Forty-Six Petitions on the Protest Crackdown, and Notice on Section 172 BNSS
The Court has chosen its question. It will not reopen the prohibitory-order power that Babulal Parate settled sixty-five years ago, but Section 172 BNSS — detention without an FIR, without the arrest safeguards, for up to a day — is now under constitutional…
Read the cover storyAlso this week
- 02 Elections: Notice on Rahul Gandhi’s Writ, Subject to His Conduct — and a Form 6 “Not Adjudicated” by the Court
- 03 Banking: The ₹8,415 Crore AT-1 Write-Down Was Beyond the Administrator’s Powers
- 04 Child Protection: Internet Access Is a Fundamental Right of Every Individual, Children Included — Just Rights for Children Alliance
- 05 Contempt: Civil Contempt Is Not Criminal Jurisdiction, and Ram Kishan Fauji Goes to a Larger Bench — Sanjay Prasad
- 06 Reservation: Conversion Does Not Carry Caste-Based Backwardness Into Islam — Sameer Ahamed
- 07 Religious Endowments: The State Is Custodian, Not Owner, and a Gift of Inam Temple Land Is Void — K. Ramalingam
- 08 Insolvency Appeals and PMLA Bail: Sixty Days Means Sixty Days, and “Immediately” Is Not Twenty-Four Hours
- 09 Arbitration: Two Venues, One Seat; an Interest Bar Read at Full Width; a Non-Signatory Joined — Three Judgments
- 10 Court Practice: A Vacation Listing Without Notice Was “an Attempt to Steal a March” — Mohammed Kamran
- 11 Election Offences: A Citizen May Complain of a False Nomination Affidavit — Rajkumar Madki
- 12 Education: The Whole Course’s Fee Must Be on the Table Before Admission — Dr. B.C. Roy Engineering College
- 13 Public Tenders: Cancel an Auction on Evidence, Revisit It Before a Contract Exists, and Do Not Demand the Impossible
- 14 Drug Pricing: A 30 Per Cent Margin Cap on Cancer Drugs Is “Hardly Anything to Be Happy About”
- 15 IBC: Default Is a Fixed Fact and Quantum Is Not — the Section 7 Standard Restated, and Fabricated Citations in a Supreme Court Filing — Deepak Raheja
- 16 NCLAT: A Liquidation Order Must Engage With the Creditors’ Unanimous Vote, and a Suspended Liquidator Cannot Keep His Other Assignments
- 17 NCLT: A Government Company Is a “Corporate Person” — Karnataka’s Civil Supplies Corporation Admitted, Subject to Settlement
- 18 Reservation: Karnataka’s 56 Per Cent Falls — the 50 Per Cent Ceiling “Circumscribes the Power of the State”
- 19 UAPA and Protest: A Charge Is No “Blanket” Bar on Travel, and Presence at a Demonstration Is No Offence — Delhi High Court
- 20 Anti-Corruption: The Chief Minister May Not Appeal the FIR Direction — Kerala High Court
- 21 Federalism: “From Political Angle” Is Not a Reason — the Chief Minister’s France Trip Is Cleared by the Court
- 22 Election Petitions: A Chief Minister’s Appeal to Children Is “in Bad Taste” but Not a Corrupt Practice — Madras High Court
- 23 Bombay: The Special Public Security Act Challenge Waits on the Petitioners’ Papers, and the Mumbai Detentions Get a Hearing
- 24 The Bar Pulled Two Ways: Petitions Over the Detained Lawyers, a Letter Against the March, and a Contempt Petition Over the Chief Justice
- 25 The BCI Office Assault: A Special Investigation Team, Not the CBI — “You Seem More Interested in Prosecuting the Chairman Than the Assailants”
- 26 Meghalaya: The Bar’s Office-Bearers Purge Their Contempt, and “the Majesty of Law Stands Restored”
- 27 Court Fees: Is an Uncapped Ad Valorem Fee Valid? The Supreme Court Will Examine Kerala’s Hike
- 28 Payments: The UPI Merchant Charge Is Deferred to “Immediately Post Diwali” — No Date, No Change in Rates
- 29 Securities: The Closing Auction Is Cut to Ten Minutes, and Derivatives Expire on the Half-Hour VWAP Again
- 30 Forex: The 20 Per Cent Risk Reserve Reaches Banks’ Own Hedges, and Non-Deliverable Contracts Are for Hedging Only
Welcome to this week’s issue of the Indian Legal Brief (ILB). Here are the judgments, orders, regulatory changes, and developments that matter to your practice — without the noise.
The last full week before the Dussehra break, and the protest docket did not shrink: by Thursday there were forty-six petitions before the Chief Justice’s bench, the Metro corporation and the Commissioner of Police had each filed an affidavit, and the Court had drawn its line — it will not re-examine Section 163 BNSS, it will examine Section 172, and every agency is to preserve its footage. On Monday the Opposition marched to the Court’s filing counter; by Friday the Supreme Court Bar Association had a criminal-contempt petition on file against a journalist and a Member of Parliament, two hundred of its own members had asked it to condemn the march, and the Chief Justice had told the Bar that “courts have never lagged behind in protecting rights.” Away from all that, the week’s judgments were substantial: the Yes Bank AT-1 write-down of ₹8,415 crore was held to be beyond the Administrator’s powers; a two-judge bench said internet access is a fundamental right of every individual, children included, and built a national child-abuse-material database into an order; civil contempt was held not to be criminal jurisdiction and Ram Kishan Fauji was sent to a larger bench; conversion was held not to carry caste-based backwardness into a new religion; and the Court recorded its first encounter with fabricated, AI-generated citations in a filing. The Securities and Exchange Board rewrote the closing auction, the Reserve Bank extended its 20 per cent forex reserve to banks’ own hedges, and the UPI merchant charge that was to bite on Thursday was put off until after Diwali.
Supreme Court Highlights
Protest Crackdown: Forty-Six Petitions, One Nodal Counsel — the Court Will Not Test Section 163, Will Test Section 172
Bench: Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justice Joymalya Bagchi — October 15, 2026 (with Justice V. Mohana on October 12 and 13)
The compliance report the Court had called for on Tuesday was not filed on Tuesday. Justice Mohana was unwell, the three-judge bench did not sit on the merits, the Solicitor General’s time was extended, and the batch — the Tripathi contempt petition against the Home Secretary, the Commissioner of Police and the Metro chairperson; M.A. Baby’s writ; Menaka Guruswamy’s habeas petition; a B.Tech student’s challenge to Sections 163 and 172 BNSS; and, by then, petitions from the Advocates-on-Record Association, the Bar Association, the Lawyers’ Association for Constitution, the Network of Women in Media and two unions of journalists — was moved to Thursday. The Court did, on Tuesday, ask for a senior police officer to be present to explain the alleged assault on women journalists, and issued notice on the Association for Democratic Reforms’ challenge to Section 16 of the Election Commissioners Act, the immunity clause the bench had already remarked on the week before.
On Wednesday the affidavits came. The Metro corporation’s chairperson tendered an unconditional apology, said that forty-five of a proposed fifty-seven stations had been restricted and reopened at 10 pm, that all 4,157 scheduled trips ran, and that “the allegation of a complete, blanket shutdown is demonstrably refuted” — ridership on 10 October was thirty-two lakh against about fifty-eight lakh on a normal second Saturday. The Commissioner of Police denied any “wilful or deliberate disobedience,” put the crowd at more than 35,000, the police deployment at 15,000 including 3,750 women officers, and the police injured at more than 240. No affidavit from the Home Secretary is reported.
On Thursday the Chief Justice and Justice Bagchi sat as two, with forty-six matters before them, and ordered: notice in all of them to the Union and the Delhi Police; every law-enforcement agency to preserve its CCTV footage and other digital material, with private parties free to place their own recordings on record; nodal counsel on each side to consolidate the overlapping petitions; and no further protest petitions to be filed. On Section 163 BNSS the bench was “not inclined to entertain” a constitutional challenge, Babulal Parate having upheld the pari materia Section 144 of the old Code. On Section 172 — the power to detain for twenty-four hours a person who resists a police direction — notice issued “only on the limited issue” of its constitutionality, with the Union to reply in two weeks and to place every Section 163 order promulgated in New Delhi on the record, including one of 23 August; Justice Bagchi told the Solicitor General that without the orders the petitioners were “arguing against a ghost.” The Court declined to restore Jantar Mantar as a protest venue for now but issued notice on a challenge to the 11 October standing order that de-notified it. For the women journalists, Indira Jaising asked for an inquiry committee on Vishaka lines; the bench was prima facie agreeable to one “predominantly or exclusively of women,” names to come in sealed cover, and gave interim protection to a journalist against whom an SC/ST Act FIR had been registered after the Solicitor General, having disclosed her name in court, withdrew it with an apology. The Section 163 petitions return on 19 November.
“Arguing against a ghost.”
On Friday the bench declined a same-day hearing to Connaught Place traders challenging the civic body’s closure of Central Park for the Cockroach Janta Party’s next march, because the Delhi High Court had already dealt with it, but listed it for 26 October with a warning: “If we feel that the NDMC’s order is a disproportionate restriction,” Justice Bagchi said, “we will exercise our powers under constitutional tort jurisdiction.” The party’s founder, Abhijeet Dipke, detained preventively ahead of that march, was released by an Executive Magistrate on Saturday.
