Back to Journal
Cover story Week of Oct 19–25
01

A Holiday Bench Stays the Vijayan Investigation, Not the FIRs

The bench decided who gets to argue the question, not the question itself, and in doing so named the two provisions the appeal will turn on: Section 17A of the Prevention of Corruption Act and Section 175(4) of the BNSS, which now makes a public servant's own…

Read the cover story

Also this week

  1. 02 Elections: “No Judicial Deference When It Comes to Law and Order” — the Andhra Nominations Order
  2. 03 Arrest: Kerala Strikes the “5 PM Cut-Off” on Producing Arrestees Before a Magistrate — P.S. Subeesh
  3. 04 Policing: ₹5 Lakh for a 2017 Arrest, Suspension for the Officers, and a Magistrate’s Remand Orders Go to the Administrative Committee — Bipin Satish Chandra Agrwal
  4. 05 Protest: A Peace-Bond Notice Survives, but the Magistrate Must Show His Material — Neha Bora, with the Cockroach Janta Party’s Leaders
  5. 06 Protest: Mumbai’s Detentions — Seven Affidavits, a Senior Officer’s Reply, and Imran Khan’s “Leave India” Notice Listed for the 26th
  6. 07 Arrest: An Officer Who Answered a Section 35(3) BNSS Notice Could Not Be Arrested Without Recorded Reasons — Madras High Court
  7. 08 Banking: Who May Draw on a Coma Patient’s Savings? Allahabad Asks the Centre and the Reserve Bank — Parveen Jahan
  8. 09 Elections: Karnataka Closes Its Revision With 2.29 Lakh Form 7s, Kerala Sets a January Roll, and the Speaker Says He Will “Expedite” the Trinamool Twenty
  9. 10 Anti-Corruption: Punjab’s OSD Sits Five Hours With the CBI Under the Court’s No-Coercive-Steps Order
  10. 11 Justice Kaul’s Memoir: “Consultation” Versus “Pre-Approval” — a Former Collegium Member on the Chandrachud Years
  11. 12 IBC: A Resolution Professional Who Drew ₹5 Lakh a Month Without the Committee’s Approval Is Suspended for a Year — Sanjay Bulakichand Borad
  12. 13 Company Law: Accounts by 31 December, Annual Returns by 31 January — the Ministry Extends FY 2025-26 Filing Without Additional Fee
  13. 14 Banking: The Minutes Show a 4–2 Stance, and the Reserve Bank Clears Its Desk Before the Break
  14. 15 Securities: The Trading Academy Must Return ₹546 Crore of Course Fees, With ₹67.87 Crore of Interest

Welcome to this week’s issue of the Indian Legal Brief (ILB). Here are the judgments, orders, regulatory changes, and developments that matter to your practice — without the noise.

The Supreme Court was closed for Dussehra from Monday to Saturday and reopens on Monday, 26 October. It sat once. On Wednesday a special bench of Justices Bagchi and Mohana heard two matters, and both are in this issue: the former Kerala Chief Minister’s challenge to the vigilance case over his daughter’s company, where the Court stayed the investigation but not the FIRs and sent the family back to the Division Bench that had refused them leave to appeal; and the Andhra Pradesh municipal nominations, where it declined to extend the deadline itself but told the State Election Commission to decide by the next morning, which the Commission did. No judgment was pronounced all week, and the trade press spent it catching up on the judgments of 12–16 October that last week’s issue covered. The week’s law was made in the High Courts. Kerala struck an executive protocol that told the police to produce arrestees between 10 am and 5 pm “as far as possible”; Bombay awarded ₹5 lakh for a nine-year-old arrest and sent a magistrate’s remand orders to its Administrative Committee; Madras released a police inspector arrested after he answered a Section 35(3) notice, because no reasons were recorded; Delhi upheld a peace-bond notice against a student leader but told the magistrate to show her his material; and Allahabad asked the Centre and the Reserve Bank who may draw on a coma patient’s savings. The Ministry of Corporate Affairs gave companies until the year’s end to file their accounts, the Reserve Bank published minutes that show a split on its stance and then cleared its desk on Friday, the Securities and Exchange Board ordered a trading academy to return ₹546 crore, and Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul’s memoir put the word “pre-approval” into the Collegium debate.

Supreme Court Highlights

Anti-Corruption: A Holiday Bench Stays the Investigation, Not the FIRs, and Restores the Vijayan Appeal — Pinarayi Vijayan v. K.M. Shajahan

Bench: Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana — October 21, 2026

On 9 October a Single Judge of the Kerala High Court (Justice A. Badharudeen) had directed the Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau to register a case against the former Chief Minister, his daughter Veena T. and his son-in-law P.A. Mohammed Riyas on information the Enforcement Directorate had shared under Section 66(2) of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, and set aside the State’s decision to hold a preliminary enquiry through a special team. On 15 October a Division Bench (Justices K. Natarajan and Johnson John) refused the three leave to appeal, holding that a person named in information that discloses a cognizable offence has no right to be heard before an FIR is registered. The Bureau registered its cases. Senior Advocate Siddharth Luthra mentioned the matter on the Court’s last working day, and the Chief Justice said he would explore a special bench during the break.

That bench sat on Wednesday, and in Pinarayi Vijayan v. Adv. K.M. Shajahan, SLP (Crl) 20437/2026 it did three things. It held that the three had standing: the Single Judge had recorded that the material disclosed a cognizable offence against them by name, and “these facts clearly make out a prima facie case of locus for the petitioners to seek leave to appeal.” It set aside the Division Bench’s order and permitted them “to pursue the appeal before the division bench,” with any interim relief being one “which the division bench will be entitled to fashion independently in accordance with law.” And it directed that “the investigation in the impugned FIRs shall remain stayed for a period of ten days” so that they could ask the Division Bench for protection; early reports said a week, and the signed order says ten days. The FIRs stand. The Directorate’s own money-laundering case is untouched: “We express no opinion with regard to its validity and keep it open to be agitated in appropriate proceedings.”

