The present owners, still in possession, petitioned in 2007 when they were first disturbed; a Single Judge quashed the acquisition for fraud, the Division Bench reversed on delay and res judicata.
In N. Arasappa v. State of Karnataka, 2026 INSC 1151, authored by Justice Vinod Chandran, the Court restored the Single Judge. Senior Advocates Kiran Suri and Basava Prabhu Patil appeared for the owners, Vikas Singh for the society and Sanjay Hegde for the State. The dismissal of a special leave petition against Karithimmaiah “does not have the sheen of a precedent of this Court” under Kunhayammed; the agreement and the Government file, which showed the fraud, were never before that bench; and the line, under Chengalvaraya Naidu and Papayya Sastry, “is between mistake and trickery; the former leading to a wrong decision but the later resulting in a decision which would not at all have been rendered, if the Court was not misled.” The approval of the Government under Section 3(f)(vi) “is not of the mere requisition made, by a Cooperative Society. It should be for the scheme; not one in contemplation but, forma et descriptio (the layout and the blueprint)”; here there was none, and a 2007 layout agreement proved it. The milestone-linked fee in the Bhagya Enterprises agreement was “a sure manifestation of the attempted fraud,” of the kind condemned in the HMT House Building line and Bangalore City Co-operative. The file showed the society had paid ₹19.60 lakh directly to owners, against the proviso to Section 6(1), and that no award existed when one was said to have been passed. “‘Fraud vitiates all solemn acts’ is a principle which cannot be reduced to providing a mere lip service.” Costs were raised to ₹50,000 per petitioner, the contempt direction against the officers dropped for lapse of time, and the restitution follows HMT v. Syed Khader: possession back to every owner, whether or not they sued, against refund of the Government’s compensation without interest; the society has no claim; plots no owner can resume are to be auctioned under a District Judge’s supervision, with the proceeds applied to victim compensation at the Chief Justice’s direction.
Why it matters: The Bengaluru housing-society acquisitions of the 1980s and 1990s have a long litigation tail, and this reopens it: a fraud-based challenge survives delay and an earlier Division Bench ruling on the same notification where the fraud material was not before that court, and the dismissal of a special leave petition settles nothing. For acquisition practice, a Section 3(f)(vi) approval must be of an actual layout, and a middleman’s fee schedule tied to statutory milestones is itself evidence of a colourable exercise of power.
Civil Procedure: A Stranger to a Consent Decree May Appeal With Leave, and Limitation Runs From Knowledge — Girishbhai Patel, With Balakrishna
Bench: Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran — October 30, 2026; Justices Sanjay Kumar and Sanjeev Sachdeva — October 26, 2026
A housing society sued the heirs of a former owner of Ahmedabad land for specific performance of a 1996 agreement and took a consent decree in April 2013. Six weeks before the suit the heirs had given a power of attorney to the appellant, who filed the defendants’ vakalatnama and, the record suggests, had chaired the society a decade earlier. Execution was sought only in 2020, and in June 2022 a Court Commissioner conveyed the land to the appellant with the society as confirming party. The Palkhiwala family, who claim under a registered sale of 1975 and were strangers to the suit, found the conveyance in the revenue records in 2023 and filed a first appeal alleging fraud and collusion, with applications for leave, condonation and injunction. The Gujarat High Court granted all three; the appellant said Section 96(3) of the Code and Order XXIII Rules 3 and 3A barred any appeal against a compromise decree.
In Girishbhai Natwarlal Patel v. Gautam Punjabhai Palkhiwala, 2026 INSC 1177, authored by Justice Pardiwala, the Court dismissed the appeals. The bar in Section 96(3) rests on the binding effect of the compromise between the parties to it; Pushpa Devi Bhagat and R. Rajanna speak to their remedies, and Triloki Nath Singh was a case where the appellant traced title through a party. “A stranger to a compromise decree cannot be said to be barred under Section 96(3) read Order XXIII Rule 3 & Rule 3A,” because those provisions “act as an estoppel only with respect to” the parties. Nor does a non-party have an unrestricted right: leave is required on the ordinary test for a person aggrieved, a legally cognisable interest prejudicially affected, under V.N. Krishna Murthy and H. Anjanappa, and “the fact that the decree in question is a consent decree neither dispenses with this requirement nor, in itself, constitutes a bar to the grant of leave.” Eleven years’ delay was properly condoned because time cannot be reckoned against strangers from the decree’s date “without examining when and in what circumstances they acquired, or could reasonably have acquired, knowledge.” The ex parte injunction was sustainable where impleadment could not precede leave and the appellant was heard before it was continued. All findings are prima facie; the High Court is to decide the appeal in three months. Anshin Desai appeared for the appellant, Mihir Thakore and Megha Jani for the family.
The companion ruling is on the other side of the decree. In Balakrishna (Dead) through LRs v. G.N. Kanniah Naidu, 2026 INSC 1155, authored by Justice Sanjay Kumar, a decree-holder with a 1999 declaration of title to a Bengaluru site, obtained on a photocopy of a 1972 allotment, met an objector in execution who produced the original allotment of the same date in his own name and had built a two-storey house with three shops on the plot, as the decree-holder admitted in cross-examination. The executing court and the Karnataka High Court sent him to file a separate suit. The Court held that an application under Order XXI Rules 97 to 101 “is on par with a regular suit,” appealable as a first appeal, and that Rule 101 bars the separate suit the High Court had directed, “in utter derogation of the mandate” of the rule; knowledge of a suit “filed without impleading the person who claims to be in possession” cannot be imputed to him; and “tax payments, at best, could lead to an inference only as to possession but not title.” The objector’s heirs were declared owners and the 1999 decree itself was set aside.
Why it matters: Between them the two judgments settle who may attack a decree they were not party to and where. A stranger whose title is affected by a collusive consent decree appeals it under Section 96 with leave, on the person-aggrieved test, with limitation from knowledge; a stranger in possession resists execution under Order XXI Rule 97 and gets a full trial of title there, not in a fresh suit. Both are reportable, and both arose from land fraud of the ordinary kind.
Service Law: A Notified Operation Attracts War Injury Pension Unless the Notification Says Otherwise — Union of India v. Narender Kumar
Bench: Justices Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Alok Aradhe — October 28, 2026
A soldier posted at Kargil in Operation Rakshak in 2003–05 was diagnosed there with rheumatoid arthritis, and on discharge in 2013 the Release Medical Board found his disabilities aggravated by service at 75 per cent for life. He received disability pension. Six years later he claimed War Injury Pension under Category E(i) of the Ministry of Defence’s policy letter of 31 January 2001, which covers disability in “operations specially notified by the Govt.” The Armed Forces Tribunal and the Punjab and Haryana High Court allowed the claim. The Ministry appealed, Additional Solicitor General Archana Pathak Dave arguing that Operation Rakshak is not such an operation.
In Union of India v. Narender Kumar, 2026 INSC 1166, the Court dismissed the appeal. “Going by the plain language of the Policy, once a notification is issued for a specific operation, Category E(i) is invoked, unless there is something indicative either in the Policy or in the notification so issued”; the Ministry’s only basis for excluding Operation Rakshak was its counsel’s statement. “The primary burden lies on the policymaker to demonstrate the circumstances in which the benefit would accrue or not accrue.” Where the language of a pensionary policy is unrestrictive, “it is not the burden of the Court to limit its application through an interpretative process.” The Court declined to rely on paragraph 44 of Army Order 1 of 2003, which “causes more confusion than it clarifies,” and directed that in future, when notifying an operation under Category E(i), the Government “must declare in clear terms” whether the benefit applies. It also said, not for the first time, that “it is high time that the MoD issues a comprehensive and clearly identifiable subordinate legislation governing the services.”
Why it matters: Until the Ministry rewrites its notifications, every Government-notified operation attracts Category E(i), and a disease contracted during the posting can qualify as a war injury. Counsel before the Tribunal’s benches will read across to Operation Rhino and the other notified operations; the Ministry has been told where the drafting burden lies.