Why it matters: The Court has chosen its question. It will not reopen the prohibitory-order power that Babulal Parate settled sixty-five years ago, but Section 172 BNSS — detention without an FIR, without the arrest safeguards, for up to a day — is now under constitutional notice for the first time, with the State’s own orders to be produced. For the lawyers and journalists who were detained, the preservation direction is the practical win: the footage exists, and it can no longer be lost.
Elections: Notice on Rahul Gandhi’s Writ, Subject to His Conduct — and a Form 6 “Not Adjudicated” by the Court
Bench: Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana — October 12 and 13; Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justice Joymalya Bagchi — October 14 and 15, 2026
The Chief Justice had declined, by letter, the Leader of the Opposition’s request for a meeting on pending petitions — “convening a meeting to discuss pending cases would wholly contravene the principle of Separation of Powers” — with the assurance that any petition “shall be heard at the earliest possible opportunity.” On Monday evening the INDIA bloc’s leaders marched to the Court to file it, and supporters entered the premises. On Thursday the bench issued notice on Rahul Gandhi v. Election Commission of India, the challenge to deletions under the Special Intensive Revision, but said in terms that entertaining it was subject to the lead petitioner explaining “his conduct on the next date of hearing,” and that issuing notice condoned nothing. “We are not sitting in ivory towers,” the Chief Justice said. “We know what statements they are making outside and what they are saying in Court.” A separate writ over the gathering inside the Court’s premises also drew notice, and on Friday the bench agreed to hear an application alleging that the Leader of the Opposition pushed a pregnant journalist during the march — the Chief Justice having refused the day before to act on an oral mention: “Not taking suo motu of an oral submission. File petition.”
The Commission’s modified Form 6 came up again on Monday. In a Bihar matter Justice Bagchi said, “There is no adjudication on the new Form 6” — it was not before the Court when the Bihar revision judgment was delivered, whatever the Commission’s 26 September press note said. On Wednesday, on Prashant Bhushan’s application in Anjali Bhardwaj that deleted Delhi voters were being told to file a Form 6 carrying a never-voted-before declaration, the hearing was advanced from 30 October to 28 October; the Chief Justice: “we are thinking of passing an order that will take care of all this.” The plea to suspend the Chief Election Commissioner was not listed this week, nor was the West Bengal deleted-voters matter the Chief Justice had hoped to take on Friday; the Shiv Sena symbol hearing did not resume.
Why it matters: The conditional notice is a new instrument — the Court has put a petitioner’s conduct outside the courtroom on the agenda of his own writ — and the Form 6 question now has a date, 28 October, on which the Court has said it intends to pass an order. Election counsel in every State under revision should read that hearing as the one that decides what a deleted voter has to sign.
Banking: The ₹8,415 Crore AT-1 Write-Down Was Beyond the Administrator’s Powers — Yes Bank v. Axis Trustee
Bench: Justices Dipankar Datta and Augustine George Masih — October 15, 2026
On 13 March 2020 the Yes Bank Reconstruction Scheme was notified; on 14 March the Administrator appointed by the Reserve Bank under Section 36ACA of the Banking Regulation Act wrote down ₹8,415 crore of Additional Tier 1 bonds to zero. The draft scheme had contained a write-down clause; the final scheme did not. The Bombay High Court quashed the write-down in January 2023, and in Yes Bank Ltd. v. Axis Trustee Services Ltd., 2026 INSC 1132 the Supreme Court dismissed the appeals of the bank, the Reserve Bank and the Union.
An Administrator steps into the board’s shoes; he does not acquire the regulator’s role, and the non-viability trigger in the bonds’ terms belonged to the Reserve Bank, which never exercised it. The Master Circular’s write-down “before” reconstruction meant before the scheme took effect, and the Centre’s deletion of the clause from the final scheme was deliberate — a general savings clause cannot supply a specific power that was removed. Validity is judged as of the date of the act; necessity does not override the procedure the Master Circular prescribes. Interim orders were vacated, coupon payments left as they stand, and the observations confined so as not to influence pending proceedings.
“Any act performed by the administrator beyond the powers clothed upon him would be wholly illegal and void.”
Why it matters: This is the first word from the Court on an AT-1 write-down under a Section 45 scheme, and it is a sequencing rule: a loss-absorption feature must be triggered by the authority the instrument names, before the reconstruction bites, or not at all. Every future bank-resolution scheme will be drafted around it, and the bondholders’ restitution claims now have a judgment to stand on.
Child Protection: Internet Access Is a Fundamental Right of Every Individual, Children Included — Just Rights for Children Alliance
Bench: Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran — October 15, 2026
Two years after the 2024 judgment that read “child sexual exploitative and abuse material” into the law, the Court returned to implementation in Just Rights for Children Alliance v. S. Harish, 2026 INSC 1149, on applications for directions. It began by rejecting the easy answer. The right to access and use the internet is a fundamental right under Article 21, read with Article 19(1)(a), of every individual including children; “any blanket restriction on the access of internet by children is nothing more than unproven measures.” The route is age-appropriate safeguards — parental consent, oversight, a child mode — not exclusion.
“The safety of our children and their freedom are not at odds with each other.”
Then the directions. The Union is to build a national database of confirmed abuse material, within the Sahyog portal or standing alone, holding hashes and URLs only, each entry verified by at least three trained human analysts, access logged and audited, with a grievance route. Intermediaries are to report such material to the Special Juvenile Police Unit, the local police or the cybercrime portal under Rule 11 of the POCSO Rules — reporting to a foreign body is not enough — to report removals within two hours, file weekly consolidated reports, display a grievance officer and a distinct reporting category, and acknowledge complaints within twenty-four hours; the Union is to consider turnover-scaled exemplary penalties, disgorgement of revenue from paywalled material, and extending the duties to every intermediary by amending the IT Rules. Schools get age-appropriate body-safety, consent and digital-safety education in the core curriculum through NCERT and the State councils — “awareness of digital safety and sex education are not two separate subjects, but two sides of the same coin” — safe and unsafe touch from the primary stage, teacher training to identify grooming, the 1098 and 1930 helplines displayed in every classroom, network filters, and free long-term counselling for victims. A progress affidavit is due; the matter returns on 10 December. The same week the Chief Justice’s bench tagged the separate petition on a minimum age for social media, with notice to the Women and Child Development and Law Ministries and the child rights commission, for 7 December.
Why it matters: The fundamental-right holding will travel far beyond this docket — into every internet-suspension case, including the one the same Court is hearing about Delhi. For platforms, the reporting timelines are now court orders with a compliance date, and “we reported it to NCMEC” is no longer an answer.
Contempt: Civil Contempt Is Not Criminal Jurisdiction, and Ram Kishan Fauji Goes to a Larger Bench — Sanjay Prasad
Bench: Justices Dipankar Datta and Sheel Nagu — October 14, 2026
A Single Judge of the Allahabad High Court, in civil contempt, rejected an officer’s compliance affidavit and summoned him. He wanted to appeal to a Division Bench; the High Court’s rules bar Special Appeals from orders in “criminal jurisdiction,” and Ram Kishan Fauji (2017), a three-judge decision, had sorted Article 226 proceedings into civil and criminal for intra-court appeals. In Sanjay Prasad v. Madhusudan Dwivedi, 2026 INSC 1128 the Court held that civil contempt under Article 215 is a special, sui generis civil jurisdiction, not a criminal one — “nomenclature alone cannot answer that question” — and that High Court decisions treating it as criminal “may no longer be good law.” An intra-court appeal lies where the contempt court goes beyond contempt and decides substantive rights, subject to the Letters Patent and the rules; Section 19 of the Contempt of Courts Act covers only appeals against punishment.
“The determinative question is not whether contempt entails punitive consequences, but what jurisdiction the Court was actually exercising when it passed the order impugned.”
Then the larger step: the bench doubted Fauji itself — “Article 226, in plain terms, confers a single, original, special, and extraordinary constitutional jurisdiction” — and referred it to a larger bench through the Chief Justice. The appellant has a fortnight to file his Special Appeal; the contempt is stayed for two months.
Why it matters: Whether a Letters Patent appeal lies from a writ order with a criminal flavour is a question that arises in every High Court every week, and the answer has been Fauji’s binary since 2017. That binary is now under reference; until it is resolved, the contempt route to a Division Bench is open on this judgment’s reasoning.
Reservation: Conversion Does Not Carry Caste-Based Backwardness Into Islam — Sameer Ahamed
Bench: Justices Prashant Kumar Mishra and Shree Chandrashekhar — October 15, 2026
A Tamil Nadu government order allowed converts to Islam from the Backward, Most Backward, Denotified and Scheduled Caste groups to obtain Backward Class Muslim certificates. The Madras High Court struck it down; in Secretary to Government, Tamil Nadu v. Sameer Ahamed N., 2026 INSC 1129 the Supreme Court dismissed the State’s petition. Caste membership alone is not conclusive of the social backwardness Article 16(4) addresses; caste status does not operate the same way in Islam or Christianity; and the disadvantages attached to a former Hindu caste do not travel into a new religion, so conversion does not by itself make a person a member of any of the seven notified Backward Class Muslim communities. Backwardness must be shown on objective criteria — stratification within Muslim communities does not place all Muslims in one class — and a reconvert needs a fresh, fact-specific determination. C. Selvarani (2024) and Kailash Sonkar (1983) were applied.