The order also marks the ground the appeal will be fought on. The bench pointed out that where the old Code’s Section 156(3) let a magistrate order an investigation on a complaint without more, Section 175(4) of the BNSS requires, before a magistrate orders an investigation against a public servant for an act in the discharge of duty, a report from the officer’s superior and consideration of the public servant’s own account of the incident; it said so, it added, “not in reference to the merits of the case before us, but to elucidate the expansive jurisdiction envisaged in the new law.” It noted that the Single Judge’s directions “may require consideration of other statutory requirements under the special law including sanction under Section 17A” of the Prevention of Corruption Act. In court, Justice Bagchi asked how an investigation of a former Chief Minister could begin without that approval; Zoheb Hossain, for the Directorate, said approval is not needed when a court directs the investigation, and the bench replied that this one arose from the Directorate’s information, not a court’s direction.

“Don’t use the process of statutory powers to meddle into the statutory domain of other entities.”

The remark was addressed to the Directorate, as were the others: “Do your PMLA examination. File your complaint under Section 4. You have got a scheduled offence”; “Don’t extend your hand beyond your statutory limits”; and, of the family, “However high you may be, you cannot be above the law.” On Vijay Madanlal Choudhary, which the Directorate cited for the proposition that its information bound the State police, Justice Bagchi said: “Our problem is now we read judgments like statutes.” The Kerala High Court did not take the restored appeals up on Friday; they are posted for Monday, 26 October. The Directorate had separately summoned the former Chief Minister to Kochi for Friday in its own case, which the stay does not reach.

Why it matters: The bench decided who gets to argue the question, not the question itself, and in doing so named the two provisions the appeal will turn on: Section 17A of the Prevention of Corruption Act and Section 175(4) of the BNSS, which now makes a public servant’s own account a precondition to a magistrate ordering an investigation. Every High Court asked to order an FIR against a serving or former official on an agency’s Section 66(2) letter will have to meet both before it reaches Lalita Kumari.


Elections: “No Judicial Deference When It Comes to Law and Order” — the Andhra Nominations Order — YSR Congress Party v. State of Andhra Pradesh

Bench: Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana — October 21, 2026

Andhra Pradesh’s urban local body elections were notified on 14 October with nominations open from the 16th to the 18th. The principal opposition party said that nearly two-thirds of its candidates had been kept from filing by violence and obstruction at nomination centres, and placed its representations to the State Election Commission and video clips on record; the High Court had declined its anticipatory plea on 15 October and then declined to extend the window. The party came to the special bench on Tuesday and was heard on Wednesday, Senior Advocate Maninder Singh appearing for it, K. Parameshwar for the Commission, and Siddharth Luthra and Mukul Rohatgi opposing for the State.

In Yuvajana Sramika Rythu Congress Party v. State of Andhra Pradesh, SLP (C) 37476/2026 the Court refused a blanket extension — “We will not allow our judicial processes to become platforms of canvassing,” Justice Bagchi said — but found a prima facie case on the material, and directed the Commission to decide by 22 October whether to extend nominations in the affected constituencies, with at least forty-eight hours from publication for the affected candidates to file; deferred publication of the final list of candidates to 25 October; and told the police to secure the nomination centres, with compliance to be reported when the matter returns on 27 October. The order describes judicial deference to the control and superintendence of elections as a doctrine of necessity, and says of constitutional courts that “their hands are not tied when appropriate interventions are necessary” to keep an election free of extra-constitutional or illegal means; grievances about the process itself remain for an election petition after it is over. UT of Ladakh v. J&K National Conference (2024) and BJP West Bengal v. State of West Bengal (2018) were relied on.

“The first line of election is of judicial deference. But there is no judicial deference when it comes to law and order.”

On Thursday the State Election Commissioner extended nominations by forty-eight hours in designated wards of the Kadapa and Tirupati corporations and the Rajampet and Mydukur municipalities, with filing on 23 and 24 October and the final list on 25 October; polling is on 1 November.

Why it matters: The Court did not touch the schedule; it made the Commission decide, on a deadline, with the police answerable for the venues. That is the shape of intervention a party kept from filing can now ask for — not a court-ordered extension, which the order declines, but a time-bound direction to the authority that can grant one, with “equality of arms” as the test.


Other Notable SC Orders This Week

  • A closed Court — the Court’s calendar marked 19–24 October as the Dussehra holidays; no judgment was pronounced and no Collegium resolution was published, and the Wednesday special bench was the only sitting. The Court reopens on Monday, 26 October.
  • Vande Mataram (reported October 23) — a former IAS officer from Kerala, Balakrishnan Sathyabhama Mavoji, filed a writ (Diary 62724/2026) against the Centre’s orders of 28 January and 9 July 2026 prescribing a six-stanza version of the song, seeking a declaration that only the two-stanza version is the National Song and that no one may be compelled to sing it or penalised for abstaining; the petition calls the orders “a direct attack against the foundational Constitutional basic structure features of fraternity and secularism.” Not yet listed; a separate challenge by T.M. Krishna is pending.
  • The Election Commission’s functioning (reported October 24) — a public interest petition asks for an expert committee headed by a former Chief Justice or judge of the Court to examine “institutional shortcomings in the functioning of the Election Commission of India,” citing the two Election Commissioners’ recorded objections to the Chief Election Commissioner’s decisions and the backlog of more than thirty-eight lakh appeals in the West Bengal revision. Not yet listed.
  • NewsClick (reported October 24) — the Enforcement Directorate has filed a special leave petition against the Delhi High Court’s judgment of 29 May (Justice Neena Bansal Krishna) quashing the Economic Offences Wing’s FIR 116/2020 and the money-laundering case against the portal and Prabir Purkayastha, contending that ₹9.59 crore of foreign investment was structured to circumvent the limits on foreign funding of digital news media. No date.
  • Drug pricing (reported October 23) — the Ministry of Chemicals and Fertilisers’ affidavit in the medicines-pricing matter before Justices Nath and Mehta puts hospital margins on anti-cancer drugs at “170% to 700% or more” and on consumables at “100% to 1000% or more,” while describing the market as “fairly competitive” and the problem as one of “information and bargaining asymmetries between patients” and sellers. The 30 per cent trade-margin cap on 137 anti-cancer drugs was gazetted on Saturday, 17 October, under paragraph 19 of the Drugs (Prices Control) Order, with revised prices to apply from 9 November. The bench sits on 27 October.
  • Lakhimpur Kheri (reported October 24) — the trial judge in the Ashish Mishra case has been replaced: Lokesh Rai was appointed District and Sessions Judge on 14 October, after the Chief Justice’s bench forwarded the victims’ families’ complaints to the Allahabad High Court on 22 September for “remedial action” and a sealed-cover report, and on 5 October directed that a vigilance report on the judge be placed before the High Court’s Chief Justice.