Environment: No Blanket Ban, “Our Orders Are Violated More Than They Are Obeyed,” and the Firecracker Order Is Reserved Nine Days Before Diwali
Bench: Justices M.M. Sundresh and Prasanna B. Varale — October 29, 2026
The Delhi-NCR air-pollution matter came up on Thursday with the Diwali question. The amicus said green crackers are lower-emission but not pollution-free. The bench was not inclined to a complete ban: “our orders are violated more than they are obeyed,” and a prohibition no one enforces is “an academic exercise.” Justice Varale asked for enforcement data after last year’s relaxation; none had been filed. Only nine of Delhi’s thirty-nine monitoring stations were working. The bench sought compliance reports on raids and illegal stockpiles, suggested that public figures, Virat Kohli among them, record awareness messages and that schools be involved, and told the authorities to file affidavits on their measures and difficulties. The order was reserved, to be passed “within a couple of days”; nothing had been pronounced by Saturday. The Central Pollution Control Board’s barium report was not mentioned. In a different matter on Wednesday, Justice Vikram Nath remarked that “post-Diwali Delhi will be very bad” and that judges cannot stay home to escape it.
Why it matters: The Court has said, in terms, that it will not issue an order it cannot see enforced, which is a change from the Arjun Gopal years. Whatever the reserved order says about green crackers and timings, the operative part for the police and the pollution boards is the compliance reporting; the Bombay High Court’s parallel orders on Mumbai are in the High Courts section.
Other Notable SC Orders This Week
- Consecutive life sentences (October 27) — in Raju Shantaram Koli v. State of Maharashtra, 2026 INSC 1161, Justices K.V. Viswanathan and Arun Palli applied the Constitution Bench in Muthuramalingam: life sentences for Section 302 and Section 376 read with 342 imposed in a single trial “cannot be directed to run consecutively”; they are superimposed, so remission of one does not of itself remit the other. The Bombay High Court’s confirmation of the consecutive direction was set aside.
- Textile cess (October 26) — in Assessing Officer, Textiles Committee v. Premium Suiting, 2026 INSC 1158, Justices S.V.N. Bhatti and N.V. Anjaria held that “manufacture” in Section 5A of the Textiles Committee Act cannot be borrowed from the Central Excise Act, and that a job worker who bleaches and dyes handloom or powerloom fabric and returns it “only works as an extended arm for the manufacturers” and attracts no cess.
- Disproportionate assets (October 28) — in V. Gopalakrishnan v. State of Kerala, 2026 INSC 1172, Justices Sanjay Kumar and Sanjeev Sachdeva upheld a former Sub-Registrar’s conviction, taking every defence adjustment on a demurrer and finding the disproportion still above 26 per cent of income; “law does not cast an impossible burden upon the prosecution to negate every hypothetical source,” and a private notebook is not an account kept in the ordinary course.
- Suspension of sentence (October 27) — in Hanuman Prasad @ Hanuta Ram v. State of Rajasthan, 2026 INSC 1180, Justices Pardiwala and Vinod Chandran cancelled the suspension of sentence granted to the alleged mastermind of a sarpanch candidate’s murder, who had served four months, while leaving the co-accused on bail because the key witnesses had turned hostile: a High Court must engage with the evidence prima facie, and release “cannot be a knee jerk reaction to the pendency, the burden of which is more on the citizen than on the Courts.”
- Miyapur (October 29) — in Bandari Ramchander v. Maitri Co-operative Housing Society, 2026 INSC 1175, Justices M.M. Sundresh and Satish Chandra Sharma dismissed twenty appeals over about 550 acres at Miyapur, Hyderabad: “a grant of jagir is not to be misconstrued as one of title over the property”; everything vested in the State on abolition in 1949; post-vesting pahani entries without a transfer order “constitute an act of nullity.”
- Rewriting the contract (October 29) — in Shreeram Builders v. Upendra Kantilal Thanawala, 2026 INSC 1176, Justices Sanjay Kumar and Sachdeva affirmed the Bombay High Court’s setting aside, under Section 37, of a majority award that had ordered specific performance of a 2003 Thane development agreement at six times the contractual rate, before the contractual precondition of full payment, over property the agreement excluded; the arbitrators “completely supplanted them with new terms, as per their own fancies.” Under Article 142 the owners must refund all sums with 9 per cent interest.
- Execution of awards (October 28) — in Royal Construction Co. v. National Projects Construction Corporation, 2026 INSC 1167, Justices Vikram Nath, Sandeep Mehta and Aparesh Kumar Singh refused to let the Delhi High Court relegate execution questions on a 2002 award to the Supreme Court as a “clarification” of its 2023 judgment, and requested the Law Commission to study the enforcement framework for arbitral awards: “the promise of arbitration remains unfulfilled if a party, having traversed the arbitral process, is compelled to embark upon another protracted course of litigation.”
- A settlement without a ruling (October 26) — in Atibir Industries v. State Bank of India, 2026 INSC 1156, the Chief Justice, Justices Bagchi and Mohana, in a judgment authored by Justice Mohana, closed a ₹400 crore dispute by directing the borrower to pay a further ₹125 crore to the asset reconstruction company that bought the loan, on top of ₹250 crore already paid, as full and final settlement, accepting a report by Justice Anil R. Dave (retired) with modification; the validity of the retrospective NPA classification and of the assignment during the writ are expressly left open, and the Court said it is “not only the Court of law but also a Court of equity.”
- Moneylenders in Maharashtra (October 29) — in Mansi Finance (Chennai) v. M. Lalitha, 2026 INSC 1174, Justices Prashant Kumar Mishra and Anjaria declined to “clarify” their May judgment but recorded that under the Maharashtra Money-Lending (Regulation) Act a promissory-note loan by an unlicensed lender is not a legally enforceable debt for Section 138, and the lender “has to produce a licence to satisfy the Court at the threshold.”
- Wakf (October 26) — in A.P. State Wakf Board v. Syed Masood Ahmed, 2026 INSC 1152, Justices Pardiwala and Vinod Chandran restored an injunction decree over inam land at Shamsabad: an unchallenged 1968 survey report and 1989 notification settle title for an injunction simpliciter, and Anathula Sudhakar does not force a declaratory suit.
- Andhra nominations (October 27) — the YSR Congress Party matter returned before the Chief Justice’s bench with the Election Commission’s compliance; the Court declined “a fishing or roving inquiry” into the obstruction allegations, left them to election petitions, said a detailed order would follow with CCTV directions for all elections, and disposed of the plea: “Now contest the elections, all the best.” Polling was on 1 November.
- Lakhimpur Kheri (October 26) — Ashish Mishra was permitted to visit his family for Diwali, to return by 16 November; the State said a Special Public Prosecutor had been appointed. “There should not be a tearing hurry, but there also should not be prolonged delay.”
- Shiv Sena (October 27–28) — the Shinde side argued that the disqualification petitions are infructuous with the Assembly’s term over; the Commission’s own submissions on the symbol did not resume, and the matter was not taken on Thursday. The connected plea against the Lok Sabha Speaker’s recognition of the merger is listed for final disposal in December after the Speaker did not appear.
- CAPF cadre review (October 28) — Justices Misra and Bhuyan, having read the Ministry’s files, said “we see that they are in violation” of the direction in Sanjay Prakash; the Centre undertook to submit the cadre-review proposal by 30 November, force-wise IPS deputation figures were sought, and the matter is on 9 December.
- West Bengal (October 28–29) — the CBI withdrew about twenty petitions to transfer the 2021 post-poll violence cases out of the State, “owing to changed circumstances”; a bench led by Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra reserved judgment on the Enforcement Directorate’s Article 32 petition for a CBI investigation of the I-PAC search, asking why the new State government had not itself handed the case over.
- Mentioned and listed — notice to the Centre on two fresh writs against the six-stanza Vande Mataram orders, tagged with T.M. Krishna, all on 30 November (October 27); notice to Rahul Gandhi on a journalist’s application alleging she was pushed at the Registry on 12 October (October 27); notice on the Digital News Publishers’ challenge to the Data Protection Act (October 27); the Centre given four weeks for a policy regime on child sexual abuse material and non-consensual intimate imagery (October 27); the MeitY told to add penalties to its draft policy on unauthorised clips of court proceedings, with YouTubers to seek the Secretary General’s permission before monetising (October 30); the Khurram Parvez bail challenge dismissed (Justices Sundresh and Varale, October 30); the Reliance–Government KG basin dispute sent to mediation before Justice Ranjana Desai (retired) (October 30); review petitions against the online rummy and poker ruling dismissed (October 28); Anil Tuteja’s bail left undisturbed, “suspicion must be converted into a full-proof evidence” (October 29); a Karnataka Lokayukta Superintendent’s anticipatory bail cancelled, “a member of a uniformed service cannot claim parity with a layman” (Justices Sanjay Kumar and Sachdeva, October 29); Anant Singh to surrender by 1 December (October 30); Siddique Kappan’s passport plea to 2 November; the Court inclined to frame principles on compulsory rural service for medical graduates (October 27); the Union to revisit the acid-attack guidelines (October 27); Rajasthan warned of a CBI inquiry into the regularisation of mining on the Jojari (October 26); the remaining Maharashtra zilla parishad polls to proceed under the interim arrangement (October 29); Mahua Moitra’s plea for public disclosure of beneficial owners of funds declined (October 29); the Sohrabuddin matter, listed for 28 October, produced no report.