“The constitutional benefit cannot be made to travel in this manner.”
Why it matters: Read with Selvarani, the rule is now stated twice in two years: a certificate after conversion needs independent proof of backwardness in the new faith, not inherited caste. State governments that have issued converts-by-category orders will need to revisit them.
Religious Endowments: The State Is Custodian, Not Owner, and a Gift of Inam Temple Land Is Void — K. Ramalingam
Bench: Justices P.S. Narasimha and Alok Aradhe — October 16, 2026
In 2017 the temporary trustee of the Nagapalayam Mariamman-Ponnachiamman Temple in Erode gifted an acre and ten cents of inam land to the Government for a Taluk Office. The Madras High Court dismissed the hereditary trustee’s challenge because Section 34 of the Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Act, which requires the Commissioner’s sanction for sales, exchanges and mortgages, says nothing about gifts. In K. Ramalingam v. Government of Tamil Nadu, 2026 INSC 1144 the Court reversed. Because the land is inam property, Section 34(5) takes it out of Section 34 altogether and Section 41 governs — and Section 41 renders the transfer null and void with no sanction mechanism at all. The gift was void ab initio, registration under Section 22-A could not cure it, and a gratuitous transfer cannot be prudent management under Sections 27 and 28. The State under this Act is a custodian and regulator of temple property, not its owner, and “does not cease to be bound by the terms of its custodianship merely because it is also the sovereign.”
“A temple property is held for the deity and not for gratuitous disposal by whoever happens to hold the office of trustee.”
The Taluk Office stays, as a tenant: rent of ₹31,000 a month from 8 March 2019, revisable every three years, arrears in three months; ₹1 lakh costs on the State; and a direction to the State and the Department to comply strictly with Sections 34, 34-A and 41 before any such transaction again.
Why it matters: The regulator cannot be the recipient of what it regulates. Every HR&CE-administered property gifted or “allotted” to a government department in Tamil Nadu is now open to the same challenge, and inam endowments sit under an absolute bar rather than a sanction route.
Insolvency Appeals and PMLA Bail: Sixty Days Means Sixty Days, and “Immediately” Is Not Twenty-Four Hours
Bench: Justices S.V.N. Bhatti and N.V. Anjaria (Ravinuthala); Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M. Pancholi (Sureka) — October 14, 2026
Two timing rules, both reportable. In Assistant Commissioner of Central Tax v. Sreenivasa Rao Ravinuthala, 2026 INSC 1121 the Revenue appealed an NCLAT order of 2 August 2023 on 21 November, counting from receipt of the certified copy on 11 October — applied for on 6 September. The Court held that the forty-five days under Section 62(1) of the Code run from pronouncement, that Section 12(2) of the Limitation Act excludes only the time actually taken to obtain the copy and not the period of inaction before applying for it, and that the fifteen days under Section 62(2) make an absolute ceiling of sixty. Thirty-five days before the application and forty-one after receipt made seventy-six: “the Appeal was filed 16 days beyond the absolute outer limit of this Court’s jurisdiction to condone delay.” Dismissed.
“A litigant cannot claim to await a copy to keep the limitation period suspended.”
In Sanjay Sureka v. Directorate of Enforcement, 2026 INSC 1124 the appellant argued that a five-day gap between his arrest and the forwarding of the order and material to the Adjudicating Authority under Section 19(2) PMLA vitiated the arrest. It did not: the Act fixes no timeline, and “immediately” means as near to simultaneous as administrative necessity allows, not within twenty-four hours. But he had been in custody about twenty months against a seven-year maximum, the investigation against him was complete and the trial could not end soon; on Manish Sisodia, the Section 45 conditions “cannot override the constitutional safeguards under Article 21,” and bail followed. “Process must not be turned into a punishment unto itself.”
Why it matters: Apply for the certified copy the day the NCLAT pronounces — the clock is already running, and it now runs against the government too. On the PMLA, the Sisodia line holds and the Section 19(2) procedural argument is closed.
Arbitration: Two Venues, One Seat; an Interest Bar Read at Full Width; a Non-Signatory Joined — Three Judgments
Bench: Justices Manoj Misra and Vijay Bishnoi (Arcis); Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M. Pancholi (Sharma Enterprises); Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran (Hemant Shah) — October 12 and 15, 2026
A franchise agreement named Delhi in one sub-clause and Goa in the next as the “place of arbitration,” and gave Goa’s courts exclusive jurisdiction; the Delhi High Court appointed the arbitrator. In Arcis Clean Energy Pvt. Ltd. v. Parshva Innovation, 2026 INSC 1109 the Court set that aside: where a clause names two places, the venue-is-seat presumption of BGS SGS SOMA and Arif Azim does not apply, the agreement is read as a whole, and the exclusive-jurisdiction clause decides. “The parties have agreed that Goa shall be the juridical seat, Delhi is just a venue.”
In Sharma Enterprises v. National Building Construction Corporation, 2026 INSC 1135, a 1991 sub-contract’s no-interest clause covered delayed payments, balance payments, withheld deposits “or otherwise”; a 2016 award gave 10 per cent from 1992. The three limbs are not a narrow genus and “or otherwise” is residuary, so pre-reference and pendente lite interest — which Section 31(7)(a) makes subject to agreement — were beyond the arbitrator’s jurisdiction; post-award interest under Section 31(7)(b) cannot be excluded and survives. “The learned Arbitrator, being a creature of the contract, acted beyond his jurisdiction.”
In Hemant D. Shah HUF v. Chittaranjan D. Shah HUF, 2026 INSC 1111, partners inducted by a later deed who had never signed the 1985 arbitration clause were held, prima facie, “veritable parties”: their rights stand only if the disputed retirement deed is valid, so the dispute “would substantially affect their rights.” Cox & Kings and Hindustan Petroleum v. BCL were drawn on; the group-of-companies doctrine was not needed.
Why it matters: Draft one seat. Where a clause has two, the governing-law and jurisdiction clause now decides which High Court appoints. And “or otherwise” in an interest bar will be read as wide as the words — plead pre-award interest only where the contract plainly allows it.
Court Practice: A Vacation Listing Without Notice Was “an Attempt to Steal a March” — Mohammed Kamran
Bench: Justices Dipankar Datta and Sheel Nagu — October 16, 2026
An accused in a ₹43 crore fake-invoice case under the CGST Act, refused bail twice by the Sessions Court and refused interim release by a writ court, had his criminal petition listed urgently in the Karnataka High Court’s winter vacation on his counsel’s memo, without notice to the department, and got bail on 26 December 2025. In Senior Intelligence Officer v. Mohammed Kamran, 2026 INSC 1140 the Court set the order aside and remitted the petition to the same Single Judge, the accused continuing on interim bail meanwhile. Pursuing a challenge to arrest and a bail petition in parallel without disclosing each to the court hearing the other is forum shopping and a want of uberrima fides; the vacation listing was “clearly an attempt to steal a march by even misleading the Court.” For registries the Court added a rule: where a bench directs listing after a period that runs out in vacation, the period should ordinarily be computed excluding the vacation, subject to the High Court’s rules, unless a specific date or the Vacation Bench is fixed.
Why it matters: “List after two weeks” before a vacation no longer means the vacation bench; and a party with two proceedings on the same facts in the same High Court has to say so in both.
Election Offences: A Citizen May Complain of a False Nomination Affidavit — Rajkumar Madki
Bench: Justices Dipankar Datta and Sheel Nagu — October 16, 2026
A private complaint alleged that a Bidar MLA elected in 2023 had given a false residential address in his nomination affidavit, an offence under Section 125-A of the Representation of the People Act. The Karnataka High Court quashed it, holding that only the Election Commission could complain. In Rajkumar Madki v. Shailendra Beldale, 2026 INSC 1138 the Court held the High Court “was clearly in error”: Section 195(1) CrPC bars cognisance only for the Penal Code offences it lists, Section 125-A is not among them and the omission is deliberate, so a private complaint is maintainable. On the facts, the false-address allegation stood rebutted, so the closure before the Magistrate was left undisturbed — with a reminder that Magistrates retain the power to deal with frivolous complaints.
Why it matters: Before the next round of State elections, a false affidavit is now a citizen-prosecutable offence; the filter is the Magistrate at the threshold, not the Commission’s discretion.
Education: The Whole Course’s Fee Must Be on the Table Before Admission — Dr. B.C. Roy Engineering College
Bench: Justices P.S. Narasimha and Alok Aradhe — October 14, 2026
Students admitted to a four-year engineering course in September 2023 found a higher fee and a new development fee from the second semester, after a State notification of 16 October 2023 raised the ceiling. The Calcutta High Court held that a fee fixed at commencement cannot be varied midstream. In Dr. B.C. Roy Engineering College v. State of West Bengal, 2026 INSC 1120 the Supreme Court upheld the result on different reasoning. Fee fixation under Regulation 7 of the AICTE Regulations, 1994 must be completed before admission, and fee committees must work efficiently to make that possible; the Court disagreed that applying a revised fee to existing batches was “retrospective,” and rejected the High Court’s estoppel reasoning from the brochure. The direction, drawn from T.M.A. Pai, Islamic Academy, P.A. Inamdar and the National Education Policy, is that the fee liability for the entire course be notified before admission, with variation during the course only in exceptional cases such as unforeseen cost increases. “The larger principle is thus one of certainty through efficient regulation.”