From the High Courts

Arrest: Kerala Strikes the “5 PM Cut-Off” on Producing Arrestees Before a Magistrate — P.S. Subeesh

Bench: Justices Raja Vijayaraghavan V. and K.V. Jayakumar — October 23, 2026

A 2023 Home Department order (G.O.(Ms) 202/2023/Home) had told Kerala’s police that arrested persons should “as far as possible” be produced before a magistrate during working hours, 10 am to 5 pm, with production after 5 pm only in “exceptional circumstances,” on prior intimation to the judicial officer and with the investigating officer present to explain. While the public interest petition against it was pending the State modified the order (G.O.(Ms) 173/2026/Home, 24 September 2026), keeping the daytime preference, adding that the twenty-four-hour limit under Section 58 of the BNSS and the Constitution must be strictly observed, and dropping the requirement that the investigating officer attend.

In Adv. P.S. Subeesh v. State of Kerala, 2026:KER:80664 the Division Bench held that Article 22(2) and Section 58 fix an outer limit; they do not give an investigating agency a right to defer production until that limit is near. Read together, “as far as possible” and “exceptional circumstances” would discourage production outside court hours even where immediate production is warranted, and treating the approaching end of the twenty-four hours as an exceptional circumstance could lead the police to hold a person overnight — delaying legal assistance and the opportunity to oppose remand. A procedural arrangement meant to regulate the timing of production “cannot justify procedural requirements that operate to the detriment of the arrested person’s fundamental rights.” The guidelines were set aside to the extent they prefer production between 10 am and 5 pm and permit later production only in exceptional circumstances; the requirement of prior intimation to the magistrate for production after 5 pm was upheld, and the State was directed to issue fresh guidelines consistent with the judgment. T.K. Sandeep and Reshma Viswanathan appeared for the petitioner; the Director General of Prosecution and the Special Government Pleader for the State.

“An executive protocol cannot dilute the safeguards guaranteed by the Constitution and the governing statute.”

Why it matters: “Without unnecessary delay” is now read against the clock from the moment of arrest, not from the next morning’s court hours. Any State circular that sets a production window, and any remand where the delay is explained by one, is open to the same challenge; the practical test is whether a magistrate was available and the police chose to wait.


Policing: ₹5 Lakh for a 2017 Arrest, Suspension for the Officers, and a Magistrate’s Remand Orders Go to the Administrative Committee — Bipin Satish Chandra Agrwal

Bench: Justices Ajey Gadkari and Kamal Khata (Bombay High Court) — October 22, 2026

The petitioner held his mother-in-law’s power of attorney for a flat in a Walkeshwar building under redevelopment and had asked the developer for ₹1.64 crore for it. On 4 August 2017 the developer handed him a ₹2 lakh advance in the developer’s own office; the police, already present, handcuffed and arrested him, and the developer then complained of extortion under Section 384 of the Penal Code, an offence punishable with up to three years. He spent six days in police custody and twenty in judicial custody. Nine years on, in Bipin Satish Chandra Agrwal v. State of Maharashtra, W.P. 4458/2017, appearing in person, he won.

The Division Bench found no record that the police had considered whether arrest was necessary for an offence of that class, no compliance with Section 41A of the Code before custody, and documents that appeared to have been fabricated to present him as a history-sheeted extortionist; the sub-inspector, it held, had acted in collusion with the developer. “We therefore conclude that the arrest and remand were high handed, arbitrary and made without application of mind.” The magistrate of the 64th Court, Mumbai, who passed the remand orders of 5, 8 and 10 August 2017, “has failed to independently apply his mind and adopted a very casual approach.” The State is to pay ₹5 lakh within two weeks and to initiate strict action against the officers concerned, including immediate suspension, with liberty to recover the compensation proportionately from their salaries; the Registry is to place the judgment before the High Court’s Administrative Committee in respect of the magistrate.

“Clearly this is a case of sheer abuse of process by the Developer in collusion with the Police.”

Why it matters: Compensation for an Arnesh Kumar breach is no longer the end of it. The order reaches the individual officers’ salaries and the remanding magistrate’s record, and it does so in a private dispute dressed as a crime — the pattern that fills the Section 482 docket. Defence counsel opposing remand should have this judgment with them.


Protest: A Peace-Bond Notice Survives, but the Magistrate Must Show His Material — Neha Bora, with the Cockroach Janta Party’s Leaders

Bench: Justice Subramonium Prasad (Delhi High Court) — October 21 and 23, 2026

Neha Bora, national president of the All India Students’ Association, had called a 5 pm gathering at Mandi House on 16 October to walk to Central Park and unfurl the national flag as part of the protests against the Chief Election Commissioner. She was detained at about 5.30 pm, held overnight at the R.K. Puram police station and released at 6 am. On 17 October a Special Executive Magistrate issued her a notice under Sections 126 and 130 of the BNSS, read with Section 135(3), to show cause why she should not execute a ₹10,000 bond with one surety, citing sloganeering at Mandi House, repeated protests around Jantar Mantar despite Section 163 orders, and instigation. Senior Advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan argued over two and a half hours on Thursday that the notice was mechanical, rested on hearsay and did not meet Section 136; the Additional Solicitor General said the magistrate had a general-diary entry, FIRs naming her and the prohibitory orders, and that she had run towards Connaught Place when stopped. “The concern of the petitioner,” the judge put it, “is that I am already branded as a bad boy and asked to say you shall be a good boy.”

The judgment on Friday evening, in Neha v. State (NCT of Delhi), W.P.(Crl) 3342/2026, dismissed the petition. “The impugned notice meets the requirements of a show cause notice under Chapter IX of the BNSS”; the scheme “does not require a show cause notice to read like a judgment”; “even one incident is sufficient for initiating proceedings under Chapter IX”; the BNSS “is preventive and not punitive in nature”; and the court “cannot sit in the arm-chair of the SEM.” But the magistrate was directed to furnish her all the material relied upon, to ensure that natural justice is observed before any bond is ordered, to record reasons in writing, and to consider whether a bond under Section 135 can be demanded at the threshold at all or only after an incident during the inquiry. She may challenge whatever follows.