From the High Courts
Anti-Corruption: Kerala Holds the Vijayan Investigation in Abeyance for Four Weeks, With the FIRs Intact — Pinarayi Vijayan v. K.M. Shajahan (Division Bench)
Bench: Justices K. Natarajan and Johnson John (Kerala High Court) — October 26, 2026
The Supreme Court’s special bench had sent the former Chief Minister, his daughter Veena T. and his son-in-law P.A. Mohammed Riyas back to the Division Bench that had refused them leave to appeal on 15 October, with the vigilance investigation stayed for ten days so that they could ask it for protection. On Monday, the Court’s first working day after Dussehra, the same Division Bench took the restored appeals against Justice A. Badharudeen’s 9 October direction to the Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau to register a case on the Enforcement Directorate’s Section 66(2) information about CMRL’s payments to Exalogic.
Senior Advocate Siddharth Luthra appeared for the former Chief Minister, N. Hariharan for Riyas, Advocate General K. Jaju Babu for the State and an Additional Solicitor General for the Directorate. The bench directed that the investigation under the two FIRs registered on 12 October be kept in abeyance for four weeks and posted the appeals to 26 November. The FIRs themselves were not stayed; the order holds the investigation, not the registration, which is the shape the Supreme Court’s order had left open to the Division Bench to “fashion independently in accordance with law.” The Directorate’s separate money-laundering case is untouched. The former Chief Minister had been summoned to Kochi for 23 October in that case; his counsel had indicated he would not attend while the Assembly was in session, and no fresh summons or any step by the Directorate was reported this week.
Why it matters: The protection the Supreme Court declined to give itself has now been given by the court it said should give it, for four weeks rather than ten days. The questions the Supreme Court flagged, whether Section 17A of the Prevention of Corruption Act and Section 175(4) of the BNSS stand in the way of a court-directed FIR against a former public servant, are now for the Division Bench on 26 November, with the investigation paused until it decides.
Religious Endowments: Madras Puts the Chidambaram Nataraja Temple Under a Board Headed by Two Former Judges
Bench: Justices G. Jayachandran and E. Manokaran (Madras High Court) — October 30, 2026
In 2014 the Supreme Court had restored the Podhu Dikshitars’ right to administer the Sabanayagar temple at Chidambaram as a religious denomination, setting aside the State’s takeover under the Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Act, while leaving the State free to act on specific instances of mismanagement. On Friday a Division Bench found that the condition on which that autonomy rested had not been met: the temple’s affairs, it held, showed maladministration since the 2014 order, with income from properties and endowments unaccounted for and unauthorised construction in the precincts.
The bench constituted a five-member Board of Management to run the temple’s secular administration, headed by two retired judges of the Court, Justices V. Bharathidasan and R.M. Suresh Kumar, with the retired IAS officer C. Rajendran and two ex-officio members. The Dikshitars keep the rituals. Income from the temple’s properties and kattalais is to be accounted for monthly, and unauthorised structures are to be removed in consultation with the Heritage Commission. The arrangement is to last, in the bench’s words, “till the ill is cured.”
Why it matters: The 2014 judgment is intact; the Court did not hand the temple back to the Endowments Department. It used the opening that judgment left, specific mismanagement proved on evidence, to put the administration under a court-appointed board while the denomination’s religious rights continue. Every denominational temple relying on Dr. Subramanian Swamy now has a template for what happens when the accounts are not kept.
Judges: No Public Meeting Whose Object Is to Target a Sitting Judge, Madras Holds — R. Karthikeyan v. Union of India
Bench: Chief Justice S.A. Dharmadhikari and Justice G. Arul Murugan (Madras High Court) — October 30, 2026
The public interest petition arose from caste-based attacks on a judge of the Court after a ruling of 25 June 2026, including public meetings and social-media campaigns directed at the judge personally. The First Bench drew the line between the judgment and the judge. Criticism of judgments is protected speech, and the Court declined any general restriction on it. But the police are not to permit a gathering whose object is to target, defame or intimidate a sitting judge, and the Cyber Crime Division is to monitor content that amounts to criminal intimidation of judges and act on it.
Why it matters: The order gives the police a standard, the object of the gathering, rather than a blanket power, and it names the agency that is to watch the online side. Counsel advising clients who organise protests against a ruling now have a clear test to meet: the judgment, not the judge.
Taxation: J&K Strikes Down Water-Usage Charges on Hydropower as a Tax on Electricity Generation the State Could Not Levy
Bench: Justices Sanjay Dhar and Rajnesh Oswal (J&K and Ladakh High Court) — October 29, 2026
The Jammu and Kashmir Water Resources (Regulation and Management) Act, 2010 imposed water-usage charges on hydroelectric projects for the water that passes through their turbines. Eleven generating companies had received demand notices. The Division Bench held that the charge, whatever its name, was in substance a tax on the generation of electricity and beyond the legislative competence of the erstwhile State: the water-resources entry is regulatory and does not carry a power to tax generation, and the adoption of the Act under the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act, 2019 could not cure a want of competence in the law adopted. The provisions were struck down to that extent and the demand notices quashed.
Why it matters: States have reached for water cess and usage charges on hydropower as a revenue head since the Supreme Court’s 2023 and 2025 rulings on mineral and other levies encouraged a look at what else might be taxed. This judgment reads such a charge by its substance, and a levy measured by the water used to generate power is, on this reasoning, a tax on generation. Expect it to be cited in Himachal, Uttarakhand and the North-East.
Arrest: Fifteen Years On, Nagpur Declares Arun Ferreira’s 2011 Arrest Illegal and Awards ₹2 Lakh
Bench: Justices Urmila Joshi-Phalke and Raj Wakode (Bombay High Court, Nagpur Bench) — October 27, 2026
Arun Ferreira was arrested outside Nagpur Central Prison on 27 September 2011, moments after his release on bail in the cases that had kept him there since 2007. The Division Bench found that the grounds of arrest were not communicated to his family or to the advocates who were present at the gate, and that the use of an unnumbered vehicle was not justified. The arrest was declared illegal. The State is to pay ₹2 lakh within eight weeks, with liberty to Ferreira to sue for more. “The punishment for such violation,” the bench said, “has to be proportionately stringent.”
Why it matters: The communication of grounds is being enforced retrospectively against arrests that pre-date Pankaj Bansal and Prabir Purkayastha, and the remedy is compensation rather than only release. Read with last week’s Bombay award of ₹5 lakh for a 2017 arrest, the Court is putting a price on the procedure.
Defamation: Calcutta Orders YouTube, X and Instagram to Take Down the Modi–Adani Documentary — Adani Enterprises v. Sabeer Bhatia
Bench: Justice Aryak Dutt (Calcutta High Court, vacation bench) — October 26, 2026
Adani Enterprises sued over a documentary on the relationship between the Prime Minister and the group, released by the entrepreneur Sabeer Bhatia, titled around the claim that the two had “stole India.” The vacation judge found the film to be a dramatised narrative rather than a news report and ordered the three platforms to take it and substantially identical copies down, with compliance affidavits in two weeks. Fair criticism of the group, the order says, is not barred; the matter returns in January 2027.
Why it matters: An ex parte takedown of political speech on an interlocutory finding that the work is “not a news report” is a wide order, and the January return date means it will stand for the better part of three months before the defence is heard. The distinction between reportage and dramatisation is doing the work here, and defendants will want to test it.