Why it matters: A binding timetable for every State fee committee and every AICTE institution: fix the course fee first, admit second. Mid-course hikes now need an exceptional justification, and a committee that has not finished its work before counselling has a problem of its own making.
Public Tenders: Cancel an Auction on Evidence, Revisit It Before a Contract Exists, and Do Not Demand the Impossible
Bench: Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M. Pancholi (Dhanlaxmi); Justices P.S. Narasimha and Alok Aradhe (Bedi Hospital); Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran (Hardev Construction) — October 12, 14 and 16, 2026
Three tender judgments that, read together, draw a line. In Dhanlaxmi Merchandise Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Madhya Pradesh, 2026 INSC 1125 the State Mining Corporation cancelled a sand-group e-auction because the highest bids were lower than the same bidders’ earlier, surrendered contracts. The highest bidder has no indefeasible right, but rejection must rest on rational, recorded material — “a previous bid is not, by itself, a continuing adjudication of market value” — and nothing on the record showed what was obtainable in October 2025; an amended surrender rule of January 2026 could not disqualify bidders in an auction already held. Cancellation quashed, allotment in six weeks. In Satinder Pal Singh v. Bedi Hospital, 2026 INSC 1142 the Chandigarh Administration accepted an e-auction bid for a site, then cancelled the bid contract and agreement to sell as not reflecting market trends; the High Court had quashed the cancellation. Reversed: a public authority may revisit an auction to maximise the price of public property so long as no enforceable contract exists, and under the Estate Rules enforceability arises only on the conveyance deed; reasons were given, the money was refunded the same day, and the bidder may bid again. And in Hardev Construction Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India, 2026 INSC 1110 a bid was rejected for not furnishing the “original” bid security after the bidder had paid it through the e-payment gateway. Insisting on an original receipt for an electronic payment was perverse — compliance was impossible and the money was already in the authority’s account — and the deference Prakash Asphaltings requires yields to perversity. “Rigid adherence to the letter of a document cannot be countenanced.”
Why it matters: The State may change its mind about an auction, but with reasons on the record at the time, and only before a binding contract; it may not cancel on a hunch about price, and it may not reject a bid for failing a condition the bidder could not meet.
Drug Pricing: A 30 Per Cent Margin Cap on Cancer Drugs Is “Hardly Anything to Be Happy About”
Bench: Justices Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta — October 12, 2026
The Department of Pharmaceuticals’ affidavit in Kishan Chand Jain told the Court that the pricing authority had decided on 8 October to cap the trade margin on anti-cancer drugs at 30 per cent of the maximum retail price, with an expert committee to list the drugs within a fortnight and an estimated saving of about ₹2,500 crore a year; that hospitals buy from the manufacturers offering the highest margins — 170 to more than 700 per cent on cancer drugs, 100 to more than 1,000 per cent on consumables; and that a uniform margin across all medicines was unworkable. The bench was not impressed. Justice Mehta: “For an ordinary cardiac stent, Indian made stent, price to retailer is Rs. 5000 but MRP is Rs. 25000,” and a saline line with a printed price of ₹270 against a cost of about ₹11; why could the whole range not be regulated, and would the 16 per cent retailer margin the Drug Price Control Order already fixes reduce availability? Listed 27 October.
Why it matters: The same bench ordered the pharmaceutical-marketing committee a week earlier; the two matters are converging on a single question — whether the Court will direct a margin cap across the formulary rather than accept a category at a time. Hospital chains and distributors should expect the next affidavit to be asked for numbers.
Other Notable SC Orders This Week
- Amendment after trial — Haramani Sahoo v. Lalita Nayak, 2026 INSC 1112 (Nagarathna and Mahadevan JJ, October 12) — a plaintiff who discovered a 1998 compromise decree only later, and obtained certified copies in 2020, showed the due diligence the proviso to Order VI Rule 17 requires; an amendment attacking that decree concerns the same property and does not change the nature of the suit. “The real inquiry is whether the amendment introduces a distinct and independent controversy.” Allowed on ₹25,000 costs; limitation left to trial.
- No rent on top of interest — Madhu Kudapa v. Lodha Healthy Constructions, 2026 INSC 1131 (Narasimha and Aradhe JJ, October 15) — on a refund with 12 per cent interest for a flat never delivered, “the award of rent in addition to interest on the full refund would amount to double compensation for the same default”; consumer fora may not award by rule of thumb. Refund of ₹1.27 crore with interest and ₹15 lakh consolidated.
- Attendant charges by the multiplier — Sunil Kumar v. IFFCO Tokio, 2026 INSC 1145 (Bhatti and Anjaria JJ, October 15) — a claimant left dependent on others for life may be assessed at 100 per cent functional disability whatever the medical percentage; attendant charges raised from ₹1 lakh to ₹25.20 lakh by the multiplier method; total ₹77.84 lakh.
- Section 17A is no shield for a bribe demand — Tejaram v. State of Rajasthan, 2026 INSC 1147 (Bhatti and Anjaria JJ, October 16) — prior approval protects recommendations or decisions made in discharge of official functions; “the act of demanding a bribe is a pure criminal act, not connected with official functions.”
- A Letters Patent bench does not re-appreciate — R. Saravanan v. Periyar University, 2026 INSC 1136 (Mishra and Chandrashekhar JJ, October 16) — a Division Bench may interfere with a writ court’s reasonable decision only for glaring, demonstrable error; a disciplinary finding on no evidence is a question of law open under Article 226. Single Judge restored.
- Plead declaration when title is clouded — Rano Singh v. Gurbax Singh, 2026 INSC 1137 (Aravind Kumar and Pancholi JJ, October 16) — a 1975 suit for possession simpliciter against a 1960 registered sale deed was time-barred and not maintainable without a declaration (Anathula Sudhakar); an unregistered agreement to sell confers no title; Section 53A unavailable to plaintiffs out of possession.
- Stranger’s objection in execution — Alladin Charities and Zakat Wakf v. Mohammed Saleem, 2026 INSC 1122 (Bhatti and Anjaria JJ, October 14) — a third party asserting independent title against a decree for possession is entitled to a full inquiry under Order XXI Rule 101 (Periyammal); citing the wrong rule is no ground for dismissal. Remanded.
- A nephew is not “family” — Islam Hussain v. Hajari Lal, 2026 INSC 1123 (Mishra and Chandrashekhar JJ, October 13) — under Section 3(g) of the U.P. Urban Buildings Act, 1972, inducting a nephew through a partnership was subletting; K.V. Muthu distinguished; eviction from the shop within six months.
- Precedent is not a statute — Union of India v. Sgt Girish Kumar, 2026 INSC 1113 (Narasimha and Aradhe JJ, October 12) — the February common judgment on disability pension, decided where entitlement was undisputed, is not authority that arrears are payable in every case; “a difference in facts may make a material difference to the precedential value of a decision.”
- Implead the State — State of Maharashtra v. Sudhir Hiwarkar, 2026 INSC 1118 (Datta and Nagu JJ, October 13) — a writ seeking money from the exchequer without the State on the array is fundamentally defective, and impleading an officer later does not cure it; ₹10 lakh under Article 142 for a lecturer who retired with nothing; expressly no precedent.
- A wrong date is not forgery — Pooja v. State of U.P., 2026 INSC 1119 (Pardiwala and Chandran JJ, October 12) — a death-certificate application with the wrong date of death, later corrected and never used for any benefit, sustains neither Section 420 nor Section 465. Quashed.
- Anti-trafficking units are police stations (October 13) — in Prajwala, Justices Pardiwala and Mahadevan directed every State and Union Territory to notify its Anti-Human Trafficking Units as police stations, found four of the May judgment’s directions on welfare institutions and nodal officers not complied with and “absolutely necessary for the ground-level implementation” of the victim protection plan, and told the Union to take it up with the States and file a fresh status report; 14 December.
- Punjab’s CBI probe (October 12) — Justices Sundresh and Varale, the bench after Justice Nagu’s recusal, declined to stay the FIR into the Chief Minister’s office that the High Court ordered in Nikhil Saraf but directed no coercive steps, with notice to the Centre, the CBI and the Enforcement Directorate.
- CAPF cadre review (October 15) — in the contempt petition before Justices Misra and Bhuyan, the Court found non-compliance with the May 2025 six-month direction “stark,” noted that the Home Ministry’s letters inviting proposals both post-dated the deadline, and asked for the files on action taken; 28 October.
- Journalist’s data (October 14) — the Chief Justice and Justice Bagchi quashed a Ghaziabad police notice to X seeking three months of a journalist’s pre-incident digital data as “an overkill,” directed that nothing obtained under it be used against him, and made his interim protection absolute.
- The Member of Parliament’s Circuit House (October 16) — in Mahua Moitra, the same bench reduced a district magistrate’s three-to-four-day notice requirement to one day and asked the State to withdraw a letter Justice Bagchi called “retaliatory”; “she will have preferential right to stay, not because she is an MP but because she’s representative of that constituency.”