Two days earlier the same judge had heard the Cockroach Janta Party’s co-convenors, Saurav Das and Ashutosh Ranka, against a magistrate’s order of 19 October extending their judicial custody by two days for breaching their ₹50,000 peace bonds by entering de-notified Jantar Mantar during the 14 October march. The court was disinclined to entertain a writ where the Code provides a revision — “Liberty is sacrosanct. But if the Code provides for remedy…” — and suggested they “withdraw this, see what happens at 2 pm and then follow the course of law.” They withdrew; that afternoon the magistrate released both on fresh ₹50,000 bonds after written undertakings not to breach the peace and not to call a protest at Jantar Mantar while it remains de-notified, any protest to be “within the four corners of the Constitution of India.”

Why it matters: Chapter IX of the BNSS — the security-for-good-behaviour chapter, with its executive magistrates and its power to detain under Section 135(3) — is now the instrument of choice for the Delhi protests, and the first High Court ruling on it has left the notice standing while fixing the procedure around it: material disclosed, reasons recorded, and an open question whether a bond can be demanded before the inquiry has found anything. The Supreme Court’s Section 172 notice returns on 19 November; this is the companion fight.


Protest: Mumbai’s Detentions — Seven Affidavits, a Senior Officer’s Reply, and Imran Khan’s “Leave India” Notice Listed for the 26th

Bench: Chief Justice Mahesh Chandra Tripathi and Justice Advait Sethna (Bombay High Court) — October 19, 2026

In Sagar Devre v. State of Maharashtra the Division Bench took on record affidavits from at least seven people who say they were detained by the Mumbai police on 10 and 11 October without having taken part in the protests against the Chief Election Commissioner, some picked up from their homes. The Advocate General, Dr Milind Sathe, said that “as far as August Kranti Maidan site is concerned, no one was detained,” that protesters had blocked Nana Chowk without permission and the police had only dispersed them. The Chief Justice directed him to file an affidavit through a senior officer. “Everybody has a right to agitate but that agitation must be peaceful,” he said; and, of the alleged detentions, “if there are instances of unlawful detention, we will obviously take care of it.” The court repeated that it would not pass blanket orders and would deal with specific instances placed on record.

The same bench was mentioned the actor Imran Khan’s petition against a 14 October notice from the Foreigners Regional Registration Office under Sections 7(2)(c) and 29 of the Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025, requiring the United States citizen and Overseas Citizen of India cardholder to leave the country by 28 October after his detention near August Kranti Maidan on 10 October; a separate show-cause asks why his overseas citizenship should not be cancelled. Senior Advocate Venkatesh Dhond said no criminal case was pending and that his client had lived in India since the age of two. The Additional Solicitor General sought time; the court listed the matter for 26 October, two days before the departure date, and asked that the State of Maharashtra be impleaded. The challenge to the Maharashtra Special Public Security Act, listed for 22 October after the bench’s demand for the petitioners’ credentials, produced no reported order. Sachin Waze’s bail appeal, reserved on 16 October, was not pronounced.

Why it matters: The Bombay bench has settled on the same method as the Supreme Court — no general relief, affidavits on each detention, the State to answer through an officer who can be held to it. The “Leave India” notice is the first use of the 2025 Act against a protester that has reached a High Court, and the 26 October listing will decide whether a departure deadline can run while the challenge is heard.


Arrest: An Officer Who Answered a Section 35(3) BNSS Notice Could Not Be Arrested Without Recorded Reasons — Madras High Court

Bench: Justices G.R. Swaminathan and P. Murugan (Madurai Bench) — October 23, 2026

Sugumaran, a suspended inspector of the Thanjavur District Crime Branch, appeared before the CB-CID on 9 October in answer to a notice under Section 35(3) of the BNSS in an extortion case — a partner in a Thanjavur hospital alleged he had been made to pay ₹5 crore meant for the inspector and his superiors during a dispute among the partners. He was arrested at 5 pm that day after questioning; the magistrate refused bail on 16 October. On habeas corpus the Division Bench held the arrest, detention and remand illegal. Section 35(5) bars the arrest of a person who has complied with a notice to appear unless the officer records reasons for considering it necessary, and the agency did not show that any were recorded; nor did it prove that the grounds of arrest had been communicated, as Articles 21 and 22 require. The court said it was not granting bail but ordering release because the custody was unlawful, and directed that he be set free “forthwith and unconditionally,” the merits untouched. “No doubt, Sugumaran is a police officer accused of having played an unauthorised mediator,” the bench said; “even such a person deserves due process.”

Why it matters: Section 35(5) is the BNSS’s version of the Arnesh Kumar safeguard for people who come when called, and this is a clean application: compliance with the notice shifts the burden to the officer to produce recorded reasons, and the absence of the record is itself the illegality. The same logic will apply to every agency that summons first and arrests at the end of the day.


Banking: Who May Draw on a Coma Patient’s Savings? Allahabad Asks the Centre and the Reserve Bank — Parveen Jahan

Bench: Justices Ajit Kumar and Garima Prasad (Allahabad High Court) — order uploaded October 21, 2026

The petition concerns an account-holder who lay in a coma, and has since died, while the family could not reach the money to pay the hospital or run the house. In Parveen Jahan v. Union of India, Writ-C 27492/2026 the Division Bench observed that in such cases the dependants “become absolutely remediless,” recalled that in Uma Mittal v. Union of India (2020) the court had asked the Centre to legislate on guardians for persons in a vegetative state and the direction had not been implemented, and asked the Union, through the Finance Secretary, and the Reserve Bank, through its Executive Director for banking regulation, to state on affidavit whether “some sort of legislation from the competent legislature” or regulatory guidelines to banks could give dependants a route to the account — and what, if anything, has been framed for such emergencies. The Uttar Pradesh Chief Secretary was asked to propose a “concrete and substantial” State-level solution, or to appear in person; the Kerala High Court’s guidelines in Shobha Gopalakrishnan, which Uma Mittal referred to, were offered as a model. If the Bank does not file, its officers may be summoned. Listed 6 November.