Environment: Kerala Quashes the Vizhinjam Erosion Committee for Conflict of Interest and Orders a Fresh Panel — Nirmala Johny v. State of Kerala
Bench: Justice Harisankar V. Menon (Kerala High Court) — October 30, 2026
The State had constituted an expert committee under M.D. Kudale to examine whether the Vizhinjam port had caused coastal erosion along the Thiruvananthapuram coast. The Court quashed the Government Order constituting it: the chairman had sat on the port’s own technical sub-committee, and a committee so composed could not give an independent opinion. Its report is not to be acted upon, and the State is to constitute a fresh, independent committee. The Court did not decide whether the port caused the erosion and did not halt construction.
Why it matters: The ruling is about who may sit in judgment, not what they found. Project proponents’ technical advisers cannot chair the inquiry into the project’s effects, and a report from such a committee is not evidence the State may rely on.
Other Notable High Court Orders
- Imran Khan’s “Leave India” notice (Bombay, October 26–27) — the challenge came before Chief Justice Mahesh Chandra Tripathi and Justice Advait Sethna on Monday and was adjourned at the petitioner’s request; on Tuesday the Additional Solicitor General sought time to 2 November and gave an assurance, recorded by the Court, that the notice of 14 October under Section 7(2)(c) read with Section 29 of the Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025 “will be kept in abeyance” until then. The depart-by date of 28 October has passed. A separate show-cause on his OCI card is pending. The Maharashtra Special Public Security Act challenge, the Devre detentions petition and Sachin Waze’s reserved bail appeal did not move.
- Punjab’s Chief Secretary (Punjab and Haryana, October 27) — Justice Harsh Bunger imposed ₹1 lakh costs on Chief Secretary K.P. Sinha for non-compliance with the direction to pay dearness-allowance arrears of about ₹14,191 crore, noting that the Supreme Court Registry’s defects in the State’s petition had not been cured despite the statement that it had been re-filed; a personal affidavit by 30 October and personal appearance on 3 November unless the Supreme Court protects him.
- Munnar (Kerala, October 29) — Justices Devan Ramachandran and Basant Balaji, sitting at Munnar, gave the State a week to name three officers for a Special Task Force that will supersede the Monitoring Committee on encroachments, added Village Officers to the digital survey teams, and said the Court would not tolerate “even a whispering amount of delay”; next 5 November.
- GST on legal databases (Allahabad, October 26) — Chief Justice Arun Bhansali and Justice Kshitij Shailendra dismissed at admission a public interest petition against 18 per cent GST on subscriptions to SCC Online, Manupatra and LexisNexis, on delay alone; “sudden awareness about the tax being unreasonable” was no ground, and the merits were not examined (Aniket Gupta v. Union of India, 2026:AHC:221725).
- Azam Khan (Allahabad, October 29) — Justice Samit Gopal suspended the sentences of Azam Khan and Abdullah Azam in the dual-PAN case, enhanced by the Sessions Court in May, and granted bail pending revision, but refused to stay the convictions, citing antecedents and the need to keep criminality out of electoral politics.
- Sourav Ganguly’s Doosra (Delhi, reported October 29) — Justice Tejas Karia asked the plaintiff to identify the specific portions of the film said to infringe his personality rights, directed the producers to hand over a copy and the plaintiff to file the manuscript of his book in sealed cover; the producers’ case is that he is only “a source of inspiration”; next 2 November.
- Race Course Masjid (Delhi, October 27–29) — Justice Anish Dayal issued notice on the mosque’s challenge to demolition; on Thursday the Centre said nothing would be demolished until the Waqf Board’s representation is decided within four weeks; next 16 December.
- Byju’s (Kerala, reported October 27) — a Division Bench admitted the review of its 12 June judgment, which had refused CBI, ED and NIA investigations into the insolvency, on fresh material alleging a forged GLAS Trust direction letter, but declined to stay the resolution process; the two judges differed on whether to stay the judgment under review, and one recorded that the matter had been listed out of turn.
- Firecrackers (Bombay, October 26) — Justices G.S. Kulkarni and Neela Gokhale took the affidavits of the Pollution Control Board, the Municipal Commissioner and the Police Commissioner in In re Noise and Environmental Pollution, said the State should not pay celebrities from public funds for the anti-firecracker campaign, and asked for a year-round campaign reaching slums through the SRA and ward councillors; next 19 November. The Nagpur Bench on 30 October sought the Police Commissioner’s affidavit on firecracker-seller licences by 3 November.
- Public servants under PMLA (Punjab and Haryana, reported October 30) — Justice Sumeet Goel set aside a Special Court’s cognizance of a money-laundering complaint against a public servant for want of the hearing and the superior officer’s report that Section 223(2)(b) of the BNSS requires; sanction, the judgment says, “does not dispense with, subsume or satisfy” that requirement. Order date not stated in the reports.
- Reported this week, order dates earlier or unstated — Kerala (Justice P. Gopinath) struck down Rule 7(37) of the Abkari Shops Disposal Rules, which barred women from working in toddy shops, applying Anuj Garg (Sophy v. State of Kerala, 2026 LiveLaw (Ker) 606); a Rajasthan Full Bench (Chief Justice Sanjay K. Agrawal, Justices Sameer Jain and Praveer Bhatnagar) held that a convict under Section 376 or POCSO is not wholly ineligible for an open-air camp and that “ordinarily” in Rule 3 confers discretion, not a bar; Madhya Pradesh (Chief Justice Alpesh Kogje and Justice Vivek Rusia) upheld Rule 3(1)(b)(iv) of the IT Rules, 2021 against an Instagram creator whose account was suspended for infringing content; Patna (Justice Rana Vikram Singh) quashed a bank-fraud prosecution of a UCO Bank panel advocate, holding that a wrong legal opinion is at most negligence for the disciplinary bodies absent evidence of collusion; Karnataka (Justice M. Nagaprasanna) quashed the second FIR against MLA Basanagouda Patil Yatnal over the same speech, 2026 LiveLaw (Kar) 434; Madras (Justice D. Bharatha Chakravarthy) upheld the cancellation of a US citizen’s OCI card for preaching without the prior permission the Section 7B notification requires (John Daniel v. Union of India, 2026:MHC:4303); Bombay (Justice Milind Jadhav) quashed an FIR over a reposted Operation Sindoor meme: “a youthful error of judgment cannot automatically be equated with a deliberate criminal act.”
- Insolvency-adjacent — Bombay (A A Estates v. Govind Niwas CHS, reported October 28) held that the Section 14 moratorium bars proceedings against the corporate debtor, not the debtor’s own counterclaim in an arbitration; Madras (Madurai Bench, EMC Ltd, reported October 28) held that a going-concern sale in liquidation does not of itself extinguish GST liabilities that arose during the resolution process, declining to follow the Calcutta “clean slate” line.
- Not heard or not reported — Karnataka’s Form 7 FIR stay (27 October), the Kharge trust matter (30 October) and the Ravi Patil stay (29 October); the Dal Lake motorboat ban in Srinagar (30 October); Kriti Sanon’s suit in Delhi (29 October); the Madras bye-election challenge and the Perambur application, both reserved; Allahabad’s Satyam Verma habeas, reserved since 8 October. Karnataka’s Deputy Chief Minister said on 26 October that the State “has decided to file” a special leave petition against the striking down of the 56 per cent quota; no filing was reported. The State’s final electoral roll, published on 27 October, carries 4,55,00,011 electors against 5,54,32,314 before the revision.
At the Bar
Collegium: Four Chief Justices for Delhi, Gujarat, Telangana and Uttarakhand, and Thirty-One Names for Five High Courts
The Supreme Court Collegium — October 26, 29 and 30, 2026
The Collegium headed by Chief Justice Surya Kant met on its first day back and recommended Chief Justices for four High Courts, three of which have run under Acting Chief Justices for months. Justice P. Sam Koshy, whose parent court is Chhattisgarh and who is Acting Chief Justice of Telangana, goes to Delhi; Justice Manash Ranjan Pathak of Gauhati, Acting Chief Justice of Gujarat, is recommended for that court; Justice Tapabrata Chakraborty of Calcutta for Telangana; and Justice Sudhir Singh of Patna for Uttarakhand. The same meeting recommended seven advocates for Madhya Pradesh (Dr Vivek Sharan, Rajesh Kumar Shukla, Kanak Gaharwar alias Kanak Lata Singh, Bhakti Vyas, Shreyas Pandit, Mrinal Elker alias Mrinal Mazumdar and Avinash Zargar) and two names for Bombay (Ajay Sharma, judicial member of the CESTAT at Mumbai, and Vaibhav Anant Sugdare, advocate).