- A pedestrian crossing, or a dharna (October 16) — in S. Rajaseekaran, Justice Pardiwala said that if the crossing outside the Delhi High Court on Mathura Road is not built by 25 November “the judges will have to come and stage a dharna near it”; the Centre’s unannounced interim-compensation scheme under Section 164A of the Motor Vehicles Act is to be gazetted and publicised, and notice went to the Ministry over the unpublished 2025 road-accident report.
- Hookah bars (October 15) — Justices Narasimha and Aradhe issued notice on a challenge to the Allahabad High Court’s ruling that hookah cannot be served even in designated smoking areas; 27 November.
- Sringeri recount (October 14) — Justices Sanjay Kumar and Sachdeva told the Election Commission it “can’t act so irresponsibly” after it said the counting video could not be traced because officers had been transferred, and directed production of the records.
- Bail and trials — the former principal of R.G. Kar Medical College granted bail in the CBI’s financial-irregularities case after more than two years in custody with seven of 147 witnesses examined (Sundresh and Varale JJ, October 15); the Mumbai criminal-defamation trial against the Leader of the Opposition over “commander-in-thief” stayed, with notice (Nath and Aparesh Kumar Singh JJ, October 12); the Bhopal trial in the Twisha Sharma death stayed on the father’s transfer plea (October 16); Tarun Tejpal’s appeal and Goa’s enhancement plea adjourned to 3 November (October 15); a Haren Pandya murder lifer’s premature-release plea dismissed with liberty to go to the High Court (October 12).
- Also this week — the Union said airfare-pricing rules are finalised and will be published within two weeks (Nath, Mahadevan and Aparesh Kumar Singh JJ, October 16); the External Affairs Ministry was asked to detail the compensation Russia has paid for Indians recruited into its army, with a public notice suggested since only six of fifty-one families have claimed (October 14); a fresh plea for guidelines on all forms of talaq was tagged with the pending Talaq-e-Hasan petition (October 16); the demolition of a church in Tenkasi was stayed (October 16); the Chief Justice’s bench floated a single December election date for the Supreme Court, High Court and district bars of Delhi (with Viswanathan J, October 14); a NEET-UG OMR challenge was listed urgently because the agency’s ninety-day record-destruction window was expiring (October 14); the firecrackers matter saw no directions on Monday — “What does religion have to do with firecrackers?” Justice Bagchi asked — with suggestions sent to the Commission for Air Quality Management, and no outcome from Thursday’s listing of the barium tests was reported; Kerala’s Chief Minister’s challenge to the Vigilance FIR direction will be listed after the break, Luthra having said that “otherwise, an 82-year-old gentleman will be put in custody” (October 16).
Insolvency & Corporate
IBC: Default Is a Fixed Fact and Quantum Is Not — the Section 7 Standard Restated, and Fabricated Citations in a Supreme Court Filing — Deepak Raheja
Bench: Justices Dipankar Datta and Augustine George Masih — October 15, 2026
Two hotel companies resisted Section 7 petitions by an asset reconstruction company on assigned loans by disputing the accounts and pointing to positive operating earnings. In Deepak Raheja v. Omkara Assets Reconstruction Pvt. Ltd., 2026 INSC 1134 the Court dismissed the appeals and let the resolution processes run. Section 7 is a summary jurisdiction: the Adjudicating Authority asks only whether a debt and a default exist, on a preponderance of probabilities from the record, without a forensic reconciliation of accounts. The occurrence of a default is a fixed past event while the quantum outstanding is dynamic, so the exact liability need not be fixed at admission and quantification belongs to the claims process. An Information Utility record of default carries high evidentiary value and is displaced only by “clear, cogent, credible and compelling material”; absent one, the Form 1 documents may collectively prove default. Profitability is no answer once default is shown — one company’s debt-service coverage was 0.12.
“Before parting, we wish to advert to an undesirable incident that transpired in course of hearing.”
The incident was the appellants’ compilation, which contained judgments that do not exist — generated by an AI tool. The Advocate-on-Record blamed the clients; senior counsel apologised. The Court had proposed exemplary costs and dropped them only because the first appellant had died during the appeal, which it held did not abate.
Why it matters: “We are solvent” and “the figures are disputed” are no longer defences to admission, and an unchallenged Information Utility record is close to conclusive. The other half of the judgment is a warning every chamber should circulate: the Supreme Court has now recorded fabricated citations in a filing, named the consequence it had in mind, and withheld it for a reason that will not recur.
NCLAT: A Liquidation Order Must Engage With the Creditors’ Unanimous Vote, and a Suspended Liquidator Cannot Keep His Other Assignments
National Company Law Appellate Tribunal, Justice Mohammad Faiz Alam Khan and Naresh Salecha — October 14 and 16, 2026
In Phoenix ARC v. Rajesh Jhunjhunwala the corporate debtor’s principal asset was a ₹318.94 crore arbitral award against Maharashtra’s Public Works Department, under Section 34 challenge. The Committee of Creditors unanimously rejected liquidation in July and sought a further 120 days, with eight fresh expressions of interest in hand; the Tribunal ordered liquidation anyway, partly on an unpleaded concern that ₹397 crore of accumulated tax losses might be monetised. The Appellate Tribunal set the order aside on 16 October: the Adjudicating Authority must compare the realisable value, timelines and cost of pursuing the award inside resolution against liquidation, and may not decide on a point never put to the resolution professional or the committee. Restoration is not automatic, but the committee’s decision must be engaged with. The parties are before the Tribunal on 26 October.
Two days earlier, in Kannan Tiruvengadam v. IBBI, the Appellate Tribunal refused to stay a two-year suspension imposed on a liquidator who had sold a ₹506 crore steel plant by private sale without the stakeholders’ committee’s advice or the Tribunal’s approval he had undertaken to seek — and refused to stay the Board’s direction that he be replaced in six other assignments: once a professional is prima facie tainted he cannot continue as resolution professional elsewhere. Final hearing 18 November.
Why it matters: A litigation asset is not a reason to liquidate, and a Tribunal that overrides a unanimous committee has to show its working. On discipline, replacement across every assignment is now the default consequence of a suspension, interim relief or not.
NCLT: A Government Company Is a “Corporate Person” — Karnataka’s Civil Supplies Corporation Admitted, Subject to Settlement
National Company Law Tribunal, Bengaluru — Sunil Kumar Aggarwal (Judicial) and Radhakrishna Sreepada (Technical) — October 12, 2026
A gunny-bag supplier filed under Section 9 for about ₹19.25 crore against the Karnataka Food and Civil Supplies Corporation, a State government company that runs the public distribution system. The corporation argued that its public-welfare function took it outside the Code. The Tribunal disagreed: a company incorporated under the Companies Act is a corporate person under Section 3(7) whatever its functions, it exercises no sovereign power, and Hindustan Construction — which concerned the National Highways Authority, a statutory body — does not help it. The admission was kept in abeyance until 31 October to allow a settlement.
Why it matters: Every State’s trading and procurement corporations are companies, and their suppliers now have a Bengaluru ruling that the Code’s door is open to them. Expect a settlement before the 31st — and expect other benches to be shown this order.
Other Notable Insolvency Orders
- Sixty days from pronouncement (October 14) — the Supreme Court’s Ravinuthala ruling on Section 62 limitation is in the Highlights above; it applies to the government as to anyone else.
- Your own TDS proves the supply (NCLAT, October 14) — in Girraj Bansal v. Rakesh Kumar Goyal the corporate debtor’s tax deductions and input-credit claims on the supplier’s invoices established the supply it was disputing; Section 9 admission upheld.
- No buy-out without a finding (NCLAT, October 14) — in Sanjit Instruments v. Bagul a share buy-out under Section 242(2)(b) of the Companies Act cannot be ordered without a prior finding of oppression or mismanagement, and not on a stale valuation; remanded to Mumbai.
- Stamp duty on a liquidation sale (Bombay High Court, order dated October 17) — in Bhadrashree Steel & Power v. State of Maharashtra the duty on a liquidator’s auction sale may be charged on the auction price of ₹8.03 crore rather than the ready-reckoner rate, “civil court” in Article 16 of the Schedule to the Maharashtra Stamp Act being read to include the Tribunal.
- Not yet — no notification of the personal-guarantor safeguards, no new regulation, circular or discussion paper from the Board this week, no circular from the Tribunal since September, nothing on the National Tribunals Commission, and no reported order on the lenders’ appeal in the Subhash Chandra matter.
From the High Courts
Reservation: Karnataka’s 56 Per Cent Falls — the 50 Per Cent Ceiling “Circumscribes the Power of the State”
Karnataka High Court, Chief Justice Vibhu Bakhru and Justice K.S. Hemalekha — October 12, 2026
The Karnataka Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Reservation of Seats in Educational Institutions and of Appointments or Posts) Act, 2022 raised the Scheduled Caste quota from 15 to 17 per cent and the Scheduled Tribe quota from 3 to 7, taking the State’s aggregate reservation to 56 per cent. In Mahendra Kumar Mitra v. Secretary, Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment the Division Bench struck down Sections 3 and 4 as violating Articles 14, 15 and 16. The 50 per cent ceiling binds, and population growth, proportional representation, the non-percolation of benefits and the separate economically-weaker-sections quota — carved from the general pool — are not the “extraordinary circumstances” Indra Sawhney contemplated; Article 16(4) is about adequate, not proportionate, representation, and the Nagamohan Das Commission had not compared representation against the forward classes. The State had also failed the mandatory consultation with the National Commissions under Articles 338(9) and 338A(9): “merely writing a letter after enacting the Act cannot be considered as consultation.” The State has said it will appeal.