Why it matters: There is no statutory guardianship for an adult in a vegetative state, and the High Courts have been filling the gap case by case under Article 226 since 2019. A direction to the Reserve Bank to say whether a banking circular can do what Parliament has not is the first time the regulator has been asked the question directly, and a circular is far quicker than a Bill.


Other Notable High Court Orders

  • Firecrackers in Mumbai (Bombay, October 21) — in In re: Noise and Environmental Pollution, Justices Kulkarni and Gokhale found the civic body and the pollution board had not even published public notices of the ban on bursting firecrackers on roads, streets and footpaths that the court extended to the whole year on 15 October, and that police station in-charges appeared unaware of it. “What is the point in having paper orders?” the bench asked; “otherwise file an affidavit that we are helpless.” Notices in newspapers and on social media by 24 October; the Police Commissioner to brief every station in-charge; compliance affidavits from the municipal and police commissioners by 26 October; a standard operating procedure against violators; a complete ban in silence zones; and the observation that it was “shocking” that Mumbai’s pollution was surpassing Delhi’s.
  • The anti-conversion law (Bombay, October 22) — Chief Justice Tripathi and Justice Sethna allowed a 70-year-old Bhiwandi Islamic teacher to withdraw his challenge to the Maharashtra Freedom of Religion Act, 2026 (the “allurement” definition, the sixty-day notice with public objections and police inquiry) with liberty to file afresh, having asked for concrete instances of interference with his own practice or propagation and declined an amendment; the Chief Justice distinguished a voluntary change of faith from a conversion undertaken only to facilitate a marriage. No ruling on validity.
  • Proceeds of crime by arithmetic (Bombay, reported October 21) — in Avinash Bhosale v. Directorate of Enforcement, Criminal Appeal 478/2026, Justices Gadkari and Khata set aside the Appellate Tribunal’s continuation of the attachment of ₹25 crore of land in Pune and Nagpur and dismissed the Directorate’s own appeal: on the agency’s own figures the debenture transactions left a balance of ₹28.81 crore against a claimed ₹67.85 crore, ₹47.52 crore of the “consultancy” receipts predated the Yes Bank loan to DHFL, and “these are official banking transactions and cannot be construed as proceeds of crime.”
  • Return the laptop (Bombay, reported October 24) — a bench headed by Justice Bharati Dangre directed the Enforcement Directorate to return the documents and devices seized from a director of Chellaram Mills and to unfreeze his locker, the 180-day retention period under Sections 17 and 20 of the PMLA having run out with no Adjudicating Authority order extending it, a lapse the agency did not dispute: by “operation of law and efflux of time … the ED has lost the authority to continue to retain the articles.”
  • Only the Supreme Court may say “not a precedent” (Delhi, reported October 21) — in Union of India v. Om Prakash, Justices Hari Shankar and Vinod Kumar held that the caveat that a judgment is not to be cited as precedent is a power peculiar to the Supreme Court under Article 141 — “the power to issue such a caveat is not available to any other court” — since a tribunal or High Court restricting its own ruling would treat similarly placed litigants unequally.
  • Munnar (Kerala, October 22) — Justices Devan Ramachandran and Basant Balaji directed the State to constitute a Special Task Force of senior revenue and police officers, relieved of other duties for at least six months, to examine and implement the recommendations of the encroachment reports of 2003–2010 on government land in Munnar and the neighbouring Idukki villages: “reports after reports are remaining in the back-burner, without any concrete action being taken.” Names by 29 October, when the court will fix its composition and powers.
  • Stale antecedents (Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh, reported October 22) — in Rouf Ahmad Wani, 2026 LiveLaw (JKL) 478, Justice Sanjay Parihar quashed, at the pre-execution stage, a 2024 Public Safety Act order resting on cases from 2005–07, several ending in acquittal, and one cheating FIR: “mere reproduction of old criminal antecedents” cannot sustain detention, and the authority cannot “transform an ordinary allegation of criminal or objectionable conduct into a threat to public order” by using the statutory words.
  • The transfer docket (Rajasthan, reported October 21) — in Vinod Agarwal v. State of Rajasthan, 2026 LiveLaw (Raj) 445, Justice Anoop Kumar Dhand, noting “a flood of writ petitions assailing the transfer orders,” dismissed a batch and restated the only grounds of interference — malice or bias, breach of a statutory provision, an incompetent authority, or extreme hardship such as a life-threatening illness — while allowing representations within two weeks and staying the transfers for four.
  • CMRL–Exalogic (Kerala, October 23) — the appeals the Supreme Court restored were not taken up on Friday and are posted for Monday, 26 October.

Politics & Public Law

Elections: Karnataka Closes Its Revision With 2.29 Lakh Form 7s, Kerala Sets a January Roll, and the Speaker Says He Will “Expedite” the Trinamool Twenty

Chief Electoral Officer, Karnataka — October 23; Lok Sabha Speaker — October 22; Chief Electoral Officer, Kerala — October 23, 2026

Karnataka’s Chief Electoral Officer, V. Anbukkumar, closed the books on the Special Intensive Revision on Friday: between 16 June and 22 October the State received 10,42,863 Form 6 applications for inclusion, 4,840 Form 6A from overseas electors, 2,28,917 Form 7 objections and 13,10,841 Form 8 corrections — 25,87,461 in all. The final roll is to be published on 27 October. On the allegation, pressed by the ruling party in the State, that “bulk Form 7 applications were filed to delete eligible voters’ names” in constituencies it holds, the officer said that “submitting a Form 7 objection does not automatically lead to deletion of a voter’s name,” that due process and verification follow, and that inquiries had been ordered into suspected false applications with legal action where wrongdoing is established. The High Court’s stay on the FIRs against the Malleshwaram booth-level agents who filed in bulk, and on the Dharwad probe, returns before Justice Hegde on 27 October, the same day the roll is published.

In Delhi, the Lok Sabha Speaker was asked on Thursday about the twenty Trinamool Congress members facing disqualification petitions, whose time to reply had run out on 20 October after he refused a further two days. “We will hear from both sides. When the responses come from the members, we will expedite the process,” he said — the Supreme Court having told him on 23 September that it expected an “expeditious” decision, and that it could not direct him but wished to remind him. On any fresh notice to remove the Chief Election Commissioner: “If any fresh notice comes, we will see and examine it accordingly under rules and procedures.” None has been filed.