On Thursday the three-member Collegium of the Chief Justice and Justices Vikram Nath and B.V. Nagarathna recommended nine advocates for the Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh High Court, and on Friday six names for Chhattisgarh (advocates Anand Shukla, Ratna Nidhi Pusty, Shashank Thakur and Sourabh Sharma, and judicial officers Rajnish Shrivastava and Balram Prasad Verma) and five judicial officers for Madhya Pradesh (Renuka Kanchan, Krishnamurty Mishra, Virendra Singh Rajput, Mamta Jain and Ashita Shrivastava). No Central notification followed within the week; Delhi remains under Acting Chief Justice Nitin W. Sambre, and no resolution on the Supreme Court’s own vacancy was published.
Why it matters: Delhi, Gujarat and Telangana have been without permanent Chief Justices since the summer, and the two Acting Chief Justices are now recommended for each other’s courts, which should make the notifications routine. Thirty-one High Court names in one week, most of them from the district judiciary and the Bar of the courts concerned, is the Collegium’s answer to the vacancy count it has been criticised for.
Mentioning: Senior Counsel Barred From Oral Mentioning From 2 November, and the Mentions Go Off the Live Stream
Registry circular of October 27, 2026; the Chief Justice’s court — October 27–28, 2026
On Tuesday, after a lawyer mentioned a matter connected to the Rahul Gandhi petitions without explaining what it was about, the Chief Justice said that mentioning without stating the issue was “the biggest nuisance” in the Court and “should stop completely.” A circular of the same date (F. No. 25/Judl./2026) provides that no Senior Advocate shall be permitted to make an oral mentioning before any bench with effect from 2 November 2026; junior counsel are to mention instead, and the circular is framed as encouragement to them. From Wednesday the live stream and audio of Court 1 no longer cover the mentioning session.
“Mentioning without explaining the issue is the biggest nuisance and should stop completely.”
Why it matters: Mentioning has been the Court’s informal fast lane, and the people who used it most were the seniors. From Monday the first thing a bench hears about an urgent matter will come from a junior, which puts a premium on the mentioning memo rather than the name at the lectern. The end of the live stream for that session also means the public record of who asked for what, and how the Chief Justice responded, is gone.
Allahabad: The Bar Accuses Justice Bhanot of Jailing a Lawyer in Court, and a Neighbouring Judge Starts Contempt Against the Protesters
Allahabad High Court — October 27–28, 2026
On Tuesday, in Court No. 49, an advocate objected to a police officer sitting behind the Additional Government Advocate. The High Court Bar Association says that Justice Ajay Bhanot ordered the advocate taken into custody and made him apologise to the officer, and mocked Senior Advocate V.P. Srivastava when he intervened. The Association’s president, Dr C.P. Upadhyay, and secretary, Santosh Kumar Mishra, wrote to Chief Justice Arun Bhansali the same day threatening to boycott the judge’s court: “if the court is free to insult a lawyer, then the lawyer will also not hesitate to insult the court.”
On Wednesday advocates protested outside the court, and reports say furniture was thrown inside it. Justice Arun Kumar Singh Deshwal, sitting in the adjoining court, initiated contempt proceedings against the advocates raising slogans: “they cannot be permitted to raise slogans, shout and disturb other Courts’ proceedings.” The Registrar (Protocol) is to produce the CCTV footage from outside Court No. 66, a reference to the Bar Council of Uttar Pradesh is under consideration, and the matter is listed on 19 November. The Association’s letter of 27 October is the second confrontation between the Bar and a judge of the Court in a month; the first, over Justice Diwakar’s judgment in Pappu Met on the Court’s internal governance, produced no Full Court response.
Why it matters: The contempt is against advocates for disrupting a court other than the one they were protesting, which is the ground on which such proceedings usually succeed. What the Bar actually alleged, a lawyer taken into custody from the well of the court, has not been examined by anyone yet, and the Chief Justice’s silence on the letter is the open question.
Other Notable at the Bar
- Women advocates (Supreme Court, October 26) — in Sarika Tyagi v. Union of India the Chief Justice, Justices Bagchi and Mohana directed every State and High Court to provide exclusive bar rooms and washrooms for women advocates in every district and taluka court, whatever their number, with funds allocated for it.
- The SCBA’s general body (Supreme Court, October 26) — the Chief Justice’s bench allowed the Association’s 2 November general body meeting on electoral reforms (proximity-card entry, the veteran-members category) to go ahead, by secret ballot, with the result sealed and not declared; Jaideep Gupta, for the court-appointed reforms committee, objected that holding the meeting “in the teeth of the Court’s order” went beyond what the Court had permitted. Listed 5 November.
- Raut and Wagle (Supreme Court, October 28) — Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul Pancholi recorded Nikhil Wagle’s unconditional apology, tendered through Indira Jaising, in the SCBA’s criminal contempt petition over remarks about the Chief Justice, and directed him to appear virtually; Sanjay Raut, who has filed an apology affidavit, is to appear in person on 17 November at 2 pm.
- The Kerala Congress post (Supreme Court, October 30) — the Registry registered Advocate-on-Record Vineet Jindal’s letter of 13 October as a writ petition on the Court’s own motion (Vineet Jindal v. Kerala Pradesh Congress Committee, W.P.(C) 1431/2026) over the “resign now” post addressed to the Chief Justice; the Committee’s president had replied to the SCBA’s notice on 22 October that a party worker posted it “without the leadership’s knowledge, consent or consultation,” and the Committee apologised to the Chief Justice in court on 27 October. No consent from the Attorney General for a private contempt was reported.
- Justice Kaul’s memoir — in an interview published on 29 October, Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul said the Collegium reiterated Saurabh Kirpal and the government’s reply was that “India is not ready for it,” and that he believes Kirpal would have been appointed were he not gay; Justice Chandrachud, asked about the book on 26 October, said he could not comment “unless I read his observations and understand the context,” that Collegium meetings were respectful, and that he recalled no recorded dissent. Without Fear or Favour is to be launched on 25 November.
- Justice Oka on the roster (October 27) — at a Campaign for Judicial Accountability seminar in Delhi, Justice A.S. Oka (retired) said the Supreme Court’s roster is “too CJI-centric” and “encourages hero worship,” that the Collegium “must ask questions to the government” about pending recommendations, and that the 26 October subject-wise roster should rule out manual intervention.
- The Chief Justice on Delhi (October 30) — at the Delhi High Court’s 60th foundation day, the Chief Justice said the court “has significantly enriched our civil and commercial jurisdiction” and that the Supreme Court has “a special relationship” with it because it takes a disproportionate share of the burden; on 28 October, at an international judicial forum, he said judgments “cannot foresee every practical difficulty” in implementation.
- Oudh Bar polls (Allahabad, Lucknow Bench) — Justices Rajan Roy and Manjive Shukla kept 300 advocates off the voters’ list for the 28 October election, 155 for a wrong place of practice and 145 for unrenewed certificates of practice (curable on proof), and directed the Bar Council of Uttar Pradesh to build an online certificate-verification system within six months (Girdhari Lal Yadav v. Bar Council of U.P., 2026 LiveLaw (AB) 889).
- A judge’s son (Kerala, October 29) — Justice Kauser Edappagath granted interim protection from arrest to a serving District and Sessions Judge seeking anticipatory bail in the Kochi Mercedes crash case, in which his minor son is alleged to have driven the car that killed a vendor: “He is a judicial officer. He will cooperate.” The victim’s family was impleaded.
- AIBE XXII — registration closed on 27 October; the examination is on 29 November. No movement on the Bar Council of India’s reconstitution, on senior designations, or on the Meghalaya contempt.
Insolvency & Corporate
IBC: Once a Plan Is Before the Tribunal, the Committee Cannot Withdraw It Because the Debtor Got Richer — Bank of India v. S.M. Kamal Pasha
Bench: Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran — October 26, 2026
The corporate debtor ran a toll road on National Highway 45. Its collections had collapsed in the pandemic when the Committee of Creditors approved a resolution plan of ₹172.55 crore, at a time when the company had ₹30 crore in the bank. The erstwhile promoter’s challenge, and a stay from the Supreme Court, held up the Tribunal’s confirmation for years; by the time that challenge failed, the cash balance had risen to ₹165 crore. The six-member Committee, led by the Bank of India as the Section 7 applicant, resolved to withdraw its approval and issue a fresh Form G, arguing that the plan now conferred a windfall on the successful applicant and that the Committee’s commercial wisdom should decide. The Appellate Tribunal refused and revived the application for confirmation; the Committee appealed. Senior Advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan appeared for the lenders, Nidhesh Gupta for the resolution applicant and Nikhil Nayyar for the promoter holding company, which has a pending application to end the process on a one-time settlement.