“The ceiling limit of 50 per cent has to be understood as circumscribing the power of the State.”
Why it matters: A week after Madhya Pradesh’s 27 per cent OBC quota fell in Jabalpur, a second State’s post-2019 quota expansion has been struck on the same ceiling, with the consultation point as an independent ground. The Supreme Court will now have two appeals asking the same question, and every State that has legislated past 50 per cent since the EWS amendment has a reason to read both.
UAPA and Protest: A Charge Is No “Blanket” Bar on Travel, and Presence at a Demonstration Is No Offence — Delhi High Court
Delhi High Court, Justice Amit Bansal (Narwal) and Justice Sanjeev Narula (Khurshid Ahmed) — October 16 and 13, 2026
Natasha Narwal, on bail since 2021 in the Delhi riots conspiracy case, sought to travel to the United Kingdom for a month to present at a conference and meet her doctoral supervisor; the trial court refused on 6 October. On Friday Justice Bansal set that aside and permitted the trip from 2 November to 1 December. The UAPA charge “does not curtail her right to travel abroad in a blanket manner”; she had been on bail for five years with no violation alleged, her family is in the Capital, and the trial horizon is long — “the trial will take 20 years,” the judge said in court. “You cannot keep the person here.” A ₹1 lakh bond with her brother as surety, no asylum application, no comment on the merits, visa and itinerary to the investigating officer, the look-out circular suspended for the trip, and the passport back within forty-eight hours of return.
Earlier in the week Justice Narula quashed an FIR under Sections 223(a) and 3(5) of the BNS against a participant in last August’s examination-aspirants’ protest at Ramlila Maidan: “mere participation in the same demonstration does not, by itself, establish a common intention to disobey lawful directions,” and presence among protesters “cannot, without more, be treated as sufficient to establish the offence.”
Why it matters: Both are Maneka Gandhi propositions stated plainly in the week the Supreme Court took on Section 172 BNSS. For the hundreds detained or booked in Delhi on 10 October, Khurshid Ahmed is the first authority to cite.
Anti-Corruption: The Chief Minister May Not Appeal the FIR Direction — Kerala High Court
Kerala High Court, Justices K. Natarajan and Johnson John — October 15, 2026
Justice Badharudeen’s 9 October direction to the Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau to register an FIR on the Enforcement Directorate’s information in the CMRL–Exalogic matter, and his setting aside of the Government’s special investigation team, were challenged by the Chief Minister, his daughter and the former Minister P.A. Mohammed Riyas in writ appeals. A stay was refused on Tuesday; on Thursday the Division Bench dismissed the leave petitions themselves. The judgment “has not affected the right of the applicants”: an accused has no right of hearing before an FIR is registered and no right to demand a preliminary inquiry where the information comes with sufficient material. Constitutional and statutory remedies against the FIR, once registered, remain open — “so long as cognizance of an offence is not taken, a writ petition under Article 226” lies. On Friday the Chief Minister’s counsel mentioned a petition in the Supreme Court; the Chief Justice said it would be listed after the Dussehra break, possibly earlier before a vacation bench. Whether the Bureau has in fact registered the FIR is not confirmed by any report.
Why it matters: The Kerala bench has closed the intra-court route by denying locus at the pre-FIR stage, which is the orthodox position and leaves the Supreme Court as the only forum before registration. Read with the Punjab matter, where the Supreme Court this week refused to stay the CBI’s FIR into the Chief Minister’s office but barred coercive steps, the pattern for a sitting Chief Minister is now: no stay, no arrest, and a hearing after the break.
Federalism: “From Political Angle” Is Not a Reason — the Chief Minister’s France Trip Is Cleared by the Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court, Justice Tribhuvan Dahiya — October 16, 2026
The External Affairs Ministry declined political clearance for Punjab’s Chief Minister to attend a food-industry exhibition in Paris, saying only that clearance was declined “from political angle.” In State of Punjab v. Union of India the Court annulled the refusal. “It has not been explained what that political angle/viewpoint is,” and reasons supplied later by affidavit cannot save an unreasoned order (Mohinder Singh Gill). The requirement that the Ministry examine the Chief Minister’s “functional role” was “superfluous” where the refusal rested on the political angle alone; the record showed the invitation, the State’s trade stall, the State’s approval and the purpose. The Centre was directed to approve the visit urgently and extend protocol. The Additional Solicitor General’s submission — “we don’t want anything happens to CM abroad” — was recorded.
Why it matters: A writ court striking down a Ministry’s political-clearance decision for a sitting Chief Minister is rare, and it was done on administrative-law basics rather than on federal principle. The same State’s Chief Secretary was before the same Court on a contempt notice this week; no report of that listing has surfaced.
Election Petitions: A Chief Minister’s Appeal to Children Is “in Bad Taste” but Not a Corrupt Practice — Madras High Court
Madras High Court, Justice D. Bharatha Chakravarthy (Sivakumar); Chief Justice Sushrut Arvind Dharmadhikari and Justice G. Arul Murugan (resignations) — October 13 and 15, 2026
The DMK’s election petition against the Salem North MLA of Tamizhaga Vettri Kazhagam alleged that Chief Minister Vijay’s campaign appeal to children to persuade their parents to vote for his party was undue influence. In K. Sivakumar v. R. Rajendran, on an application under Order VII Rule 11, Justice Chakravarthy rejected the petition: “the entire act of involving tender children is in bad taste,” and “making reels out of it is cheap and politically motivated,” but it does not overpower adult free will, was not the returned candidate’s act or with his consent, and a breach of a Commission circular is not an “order” under Section 100(1)(d)(iv). “Neither Section 123(2) nor Section 100(1)(d) nor Section 100(1)(d)(ii) include such an act of campaigning.” Security refunded. On Tuesday the First Bench upheld the Speaker’s acceptance of six AIADMK legislators’ resignations, two of whom have since won bye-elections for the ruling party. Justice Lakshminarayanan heard the Chief Minister’s own application to reject the Perambur petition against him on Wednesday and reserved orders without a date; the First Bench’s judgment on the five-seat bye-election challenge, reserved on 1 October, has not come.
Why it matters: The threshold for an election petition in Tamil Nadu’s new political order is being set now, and it is being set high: pleaded facts, consent of the candidate, and a statutory ground — not a Commission circular and not a campaign’s taste.
Bombay: The Special Public Security Act Challenge Waits on the Petitioners’ Papers, and the Mumbai Detentions Get a Hearing
Bombay High Court, Chief Justice Mahesh Chandra Tripathi and Justice Advait Sethna — October 13 and 16, 2026
The Congress, the People’s Union for Civil Liberties and the trade-union federation AITUC challenged the Maharashtra Special Public Security Act; Navroz Seervai argued vagueness, a chilling effect, and that the Act is harsher than the UAPA because it allows demolition of property. On Friday the Chief Justice’s bench declined to begin on the merits until the petitioners placed their registration, constitution and office-bearers on record — “we want to see the credentials of the petitioners before proceeding to hear the matter on merits” — and adjourned without a date. On Tuesday, on a public-interest petition alleging that some six hundred people were detained in Mumbai on 10 October and three hundred the next day, the Chief Justice said, “We will take care of the issue but obviously we will not permit this,” asked for specific instances, and listed it for Monday. The actor Imran Khan, a United States citizen and overseas-citizen cardholder detained near August Kranti Maidan that Saturday and served a “Leave India” notice within five days requiring his departure by 28 October, filed a challenge to be mentioned on Monday; no order yet. Justices Kulkarni and Gokhale heard the National Investigation Agency’s appeal against Sachin Waze’s bail through the week — “Why is this a terrorist act? Only because there were explosives?” — and reserved orders on Friday; he stays in custody under the September stay.
Why it matters: Three Bombay threads converge on Monday, 19 October, and a fourth is reserved. The credentials direction in the Security Act challenge is a reminder that an organisational petitioner has to prove it exists before it can prove a statute is unconstitutional.
Other Notable High Court Orders
- “Scant respect” for liberty (Delhi, Kathpalia J, reported October 15) — bail was granted in a 2022 murder case after a “completely botched up investigation,” recording “the scant respect that the local police has shown … concerning liberty of an individual.”
- Educomp’s SFIO probe quashed (Delhi, Mahajan J, October 16) — the Centre’s 2018 order under Section 212(1)(c) of the Companies Act referring Educomp Solutions to the Serious Fraud Investigation Office was unreasoned and mechanical: inspection reports found no siphoning, a newspaper report and a legislator’s letter were not enough, and “mere presence of material is of no consequence unless the same is discernible from the order itself.”
- “No Added Sugar” stays on the pack (Delhi, Mahajan J, October 16) — the food regulator’s direction to Britannia to drop “No Added Sugar / No Maida / No Palm Oil” was stayed as prima facie statements of fact rather than advertisements disparaging rivals; “100% Millets” dropped without prejudice; 15 January.