Kerala’s Chief Electoral Officer, D. Sajith Babu, set out the Special Summary Revision that follows the State’s intensive revision: begun on 15 October rather than 1 October, a draft roll on 12 November, claims and objections to 11 December and disposal by 28 December, and a final roll on 4 January 2027. “Political parties have asked for more time,” he said of the booth-reorganisation deadline. “I think there is logic in their demand.”

Why it matters: Karnataka’s numbers are the first full accounting of a Form 7 campaign — 2.29 lakh objections against 10.4 lakh inclusions — and the officer’s position that an objection triggers verification, not deletion, is the standard the FIR matters and the Supreme Court’s Form 6 order of 28 October will be measured against. The Speaker’s statement is the first on the record since the Court’s reminder, and it commits him to nothing but a hearing.


Anti-Corruption: Punjab’s OSD Sits Five Hours With the CBI Under the Court’s No-Coercive-Steps Order

CBI, Chandigarh — October 19, 2026

Rajbir Singh Ghuman, officer on special duty to the Chief Minister of Punjab, appeared at the Central Bureau of Investigation’s Chandigarh office on Monday for a second round of questioning, about five hours after nearly six on 16 October, in the case the Punjab and Haryana High Court ordered on 5 October in Nikhil Saraf on the Enforcement Directorate’s letters about postings and tenders. The Supreme Court on 12 October declined to stay the FIR but directed no coercive steps against him. His lawyer, G.P.S. Ghuman, protested that he was not allowed to accompany his client inside, citing the Supreme Court’s guidelines on the presence of counsel during interrogation, and said the matter would be taken to the CBI court. The officer denied wrongdoing and described the messages the Directorate flagged as routine transfer requests. No chargesheet or arrest is reported; the Chief Secretary’s contempt matter over dearness-allowance arrears is before the roster bench on 30 October, and the High Court’s status hearing in the probe is on 7 December.

Why it matters: A “no coercive steps” order is being tested in the way it usually is — by summons rather than arrest — and the live question is the one the lawyer raised: whether counsel may be present within sight during questioning of a person the Court has protected. That is the next application in this matter.

At the Bar

Justice Kaul’s Memoir: “Consultation” Versus “Pre-Approval” — a Former Collegium Member on the Chandrachud Years

Reported October 24–25, 2026

Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul, who sat on the Collegium from June 2022 until his retirement in December 2023, has a memoir, Without Fear or Favour, due out shortly, and spoke about it to Karan Thapar for The Wire. Its account of one Collegium meeting has set the week’s argument: five names for the Supreme Court had been agreed in advance; the Chief Justice proposed a sixth at the last minute and asked whether he should telephone the Government for its view; Justice Kaul told him not to, because the Collegium was still deliberating. “There is a difference between consultation and what I came to regard as pre-approval,” the book says; seeking the Government’s nod before the Collegium had formally deliberated “sends a wrong signal.” In the interview he said the practice of discussing names with the Government beforehand had existed before and after Justice Chandrachud, that the then Chief Justice believed that was how the process had long worked, and that he had tried to discourage it because successors with shorter tenures would find it hard not to follow. Asked whether Justice Chandrachud was “too deferential,” he would not adopt the label but said that on administrative matters there was “too much of a discussion” with the Government.

Two other claims concern the bench rather than the Collegium. He says the petitions over the Centre’s delay in clearing judicial appointments were taken from his bench, and that before the reconsideration of Vijay Madanlal Choudhary he was advised to take a “middle path”: “In my judicial career, I have never taken the middle path ever in any way.” On the National Judicial Appointments Commission he said the 2015 Act could have been refined rather than struck down — “we would at least have sat across the table and discussed it” — and that the Collegium must resist executive pressure. Justice Chandrachud has not responded in the reports; the Congress has cited the book.

Why it matters: Collegium members do not usually describe its meetings, and this one describes the step that the system’s defenders say does not exist — the Government being sounded before the judges have decided. With the Court’s thirty-eighth seat still open and three High Courts under Acting Chief Justices, the account arrives as the question of who is consulted, and when, is live.


Other Notable at the Bar

  • Ladakh (October 21) — the Ladakh Bench of the Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh High Court held its first regular sitting at Leh, at over 11,500 feet, with Chief Justice Bhati appearing virtually and Justice Sanjay Parihar in person; five Division Bench matters and sixty single-bench matters were listed on the first day, sittings continuing to the 23rd. Justice Parihar said the aim was that “geographical barriers do not become obstacles to justice.” Litigants from Leh and Kargil previously travelled to Srinagar or Jammu.
  • A consent request (October 19) — Advocate-on-Record Savita Singh wrote to the Attorney General for consent under Section 15(1)(b) of the Contempt of Courts Act to proceed against the Kerala Congress president, Sunny Joseph, and the administrators of the party’s State X handle over a since-deleted 12 October post addressed “Dear Surya Kant” and ending “resign now … We will find your replacement”: “The aforesaid post constitutes blatant criminal contempt.” No decision on consent is reported; the Bar Association’s own seven-day notice to the same recipient also expired this week without a reported reply.
  • Law Commission (October 22) — the Commission’s national conference on co-operative federalism and legal reform in New Delhi was inaugurated by the Vice-President, who called the three criminal codes “a major step towards legal reforms,” said more than 1,700 obsolete laws had been repealed in twelve years, and that “political differences must never come in the way of the larger public interest”; the Law Minister spoke of States as partners rather than implementing agencies. No report was released.
  • Appointments — no Collegium resolution was published during the break, and no notification of a High Court judge or Chief Justice issued; Delhi, Gujarat and Telangana remain under Acting Chief Justices, the Supreme Court’s thirty-eighth seat remains open, and the Collegium’s last published recommendation is of 28 September.