In Bank of India v. S.M. Kamal Pasha, 2026 INSC 1154, Civil Appeal 12045/2026, the Court held that the binding effect of a plan under Ebix Singapore runs both ways. That judgment concerned a resolution applicant seeking to withdraw or modify a plan after the Committee’s approval; “the dictum applies squarely to the CoC too,” and the Code “provides no scope for effecting further modifications or withdrawals of CoC-approved resolution plans” at the behest of either side. Section 12A, read with Regulation 30A, is an exhaustive code for withdrawal of the application at four stages, the last of them after the invitation for expressions of interest; read with Sections 30(2) and 31, “the withdrawal of an application can only be till the CoC approves the plan and after it is placed before the Adjudicating Authority, there can be no withdrawal either of the application or the approved Resolution Plan.” Kalyani Transco, which holds that the Committee survives approval until the plan is implemented, “does not detract from the essential binding nature” of the plan.
“The SRA’s contention that the CoC has turned turtle not because of its commercial wisdom but only due to a shortsighted opportunism revealing institutionalized rapacity also cannot be ignored.”
The Court did not interfere with the Appellate Tribunal’s order, which had sent every contention of the applicant and the promoter to the Tribunal to be considered when it decides confirmation. The Tribunal is to take up the confirmation application and the promoter’s settlement application together, “as expeditiously as possible,” with its satisfaction under Section 30(2) to be entered after verifying the debtor’s present financial position and cash balance against the plan’s terms. “The improved profitability alone cannot be a reason to refuse approval if the Resolution Plan meets the requirements.” Beyond the binding nature of the plan, the Court’s observations are prima facie and do not govern the Tribunal’s final decision.
Why it matters: Lenders have treated Kalyani Transco as licence to keep negotiating after approval; this judgment closes that reading. Between the Committee’s vote and the Tribunal’s order the plan is fixed for both sides, and the only lawful route out is Section 12A before approval. A debtor whose fortunes recover during a long confirmation fight is the resolution applicant’s gain, and the Committee’s remedy is the Section 30(2) scrutiny the Tribunal must still perform.
IBC: A Lender That “Navigates” the Debtor’s Policy Is a Related Party, and the Test Is Lower Than Control Under Section 29A — ECL Finance v. Abhinav Mukherjee
Bench: Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran — October 27, 2026
ECL Finance had subscribed to ₹110 crore of debentures issued by a group company to fund a Greater Noida housing project, with the corporate debtor as corporate guarantor and mortgagor, and had separately extended a ₹90 crore facility on which the debtor was also guarantor. When the debtor went into insolvency in January 2020, ECL and the debenture trustee claimed ₹139 crore and ₹131 crore and were admitted to the Committee of Creditors. A single homebuyer objected. The Tribunal held the claims were not financial debt and that both creditors were related parties; the Appellate Tribunal disagreed on the first point but held the claims could not be entertained because the guarantee had not been invoked before the insolvency began, and agreed on the second.
In ECL Finance Ltd. v. Abhinav Mukherjee, 2026 INSC 1159, Civil Appeal 6268/2022, the Court corrected both tribunals on financial debt: Anuj Jain itself recognises guarantee liabilities, and after China Development Bank v. Doha Bank a financial debt does not require a default, so an uninvoked guarantee is still a claim. It upheld the individual homebuyer’s standing to challenge the composition of the Committee, which Phoenix ARC allows. On related party, the Appellate Tribunal had applied ArcelorMittal, which reads “control” in Section 29A as positive, de jure or de facto control. That, the Court held, is the wrong yardstick. Section 5(24)(m)(i) asks only whether the creditor participates in the debtor’s policy-making, and “the rigour to find a financial creditor to be a related party under Section 21 … is a tad lesser than that required to find ‘control’ under Section 29A.” The Court then read the documents: a nominee director and an observer on default, a casting vote on board and shareholder deadlocks that is “final and binding,” approval of the quarterly construction budget and control of escrow releases, consent to any change of key managerial personnel, the power to appoint selling agents, and a power of attorney over construction, approvals, labour and sales. That the powers were never exercised was no answer; “it is crystal clear that ECL has an all-pervasive control.” The debenture trustee, protecting the same holder, was excluded with it, and an assignment of ECL’s facility rights made after the insolvency began and after ECL had filed its claim failed the bona fide test in Phoenix ARC.
“The requirement would not be to the extent of being in the driving seat, but a role of navigation would suffice, in determining policy and channelising business interests.”
Why it matters: The covenant package every structured-finance lender takes, nominee directors, deadlock rights, budget approval, escrow control, KMP consent, can now disqualify the lender from the Committee on a standard the Court has set below the one it uses for resolution applicants. The judgment also reasons that it is ECL’s status as sole debenture holder under Section 21(6A)(a) that disables it, “even in the status of a lender,” a reading of the first proviso to Section 21(2) that is narrower than the usual one and will be argued over. Assignment after the fact will be examined for bona fides and will not cure the disability.
IBC: Real-Estate Insolvency Is Rewritten — Project-Wise Accounts, Project Exclusion, a Choice of Representatives, and RERA at the Table
IBBI (Insolvency Resolution Process for Corporate Persons) (Fifth Amendment) Regulations, 2026 and Circulars 109 and 110 — October 30, 2026
The Board notified on Friday the amendments to the corporate insolvency regulations it had consulted on for real-estate debtors, effective on publication in the Gazette, with two circulars the same day and a press release on Saturday. Regulation 4D is substituted to require a separate bank account for each real-estate project, project-wise receipts and payments placed before the Committee, and compliance with RERA’s fund-utilisation rules during the process. A new Regulation 4F requires project-wise details at the first Committee meeting and allows the Committee, by a vote of not less than 66 per cent, to recommend that a project be excluded from the insolvency, with the resolution professional then applying to the Tribunal. A new Regulation 4G requires an independent technical and cost-to-complete assessment for each project before expressions of interest are invited, to form part of the information memorandum as a process cost.
Creditors in a class are to be offered a choice of three insolvency professionals as their authorised representative (Regulation 6(2)(bb)); the representative’s minutes go to the professional and the Committee and the representative’s views are recorded (Regulations 16A(11A) and 24(6A)). The information memorandum must now carry project-wise contents including allottees’ relief preferences (Regulation 36(2)(ja)); the monitoring committee under Regulation 38(4)(b) must include an allottee representative and a representative of the RERA authority; and Regulation 38A is substituted to require project-wise plan contents, timelines and periodic reporting. Regulation 30A is clarified so that the resolution professional continues until the Tribunal decides a Section 12A withdrawal. Circular 109 introduces a revised Form CA with a Part II for allottees, without requiring claims already filed to be refiled; Circular 110 requires compliance with RERA for debtors with real-estate projects and display of the insolvency status at project sites and offices, with the professional to pull project data from the RERA portal. Separately, Disciplinary Committee order 349/2026 of the same date suspends the authorisation for assignment of Fanendra Harakchand Munot over a miscalculation of voting shares in the Shree Bhimeshwari Ispat process.
Why it matters: Project-wise resolution, which the Appellate Tribunal has been improvising case by case since Supertech, is now the regulatory default, and the Committee has a formal power to carve a project out. For allottees, the choice of representative and the seat on the monitoring committee are the first structural changes to their position since they became financial creditors in 2018. Every pending real-estate process will need its accounts, its Form CAs and its information memorandum re-cut.
Tribunals: “Our Requests Are Directions,” the Court Tells the NCLAT, and Says the Ministry Has “Hijacked” the NCLT’s Staff
Bench: Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran — October 27–30, 2026; Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana — October 29, 2026
In Sona Bansal v. Vashisht Kumar Goyal, the Court had on 15 July requested the Appellate Tribunal to hear an appeal on 23 July. It was not heard; the Tribunal meanwhile admitted the Section 7 application. Justices Pardiwala and Vinod Chandran said they were “quite disturbed,” sought an explanation from the Appellate Tribunal and directed that no Committee of Creditors be constituted meanwhile, returnable 19 November. In a separate order the bench recorded the principle: when the Supreme Court makes a request to any court or tribunal, “it has to be construed as a direction.”