- Delhi’s revision, two readings (Delhi, Mehta and Choudhary JJ, reported October 16) — the Division Bench held that deleted voters may file Form 6 and that the fear of a false-declaration prosecution is “misplaced,” the same week the Supreme Court advanced its own hearing on the same form to 28 October; the Youth Congress’s challenge to the de-notification of Jantar Mantar got notice before Justice Mahajan (October 13; 17 November), and the police’s assurance of “appropriate steps” against the protest’s organiser was recorded in a Palika Bazar vendor’s petition (Acting Chief Justice Sambre and Sharma J, October 15; 3 November).
- The journalist’s SC/ST Act FIR (Delhi, Pushkarna J, October 16) — the High Court refused to stay the probe into the woman journalist booked on an Assistant Commissioner’s complaint — “No no. Not like this” — a day after the Supreme Court gave her interim protection; the police are to respond after the break.
- Special prosecutors for POCSO (Kerala, Chief Justice Sen and Syam Kumar J, October 14) — the government order allowing POCSO prosecutors to take Juvenile Justice Act cases was held unsustainable against In re Alarming Rise; exclusive prosecutors within six weeks, and thirteen more exclusive courts to be considered.
- A detention order the detenu could not read (Kerala, Narendran and Muralee Krishna JJ, reported October 16) — a Kannada speaker’s KAAPA detention was quashed for want of a translated order: “the fundamental right guaranteed to him under Article 22(5) of the Constitution of India was denied to him.”
- No stay on the Waqf Board’s reconstitution (Kerala, Manu J, Saturday October 17) — the 16 October reconstitution stands subject to the outcome; “no case is made out to pass a stringent interim order.”
- Four years suspended on 75 per cent of the fine (Kerala, Badharudeen J, October 15) — the former police chief Tomin Thachankary’s disproportionate-assets sentence was suspended pending appeal on deposit of ₹23 lakh; “prima facie, the finding of the learned Special Judge could not be faulted.”
- A minister’s PMLA bail refused (Punjab and Haryana, Kuldeep Tiwari J, October 16) — in Sanjeev Arora v. Enforcement Directorate an officer on a FEMA search may inform the police of a cognisable offence, the Section 45 conditions apply before the High Court, a Section 50 summons is no precondition to a Section 19 arrest, and the material disclosed “a clear case of trade-based money laundering.”
- Three quashings in Bengaluru (Karnataka, Nagaprasanna J, October 16) — the FIR against Amit Malviya over a post on the Leader of the Opposition was quashed, as were the Istanbul-convention-centre broadcast cases against him and Arnab Goswami; a doctor’s cases over an illegal-immigrant complaint were quashed with a direction to constitute district committees under the Home Ministry’s procedure within three months; and an earlier order permitting a private complaint against the Kharge family was recalled because the family had not been heard (30 October). Earlier in the week the Dharwad bench stayed the investigation into the bulk-deletion FIR against Dr Ravi Patil (Venkatesh Naik J, October 13; 29 October) and Justice Poonacha ordered Meta to restore a party spokesperson’s accounts except the links a Magistrate had ordered down (October 13; 12 November).
- Custodial death, no bail (Orissa, Narasingh J, October 14) — a sub-inspector, an assistant sub-inspector and a constable charged over a 2017 death in custody with twenty-four injuries were refused bail: “society governed by the rule of law expects discipline, not death, in custody,” and a history-sheet “cannot dilute the constitutional protection available to him.”
- Death commuted (Calcutta, Shampa Sarkar and Smita Das De JJ, October 14) — the death sentence of a man who murdered his wife and eighteen-month-old daughter was commuted to life: not the rarest of rare, and the trial court had called for no report on his conduct in custody. The same week Justice Tirthankar Ghosh refused Sujit Bose bail for the third time in the municipal-recruitment money-laundering case (October 13); the Chief Justice’s bench stayed a single judge’s protection order for a party’s Durga Puja book stall on a State highway for suppression of a Public Works e-mail (October 16); and the Registry reported that “there is no masjid constructed on the rooftop of the High Court building,” only a locked room with religious texts whose keys an advocate holds, who was impleaded (PIL order uploaded October 15; 14 December).
- Dal Lake goes quiet (Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh, Chief Justice Bhati and Sekhri J, October 14) — every fuel-powered motorboat, motorised shikara and jet-ski barred from the lake until further orders, breach to be treated as contempt, a policy on electric alternatives to be explored; 30 October.
- Reliance keeps the Jamnagar land (Gujarat, Devan Desai J, October 14) — the State’s 2008 reconsideration of a 1993 allotment was set aside, a thirty-three-year delay by the original allottee’s heirs “could not be overlooked.” Justice Pinto recused from the journalist Ravi Nair’s revision in the Adani defamation case — “Not before this Court” (October 13).
- Firecrackers, all year (Bombay, Kulkarni and Gokhale JJ, October 15) — the September order banning crackers, loud music and lasers on roads and in silence zones applies to every festival across Maharashtra: “there cannot be any distinction between different festivities taking place throughout the year”; 25 November.
- Route marches (Madras, Lakshminarayanan J, October 15 and 16) — the Advocate General undertook permission for two RSS marches by 19 October, and the police were told not to deny in future; “citizens’ rights cannot be surrendered to the whims and fancies of the police,” and the State’s reliance on a minority community’s objection was “a classic case of using a scalpel not for operation but to kill the patient.”
- Also this week — the Telangana High Court recorded the Commission’s assurance of reasoned orders on every mismatch notice in the revision, with the final roll due 9 November (Acting Chief Justice Koshy and Nandikonda J, October 13); the Madhya Pradesh High Court disposed of habeas petitions by people detained on their way to the Delhi protest after the State said they had “returned to their families” (reported October 13); the Allahabad High Court’s reserved judgment on the journalist Satyam Verma’s National Security Act detention has not come; a Gujarat bench dropped criminal contempt against a lawyer on an apology and ₹1 lakh to a cancer hospital (order uploaded October 15).
At the Bar
The Bar Pulled Two Ways: Petitions Over the Detained Lawyers, a Letter Against the March, and a Contempt Petition Over the Chief Justice
Supreme Court of India and the Bar — October 12–17, 2026
The Advocates-on-Record Association’s writ, filed on Sunday and reported on Monday, names the advocates-on-record who were taken to a sports complex on 10 October, Senior Advocate Shadan Farasat — carried by his arms and legs, shirt torn, on video — and two women advocates manhandled by officers without name tags, and asks for an “independent, impartial, time-bound inquiry”; the Bar Association’s petition asks for a status report, the Section 163 orders and preservation of body-camera footage, and challenges the closure of the Supreme Court Metro station “without consulting the Chief Justice of India.” The Lawyers’ Association for Constitution filed a third. On Monday morning Gopal Sankaranarayanan told the Chief Justice’s bench, “I have never seen lawyers being dragged through the streets”; the Chief Justice: “Every lawyer, every member of the Bar, has the right to be part of peaceful activities.” The Delhi High Court Bar wore black ribbons on Monday; on Tuesday at 1.15 pm the Bar stood in silence at the Gandhi statue; the District Bar Association, Chandigarh, observed a no-work day on Thursday “in strong protest against the reported humiliation and mistreatment of Advocates.” On Thursday the Court’s order preserved the footage; it directed no inquiry, and the Bar’s petitions sit in the batch for 19 November.
The other current ran the other way. On Monday evening the Opposition’s march reached the Court’s premises; by Wednesday about two hundred members had written to the Bar Association seeking a resolution condemning a “mob of thousands of supporters to pressurize the judicial process,” and the Association had served a show-cause on one of its own members over a confrontation with its President on the Court’s lawns. On Thursday the Bar Council of Delhi wrote to the Chief Justice condemning “uncorroborated, sensational allegations” against judges on digital platforms. On Friday the Bar Association’s criminal-contempt petition against the journalist Nikhil Wagle and the Member of Parliament Sanjay Raut, filed with the Attorney General’s consent over remarks about the Chief Justice, drew notice from the Chief Justice and Justice Bagchi; both had apologised publicly, personal appearance was dispensed with. “Courts have never lagged behind in protecting rights,” the Chief Justice said. “If you still keep condemning, it’s very unfortunate.” On Saturday the Association’s Joint Secretary served a legal notice on the Kerala Congress president over a deleted post telling the Chief Justice to “resign now.”
“Hope better sense prevails on everyone.”
Why it matters: The Bar’s institutions spent the week as petitioner against the police and as petitioner against the Court’s critics, within four days of each other. The detained lawyers’ petitions got preservation, not an inquiry; the contempt petition got notice in a day. Members will draw their own conclusions about where the Association’s weight went.
The BCI Office Assault: A Special Investigation Team, Not the CBI — “You Seem More Interested in Prosecuting the Chairman Than the Assailants”
Bench: Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana — October 12, 2026
Lawyers protesting outside the Bar Council of India’s office in the early hours of 21 August, demanding the Chairman’s resignation, were assaulted; a complaint was lodged the next day and no FIR followed; the Delhi High Court refused a CBI probe in September. On Monday the Chief Justice’s bench directed the Commissioner of Police to constitute a special investigation team headed by an officer of Deputy Commissioner rank, reporting to the jurisdictional Magistrate, and left the petitioners free to file a private complaint. Prashant Bhushan pressed for an independent agency; Justice Bagchi: “You seem more interested in prosecuting the BCI Chairman than the assailants. He was never there.” And: “The Court will give you access, your clients have a right to fair investigation, and we are here to ensure that.”