Insolvency & Corporate

IBC: A Resolution Professional Who Drew ₹5 Lakh a Month Without the Committee’s Approval Is Suspended for a Year — Sanjay Bulakichand Borad

IBBI Disciplinary Committee (Jayanti Prasad, Chairperson; Dr Bhushan Kumar Sinha, Whole Time Member) — October 21, 2026

Golden Tobacco’s insolvency, admitted by the Ahmedabad Tribunal in June 2022, has been through a replaced resolution professional, an appellate restraint and a Supreme Court status quo. Mr Borad was appointed in May 2024 by an order that said he would be paid according to the Board’s guidelines; the Appellate Tribunal in January 2025 directed that payments to professionals would be “subject to ratification by the reconstituted CoC”; the erstwhile professional was reinstated in May 2025. In between, Mr Borad drew ₹5 lakh a month — the fee the committee had approved for his predecessor in 2022 — where the minimum under Regulation 34B(2) of the CIRP Regulations for a debtor of that claim size is ₹3 lakh, and the proviso allows a higher fee only where the committee fixes it with reasons recorded. His defence was that the regulation prescribes a minimum, not a maximum; that the committee had already approved ₹5 lakh “for the Resolution Professional and not to a particular individual”; and that he had given an undertaking to refund if the fee was not ratified.

In Order IBBI/DC/348/2026 the Committee rejected each point. The 2022 approval was given to a different professional at a different stage; voting by the committee had been barred by the Tribunal from March 2023 and the Appellate Tribunal had frozen further steps, so no fresh approval existed or could be inferred; and “merely giving an undertaking to refund the amount later, if it is not approved, does not substitute the requirement of the CoC’s approval with recorded reasons that Regulation 34B(2) requires before a higher fee is fixed.” The contravention was of Section 208(2)(a) and (e) of the Code, Regulation 34B(2), and the Code of Conduct. A second charge — failing to raise rent invoices on a tenant whose lease had expired — was dropped in view of the appellate and Supreme Court restraints on him. His registration is suspended for one year, the excess fee is to be deposited in the debtor’s account within sixty days, and the order takes effect thirty days from issue.

Why it matters: Regulation 34B(2) is read as a floor with a gate on it: anything above the minimum needs the committee’s approval and reasons, in advance, for that professional, and a predecessor’s approval, a pending ratification or a refund undertaking does not open it. Professionals stepping into a running case where the committee cannot meet should take the minimum and apply, not draw and undertake.

Legislative & Regulatory Watch

Company Law: Accounts by 31 December, Annual Returns by 31 January — the Ministry Extends FY 2025-26 Filing Without Additional Fee

Ministry of Corporate Affairs, General Circular 05/2026 — October 24, 2026

On stakeholder representations the Ministry extended the time for filing financial statements for the financial year ended 31 March 2026 in Forms AOC-4, AOC-4 (CFS), AOC-4 (XBRL), AOC-4 NBFC (Ind AS) and AOC-4 CFS NBFC (Ind AS) to 31 December 2026, and annual returns in MGT-7 and MGT-7A to 31 January 2027, without additional fee. The circular is explicit that it “shall not be construed as conferring any extension of statutory time for holding of AGMs”: a company that did not meet the meeting deadline remains liable under the Act, and a filing after the extended window attracts fee from the original due date.

Why it matters: The extension buys the filing, not the meeting. Companies that held their annual general meeting late need the Tribunal’s or the Registrar’s relief as before, and the extension does not protect a director from the consequences of a late meeting under Section 96. Secretarial calendars should treat 31 December and 31 January as the dates and leave the meeting record alone.


Banking: The Minutes Show a 4–2 Stance, and the Reserve Bank Clears Its Desk Before the Break

Reserve Bank of India — October 19, 21 and 23, 2026

The minutes of the 5–7 October meeting, published on Wednesday, record that the 25-basis-point increase to 5.50 per cent was unanimous and the change of stance to “calibrated tightening” was not: Dr Nagesh Kumar — “I feel that a neutral stance remains appropriate” — and Prof. Ram Singh — “I do not favour shifting the stance from neutral to tightening mode” — would have kept it neutral. The Governor described the new stance as “essentially signalling that rate cuts are off the table in the near term.” The next meeting is on 2–4 December.

On Friday three sets of instructions followed. The Prudential Norms on Capital Adequacy (Eleventh Amendment) Directions, 2026 bring in the Basel Committee’s 2017 leverage-ratio standard from 1 April 2027, the August draft having been revised after feedback, with the Bank’s response to comments annexed. The Commercial Banks (Forthcoming Instructions) Second Amendment Directions, 2026 complete the operational-risk capital framework from the same date, mapping the business-indicator components to financial-statement lines (the mapping is “indicative”), fixing the loss component at fifteen times average annual operational losses net of recoveries, and setting ten years of loss data as the norm with five permitted on first entry. And A.P. (DIR Series) Circular 28 delegates the compounding of FEMA contraventions in overseas investment, borrowing and lending, and guarantees from the Central Office to the Regional Offices — overseas-investment cases by the prefix of the foreign entity’s identification number, borrowing and guarantee cases by the applicant’s registered office, mixed cases staying with the Cell for Effective Implementation of FEMA in Mumbai. Earlier in the week, on Monday, the Bank deleted the limits on non-option derivative contracts from its Miscellaneous Directions for commercial banks and small finance banks, with no replacement.

Why it matters: For bank boards the dates are 1 April 2027 for both the leverage ratio and operational-risk capital, with the final texts now in hand. For the FEMA bar the compounding delegation is the practical change — applications that went to Mumbai now go to the regional office that supervises the applicant, which should shorten the queue but means a different officer and a different practice in each region.


Securities: The Trading Academy Must Return ₹546 Crore of Course Fees, With ₹67.87 Crore of Interest

SEBI final order, Avadhut Sathe Trading Academy — October 23, 2026

The interim order of December 2025 had impounded ₹546.16 crore as the prima facie unlawful gains of a trading-education business the regulator said was giving actionable, live-market trading calls without registration as an investment adviser or research analyst. The final order, reported at 171 pages, confirms it: Avadhut Sathe and the academy are to refund ₹546.17 crore of fees collected from participants, with interest of ₹67.87 crore at 12 per cent, within five months, their bank accounts remaining under debit freeze until the money is deposited; both are barred from the securities market for two years or until the refund is complete, whichever is later; Gouri Sathe, a co-director, is barred for six months for failing to exercise oversight; and penalties of ₹6 crore on the academy, ₹4 crore on Mr Sathe and ₹1.5 crore on Mrs Sathe total ₹11.5 crore. The Appellate Tribunal had earlier cut the interim deposit to ₹100 crore; the final order will go there next.