Two days later, in the suo motu matter on the Tribunal’s members and infrastructure (In re Appointment of Members and Infrastructure in NCLT, with Ziyaul Haq v. Union of India), the Chief Justice’s bench heard that the Ministry of Corporate Affairs had outsourced recruitment of the Tribunal’s staff by a contract of 6 October without the President’s approval, that existing staff faced removal around 1 November, and that eighteen benches were sitting half-days. “It is unfortunate,” the Chief Justice said, “that the Ministry of Corporate Affairs has hijacked NCLT staff appointments.” Notice issued; the Court suggested deputation and phased recruitment through the UPSC and SSC, and asked the Presidents of the Tribunal and the Appellate Tribunal for proposals on infrastructure within four weeks. The Attorney General was asked to impress on the Union the need for basic amenities. On the same day the Court declined to interfere with the Appellate Tribunal’s refusal of interim relief to Ritesh Prakash Adatiya, the resolution professional whose registration the Board cancelled over three Anil Ambani group processes, leaving all questions, including the “clarificatory amendment” point pending before another bench, to the Appellate Tribunal.
Why it matters: Both orders are about who runs the tribunals. The first makes a Supreme Court “request” to a tribunal a direction enforceable by explanation; the second puts the Ministry’s control over the Tribunal’s own staff before the Court, with a National Tribunals Commission still unconstituted. Practitioners before the NCLT should expect the half-day sittings to continue until the staffing question is settled.
Other Notable Insolvency Orders
- Polycab (NCLAT, October 30) — the Principal Bench set aside the Ahmedabad Tribunal’s 7 October admission of Asier Metals’ Section 9 petition against Polycab India for ₹2.78 crore, finding a plausible pre-existing dispute in the correspondence on credit notes, demurrage and reconciliation, and restored the board.
- No right from an earlier approval (NCLAT, October 27) — Justice N. Seshasayee, Arun Baroka and Indevar Pandey in Vasu Buildcon v. Kashi Viswanathan Sivaraman (IVR Prime IT SEZ): after a remand, the earlier Committee approval conferred no right on the applicant; the revised plan failed the 66 per cent threshold and the Section 12A offer the 90 per cent one, and a fresh Form G was within the Committee’s commercial wisdom.
- The buyer’s veil (NCLAT, October 27) — in Subbarao Siddabattula v. Radhey Shyam Yadav the corporate veil of a company that bought the debtor’s business cannot shield the persons in complete control of the debtor from liability for the acquired business’s dues.
- Section 95 limitation (NCLAT, reported October 30) — in Poonam Anoop Wadhera v. Canara Bank the Principal Bench held a personal-guarantor application filed on 8 November 2024 time-barred, limitation having run out in March 2024; admission of the bank’s claim in the corporate debtor’s process is not an acknowledgment under Section 18 of the Limitation Act.
- Section 240A (NCLAT, reported this week) — in Shobhit J. Rajan v. ARCK Resolution Professionals the Principal Bench held that the MSME exemption reaches only Section 29A(c) and (h), not the eligibility criteria the Committee sets under Section 25(2)(h), departing from the Saravana Global line.
- Coffee Day (NCLAT, reported October 29) — the Appellate Tribunal declined to disturb the Bengaluru Tribunal’s order letting the Austrian insolvency administrator amend the date of default from November 2020 to September 2019, which takes the claim outside Section 10A; two weeks for an additional reply.
- A government company admitted (NCLT Bengaluru, reported October 27) — Daaksh Jute LLP v. Karnataka Food and Civil Supplies Corporation has been admitted on an operational debt of ₹19.25 crore for gunny bags, the Tribunal holding that a government company is a corporate person and that supplying ration bags is a commercial activity, not a sovereign function; the order’s date is not stated in the report and the settlement window had been to 31 October.
- Admissions and plans (NCLT, this week) — Bengaluru admitted Nadella Agrotech on Voyager Trading Partners’ Section 9 petition (26 October, claims by 9 November); New Delhi approved a project-wise reverse insolvency plan for CHD Developers’ Golf Avenue project with a 42-month implementation; Mumbai gave first-motion approval to the merger of Reliance Defence Systems and Reliance Aerostructure; Kolkata admitted Samsara Energy on SREI Equipment Finance’s petition and held that assessment may continue after liquidation but penalty notices are barred by Section 33(6).
- Securities Appellate Tribunal (October 26) — in Ventura Securities v. MCX the Tribunal set aside a ₹1.49 crore exchange penalty for client-level position-limit breaches in natural-gas options, the applicable circular capping such penalties at ₹2 lakh, ordered a refund of ₹1.76 crore and imposed ₹1 lakh costs on the exchange.
- Not moved — Subhash Chandra’s applications before the Appellate Tribunal (29–30 October) produced no report, and the five-member Tribunal bench sits on 19 November; the Phoenix ARC parties’ 26 October listing in Mumbai and the Chamber Constructions listing the same day were not reported; Kannan Tiruvengadam stands for final hearing on 18 November; nothing on Greenopolis, Reliance Entertainment, the SpiceJet lessors, Jindal Poly Films or Anil Ambani’s own insolvency. The personal-guarantor safeguards remain unnotified.
Legislative & Regulatory Watch
GST: The 57th Council Is Implemented — Three Notifications, Ten Circulars, Rate Changes From 1 November, and an Instruction That There Will Be No Arrests
Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs — October 26–30, 2026
Three weeks after the Council met, the Board put its recommendations into instruments. Notification 03/2026-Central Tax (26 October) brings Sections 153 to 155 of the Finance Act, 2026 into force on 1 November, amending Sections 15, 34 and 54 of the CGST Act on post-sale discounts and credit notes, extending provisional refunds to inverted-duty claims and dropping the ₹1,000 floor for IGST refunds on exports. Notification 04/2026 extends e-invoicing to reverse-charge supplies from unregistered persons and to imports of services from 1 January 2027. Notification 05/2026, the CGST (Amendment) Rules, 2026 (G.S.R. 919(E)), is staggered: most of it from 1 November; the registration-cancellation and refund-form changes from 1 December; the GSTR-7A and e-invoice schema changes from 1 January; and the blocking, cancellation, capital-goods-refund and demand-form changes from 1 April 2027. Among the substantive changes: a new Rule 14B for registration at an e-commerce operator’s warehouse in another State, with a ₹2.5 lakh monthly cap on business-to-business output tax; deemed approval of registration amendments on timelines; a 180-day route to revocation of cancellation; removal of the 1.5-times cap on the value of zero-rated goods under Rule 89; refund of input-services credit availed on or after 1 November under the inverted-duty head; refund of capital-goods credit on a sixty-month apportionment from April 2027; a ten-day limit for deficiency memos; a system-generated 90 per cent provisional refund within three working days; and a one-year ceiling on blocking of credit under Rule 86A with new demand forms.
Eight circulars of 26 October (257 to 264/2026-GST) cover registration guidelines for applicants, adjudication and appeal practice that is not to be cited in notices, the 10 per cent pre-deposit under Sections 107(6) and 112(8) and its refund, input service distributors, the 50 per cent option for banks under Section 17(4), credit on demonstration vehicles in the dealer-agency model (withdrawing paragraph 4.6 of Circular 231), export proceeds received through repatriable rupee accounts, and the retrospective omission of Rule 96(10) from 23 October 2017 following Goodluck India. Rate notifications of 27 October take effect on 1 November, including fertilisers and bio-stimulants at 5 per cent, conditions on credit for hotels, restaurants and catering, electric-vehicle passenger transport at 5 per cent, and exemptions for helicopter services in the North-East and for warehousing. Two further circulars of 28 October deal with classification and with the line between research and consultancy.
The instrument practitioners will cite first is Instruction 02/2026-GST of 30 October. Pending the amendments due in April 2027, the Board directs that there are to be no arrests under the GST law, Section 69 being due for omission; that e-way-bill interceptions are to be made only on specific intelligence authorised in writing by an officer of the rank of Joint Commissioner or above and within the officer’s jurisdiction, with no confiscation under Section 130 in transit; and that no show-cause notice is to issue where the aggregate demand across all four levies is below ₹10,000.