Why it matters: This is the largest refund direction against an unregistered adviser and the first to treat course fees as the disgorgeable gain. The line it draws is the one every “education” channel must now observe: teaching a method is education; a specific instrument, a price and a time is advice, and the registration requirement follows the content, not the label.


Other Notable Regulatory Moves

  • Early pay-in (SEBI, October 22) — where a client has a net sell obligation and the clearing corporation has accepted early pay-in, no margin is to be collected from the trading or clearing member on the client’s subsequent cash-segment positions up to the available early-pay-in value, computed in real time as the lower of the accepted value and the value sold; if the sale is squared off the benefit is withdrawn and any shortfall blocked from the member’s proprietary collateral; trade-for-trade securities excluded. Effective four months from issue.
  • Call records (SEBI, October 23) — following the October amendment to Regulation 25 of the Research Analysts Regulations, call recording of interactions with institutional investors (as defined in the ICDR Regulations) is no longer mandatory from 8 November; other records of every client interaction — signed physical, e-mail from a registered address, SMS, or other legally verifiable form — remain, for five years and longer if a dispute is pending.
  • Exchanges’ side businesses (SEBI consultation, October 22) — a proposed automatic route for stock exchanges and depositories to invest in related activities without case-by-case approval under Regulation 38(2) of the SECC Regulations and Regulation 7(c)(i) of the Depositories Regulations, with an annual cap of the lower of 5 per cent of net worth and the regulatory minimum, post-investment net worth of at least one and a half times the minimum, board approval and half-yearly reporting; comments by 12 November. Separately, a press release of 22 October cautioned investors against stock tips through invitation-only messaging groups.
  • Jane Street (SAT, October 21) — the Appellate Tribunal reserved its order on the firm’s application for the regulator’s order logs, counterparty data and internal communications in its appeal against the interim order of July 2025; the regulator said it had shared more than ten gigabytes and called the demand dilatory.
  • Puducherry Co-operative Urban Bank (RBI, October 21) — all-inclusive directions under Section 35A read with Section 56 of the Banking Regulation Act from close of business on 21 October for six months: withdrawals capped at ₹5,000, no fresh loans, deposits or investments without approval, deposit insurance to ₹5 lakh; “should not per se be construed as cancellation of the banking license.” Directions on Konark Urban (Ulhasnagar) and Suri Friends’ Union were extended to January.
  • Insurance distribution (IRDAI, October 24) — the comment deadline on the paper recalibrating the economics of insurance distribution was extended from 25 to 31 October, more than 650 comments having come in.
  • Tax (CBDT, October 19) — Notification 137/2026 inserts Rule 281A and Form 173A for foreign institutional investors and the Bank for International Settlements to claim the exemption on specified securities income under the Income-tax Act, 2025, with ISIN-level holdings as at 1 April; Notification 136/2026 exempts interest on the New Development Bank’s rupee bonds from deduction at source from tax year 2026-27 — a withholding exemption, not an income exemption.
  • Air (CAQM, October 21) — Stage I of the Graded Response Action Plan was invoked in Delhi-NCR after the first “poor” day of the season, an average index of 245: interstate buses not meeting BS-VI or running on CNG or electricity barred from eight States, diesel generator rules, and twenty extra Metro trips a day.
  • Not yet — no draft of the Intermediary Rules amendment on under-18 accounts (the four-week clock from 28 September runs out about 26 October); no notification of the committee on pharmaceutical marketing the Court directed on 8 October (two weeks ran to about 22 October); no post-Diwali date for the UPI merchant charge; no Central Tax notification implementing the 8 October Council decisions; no IBBI notification of the personal-guarantor safeguards; no constitution of the National Tribunals Commission.

What We’re Watching Next Week

  • Monday, October 26 — the Supreme Court reopens. In Kerala, the Division Bench takes the restored CMRL–Exalogic appeals, with the Supreme Court’s ten-day stay running to about the end of the month; in Bombay, Imran Khan’s “Leave India” challenge, two days before his departure date, and the municipal and police commissioners’ firecracker affidavits before Justices Kulkarni and Gokhale; before the Mumbai Tribunal, the Phoenix ARC parties after the Appellate Tribunal set aside the liquidation.
  • Tuesday, October 27 — the Andhra nominations matter returns before Justices Bagchi and Mohana with the Election Commission’s and the police’s compliance; drug pricing and the 30 per cent cap before Justices Nath and Mehta; the Karnataka Form 7 FIR stay before Justice Hegde, the same day the State publishes its final roll; the Opposition’s challenge to the Special Intensive Revision deletions is returnable.
  • Wednesday, October 28 — the Delhi revision and Form 6 before the Chief Justice’s bench, which said it was “thinking of passing an order”; the CAPF cadre-review contempt before Justices Misra and Bhuyan; the Sohrabuddin matter; the wrestlers’ appeal at Rouse Avenue.
  • Thursday and Friday, October 29–30 — the West Bengal deleted-voters appeals, the Chief Justice’s fall-back date; Subhash Chandra’s applications at the Appellate Tribunal; the Munnar task-force names in Kerala; the Punjab Chief Secretary’s contempt before the roster bench; the Dal Lake motorboat ban in Srinagar; Kriti Sanon’s personality-rights suit in Delhi. On the 31st, the Karnataka Tribunal’s settlement deadline in Daaksh Jute.
  • Reserved or pending — Sachin Waze’s bail appeal in Bombay; the five-seat bye-election challenge and the Chief Minister’s application in the Perambur election petition in Madras; Satyam Verma’s National Security Act habeas in Allahabad; the Goa bench’s revision verdict; the Jane Street disclosure order at the Appellate Tribunal; the Committee of Creditors’ power to withdraw an approved plan; the Sambhal survey; the Sabarimala nine-judge reference; the two-child norm; the seven-judge sales-tax surcharge reference. The Section 163 petitions and the Bar’s detention petitions return on 19 November; the IRDAI distribution paper closes on 31 October.

That’s all for this week. If a colleague would find this useful, forward them this page — or better yet, ask them to subscribe.

Enjoyed this issue?

Get the next one delivered straight to your inbox every Monday.

Every Monday morning. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.