Why it matters: The Council’s enforcement promises are now administrative instructions binding on the field formations, which a taxpayer can hold an officer to before the statute changes. The refund changes alter cash flow for inverted-duty and export businesses from this week, and the Rule 96(10) circular closes the ground on which thousands of export refunds were being recovered. The April 2027 items, the demand forms and credit blocking among them, are the ones to diary.
Securities: A Carbon-Credit Company’s Promoter Banned for a Year Over ₹197 Crore of Premature Revenue, ₹1 Crore on CDSL, and a Censure for Axis Capital
Securities and Exchange Board of India — October 28–30, 2026
On Friday the Board passed its final order against EKI Energy Services, finding that the company had recognised ₹197.04 crore of revenue prematurely and overstated expenses by ₹26.34 crore in 2021–22 and 2022–23. The company is barred from the market for two months, its managing director Manish Dabkara for twelve months and the former chief financial officer Mohit Agarwal for eight, with shorter bans on others; penalties of about ₹88 lakh in all; and a direction to the managing director to recoup the sums diverted. The same day an adjudication order imposed ₹1 crore on Central Depository Services under Section 15HB for lapses found in the 2023–24 inspection, among them pledge rejections without reasons, data-loss-prevention gaps, unpatched vulnerabilities and disaster-recovery drills, an order distinct from the ₹1 crore penalty in July over the LockBit intrusion. On Wednesday the Board censured Axis Capital over the ₹260 crore Sojo Infotel debenture issue, where a repayment commitment that functioned as a guarantee had been dressed as underwriting and ₹166.84 crore had been paid into escrow in March 2024.
Also this week: a memorandum of understanding with the Bank of England on cooperation over clearing corporations (28 October); a rationalised periodicity for KYC review of foreign portfolio investors (30 October); extensions of the compliance timelines for debenture trustees’ separate business units (27 October) and for the digital-accessibility circulars (30 October). The chairman said in Kolkata on Saturday that the Board is moving to delist listed shells with no economic activity, the vehicles of pump-and-dump schemes. No board meeting was held. The Settlement Regulations, 2026 commence on 7 November, with the 90-day transition window at a 20 per cent premium running to early February; comments on the issue-proceeds monitoring consultation close on 3 November and on the SME IPO paper on 4 November. The Appellate Tribunal’s reserved order on Jane Street’s disclosure application was not pronounced.
Why it matters: The EKI order is the Board’s first accounting-fraud outcome in the carbon-credit business, and the ban on the promoter rather than only the company is the measure that matters. The Axis Capital censure, for a guarantee called underwriting, is a signal to merchant bankers structuring credit enhancement around a debt issue.
Telecom: TRAI Floats Draft Guidelines on Responsible Use of AI in Networks, With Comments by 27 November
Telecom Regulatory Authority of India — October 30, 2026
The Authority released draft Guidelines on Responsible Use of AI in Telecommunication Networks and Services on Friday. The framework asks each operator for a board-approved AI policy, an AI governance and safety committee with a designated officer, reporting of serious AI incidents, and a central incident database maintained by the regulator. Comments are due on 27 November. The second stage of the Third Amendment to the Telecom Commercial Communications Customer Preference Regulations is due on 17 November, and nothing moved on the quality-of-service review.
Why it matters: This is the first sector regulator to propose an AI governance structure for licensees, ahead of any general AI law. The incident-reporting duty and the central database are the provisions that will have compliance and disclosure consequences for operators and their vendors.
Other Notable Regulatory Moves
- Reserve Bank — a quiet week on the regulatory page: the Section 35A directions on Lokapavani Mahila Sahakari Bank (Mandya) and Sonpeth Nagari Sahakari Bank (Parbhani) were extended on 28 October and on Irinjalakuda Town Co-operative Bank on 29 October; the 625th Central Board meeting on 30 October reviewed the deposit insurer and select departments without a policy outcome; lead-bank responsibilities were reassigned for the reorganised districts of Delhi (27 October). Punjab National Bank disclosed on 29 October a penalty of ₹1.57 crore for non-compliance with the currency-chest directions; the Bank’s own release had not appeared by Saturday. The KYC Amendment Directions, with the mule-account provisions, remain in draft; the Supreme Court’s 29 October direction that they must require banks to indemnify digital-arrest victims is in the Supreme Court section above. Next monetary policy 2–4 December.
- UPI merchant charge — no post-Diwali date has been notified by the NPCI; the 13 October deferral stands and Diwali is 8 November.
- Corporate Affairs — nothing new after the 24 October extension of the annual-filing dates (accounts to 31 December, annual returns to 31 January without additional fee); no amendment to it, no new rules, nothing on the Corporate Laws (Amendment) Bill. Applications for the full-time member vacancy at the National Financial Reporting Authority close on 16 November.
- Competition Commission — approvals announced on 30–31 October: Adani Energy Solutions’ acquisition of IntelliSmart Infrastructure from NIIF and EESL (about ₹3,050 crore including redemption of debentures) and Aditya Birla Renewables’ acquisition of Solenergi Power from Shell; approvals for Xavier Niel’s Vodafone stake and a Prosus investment in Navi were reported by single sources. No penalty orders.
- Insurance — comments on the IRDAI’s paper on distribution economics closed on 31 October after the extension; a circular of 30 October migrates health regulatory returns and product identification to the integrated portal.
- Not yet — no draft of the Intermediary Rules amendment on under-18 accounts; no amendment extending CSEAM reporting to all intermediaries; no appointments to the Data Protection Board; no members for the Mediation Council; no National Tribunals Commission; no notification of the personal-guarantor safeguards. The pharmaceutical-marketing committee the Supreme Court ordered on 8 October was constituted by the Department of Pharmaceuticals on 22 October, before this week, under Dr M. Srinivas of NITI Aayog with Preeti Sudan and Dr Naresh Trehan, to report within two months of its first meeting.
What We’re Watching Next Week
- Monday, November 2 — the bar on oral mentioning by Senior Advocates takes effect in the Supreme Court; Siddique Kappan’s passport plea; in Bombay, Imran Khan’s “Leave India” notice, held in abeyance on the Additional Solicitor General’s assurance; in Delhi, Sourav Ganguly’s suit over Doosra; the SCBA’s general body meeting on electoral reforms, its result to be sealed.
- Tuesday, November 3 — Punjab’s Chief Secretary is to appear in person before Justice Bunger unless the Supreme Court protects him; the Tejpal appeals; the Palika Bazar matter in Delhi; comments close on SEBI’s issue-proceeds monitoring consultation; the Nagpur Police Commissioner’s affidavit on firecracker licences.
- Wednesday and Thursday, November 4–5 — the Dharmasthala de novo investigation before the Karnataka High Court; on Thursday, Maharashtra’s 1.22 crore “logical discrepancy” deletions before the Chief Justice’s bench, the SCBA reforms matter, and the Munnar task force names in Kerala.
- Friday, November 6 — the Centre’s and the Reserve Bank’s positions on a coma patient’s bank account before Allahabad in Parveen Jahan; the status report in the Delhi-NCR rapes suo motu matter.
- The weekend — SEBI’s Settlement Regulations, 2026 commence on Saturday, 7 November; Diwali is Sunday, 8 November, with the NPCI’s post-Diwali date for the UPI merchant charge still unannounced, and the revised prices under the 30 per cent cancer-drug margin cap apply from 9 November.
- Reserved — the firecracker order before Justices Sundresh and Varale; drug pricing before Justices Nath and Mehta; the Enforcement Directorate’s petition against Mamata Banerjee; Jane Street’s disclosure application at the Securities Appellate Tribunal; Sachin Waze’s bail appeal in Bombay; the Madras bye-election challenge and the Perambur application; Satyam Verma in Allahabad; and at the Supreme Court the Sabarimala nine-judge reference, the two-child norm, the seven-judge sales-tax surcharge reference, the Sambhal survey, the PMLA Adjudicating Authority’s composition, anticipatory bail direct to the High Court, the Jindal Poly Films recall and the IDBI officials’ prosecution. The Opposition’s Election Commission petitions and Sanjay Raut’s appearance are on 17 November; the Section 163 and 172 BNSS batch, Sona Bansal, the Allahabad contempt and the five-member NCLT bench in Subhash Chandra on 19 November; the restored Vijayan appeals in Kerala on 26 November.
That’s all for this week. If a colleague would find this useful, forward them this page — or better yet, ask them to subscribe.
Enjoyed this issue?
Get the next one delivered straight to your inbox every Monday.