Why it matters: A court-directed team with a magistrate’s oversight is what the petitioners got, two months after an assault on lawyers at the regulator’s door went uninvestigated. The regulator’s own reconstitution timetable, the women’s quota and the age limit for law courses produced no listing and no report this week.
Meghalaya: The Bar’s Office-Bearers Purge Their Contempt, and “the Majesty of Law Stands Restored”
Meghalaya High Court, Chief Justice Revati Mohite Dere and Justice H.S. Thangkhiew — October 14, 2026
The Shillong Bar Association and the High Court Bar had resolved on 30 September to abstain from work until the Advocate General was removed, over remarks he made in court about the Bar’s handling of a woman intern’s complaint; the Court issued criminal-contempt notices on 8 October and the call was withdrawn the next day. On the return date the office-bearers tendered unconditional apologies and undertook not to join any similar abstention. The Court accepted them: “We find that the unconditional apology tendered is bona fide and sincere,” “all the contemnors have shown genuine regret and remorse,” and “this Court is of the view that the majesty of law stands restored.” Proceedings were dropped against two who had resigned earlier and two who showed they had appeared in court.
Why it matters: The sequence — strike resolution, contempt notice within eight days, withdrawal the next day, apology and discharge within a fortnight — is the template Harish Uppal contemplates, and it worked without a single punishment. Other High Courts facing abstentions this winter have the order to point to.
Court Fees: Is an Uncapped Ad Valorem Fee Valid? The Supreme Court Will Examine Kerala’s Hike
Bench: Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justice Joymalya Bagchi — October 16, 2026
The Kerala Finance Act, 2025 raised court fees across the board — by several hundred per cent in some classes and far more in others — and exempted the State itself. On the High Court Advocates’ Association’s petition the Court issued notice limited to one question: whether an ad valorem fee with no upper ceiling is valid. Justice Bagchi observed that judicial time in commercial disputes “must come at a price”; the Chief Justice, on the State’s self-exemption: “The right hand will be paying the left hand.”
Why it matters: The last word on court fees as a tax on justice is decades old, and every State’s revenue department is watching Kerala’s experiment. A ruling that an uncapped fee is unconstitutional would reach every High Court’s fee schedule.
Other Notable at the Bar
- Appointments — the Centre appointed two judicial officers, Dharmalingam Lingeswaran and Balathandayutham Karthikeyan, as Additional Judges of the Madras High Court on Tuesday, five months after the Collegium’s recommendation; no Collegium resolution was published this week, and the Supreme Court’s thirty-eighth seat and the three High Courts under Acting Chief Justices remain as they were. On Sunday the Chief Justice inaugurated the Ladakh bench of the Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh High Court at Leh, with Justices Sundresh, Narasimha and Palli and the Attorney General present; sittings begin on 21 October before Chief Justice Bhati and Justice Parihar, with seventy-five cases identified.
- One election day for Delhi (October 14) — the Chief Justice and Justice Viswanathan floated a single December date for the Supreme Court, High Court and district bar elections to end multiple voting — some 28,000 members and about 3,400 votes at the last Association poll — and called a term cap “too harsh and disproportionate”; a status report on the May order was sought.
- A hundred-year-old Senior Advocate (Kerala, October 12) — P.B. Menon of Palakkad, at the Bar for about seventy-six years, was designated under the High Court’s 2026 rules.
- Bar Council of Delhi (October 14) — Nitin Ahlawat elected Chairman, Sangeeta Sondhi Vice-Chairman, Ramit Sehrawat Secretary; Piyush Gupta goes to the Bar Council of India.
- Calcutta (October 12) — on the lawyer-safety petition, Chief Justice Ghuge proposed metal detectors at the High Court and the district courts and asked the Bar Council and every lawyers’ body to decide and write to him; egg-pelting at three courts and an alleged attack at Senior Advocate Bikash Ranjan Bhattacharya’s residence were flagged; 11 December. The same bench warned a former judicial officer of “aggravated contempt” for grounds of appeal suggesting a judge could not hear him fairly (October 15).
- Kochi (October 13) — the High Court’s Registrar General barred a lawyers’ association from staging a “symbolic impeachment” of the Chief Election Commissioner on the Court’s premises; the event moved to a car porch.
- Said this week — the Chief Justice at the National Law School’s rescheduled convocation on Saturday: “hearing before judging, distinguishing a person from a position and disagreeing without denying another person’s dignity.” Justice Kurian Joseph, on Tuesday, on the Court as guardian: “the guardian is bound to bite also if the barking does not lead to the desired result.” Justice Sudhanshu Dhulia, in the Sir Syed lecture: “In my opinion, Sharjeel Imam and Umar Khalid should have been granted bail a long time ago.” Kapil Sibal, at a press conference: “the one thing they have not been able to capture is the Supreme Court of India.” Rebecca John, in an interview: “The architecture of law is designed to make protests as unpalatable as possible.”
Legislative & Regulatory Watch
Payments: The UPI Merchant Charge Is Deferred to “Immediately Post Diwali” — No Date, No Change in Rates
National Payments Corporation of India, UPI and Services Steering Committee — October 13, 2026
The 0.4 per cent charge on person-to-merchant UPI payments above ₹2,000 — capped at ₹300, with flat and reduced rates for railways, telecom, fuel, insurance and capital-market payments, split four ways between the issuer, the acquirer, the app and its sponsor bank, never charged to the customer — was to take effect on Thursday under the September circular. On Tuesday the steering committee deferred it: the charge “shall be implemented immediately post Diwali on a date to be notified separately.” No new date, no revised rates, no fresh circular number. The Supreme Court’s petition, in which the Centre, the Reserve Bank and the Corporation have until about 26 October to file, was not listed.
Why it matters: Every merchant-acquiring contract and app-pricing schedule drafted for a 15 October start is now conditional on a notification that has not issued. Watch for the fresh circular, and for the turnover exemption that has been reported as under consideration but not confirmed.
Securities: The Closing Auction Is Cut to Ten Minutes, and Derivatives Expire on the Half-Hour VWAP Again
Securities and Exchange Board of India, Market Regulation Department — October 15, 2026
Nine months after the January circular that introduced a closing auction session, the Board has rewritten it. From 7 December the session is a separate ten minutes from 3.30 to 3.40 — a minute of reference-price and transition, five minutes of limit and market orders, four minutes of limit orders only, with a system-driven random close between 3.38 and 3.40 — and the reference price is the volume-weighted average of the last fifteen minutes of continuous trading. Index derivatives trade to 3.45 on every day except expiry, when expiring index contracts cease at 3.30; stock derivatives trade to 3.45 including expiry. The change that matters most is in settlement: expiring index contracts settle on an index computed from constituents’ VWAP in the last thirty minutes of continuous trading, and stock contracts on the thirty-minute VWAP across exchanges — the auction no longer sets derivative settlement prices. Unexecuted limit orders carry into the session; iceberg orders carry as fully disclosed limit orders with lower time priority unless the participant opts out; the carry-over and iceberg provisions take effect on 8 February 2027. Exchanges and clearing corporations have seven days to revise their procedures.
Why it matters: The January design had the closing auction setting expiry prices, which concentrated expiry-day pressure into a single print; the September consultation said so and the Board has reversed it. Trading-desk compliance and algorithm documentation need updating before December, and exchange bye-law amendments will follow within the week.
Forex: The 20 Per Cent Risk Reserve Reaches Banks’ Own Hedges, and Non-Deliverable Contracts Are for Hedging Only
Reserve Bank of India — October 12 and 15, 2026
Two days after the Saturday package that capped unhedged-exposure derivatives at $5 million and imposed a 20 per cent cash reserve on rupee derivatives above $2 million, the Bank extended the reserve. Under A.P. (DIR Series) Circular No. 27, the Foreign Exchange Risk Reserve applies also to rupee derivatives an authorised dealer undertakes to hedge its own asset-liability currency risk where it buys foreign currency against the rupee — 20 per cent of the rupee-equivalent notional, in cash with the Bank, maintained daily until termination, for contracts entered after issue — and non-deliverable rupee derivatives may be offered to non-residents only for hedging, no longer for any purpose. Thursday’s frequently-asked-questions settle the mechanics: the reserve attaches where the user buys foreign currency against the rupee above $2 million for a current-account hedge, not where the user sells, not to capital-account hedges, not to non-rupee contracts, not to market-making or proprietary positions; options are measured by the highest-notional leg; roll-overs are fresh contracts; the reserve runs from the next business day to the day after termination, pro rata on partial cancellation, reported by 5 pm the next day, and earns no interest.
Why it matters: A zero-interest 20 per cent cash reserve is a direct cost on every importer’s and every borrower’s large hedge and now on the bank’s own book, and the FAQ’s $2 million threshold invites tranching the Bank may close next. Treasury counsel should re-read ISDA schedules and hedging policies for whose cost this is.
Other Notable Regulatory Moves
- Freeze the promoters’ demat accounts (SEBI consultation, October 13) — proposed mandatory monitoring agencies for every issuance other than offers for sale, with agencies free to report non-cooperation to the exchanges, a ₹50,000 fine per instance, and escalation to notice to promoters and a freeze on their demat accounts after fifteen and ten days; a proposed new Regulation 32A of the Listing Regulations; comments by 3 November.
- Rajesh Exports (SEBI confirmatory order, October 14) — the Whole-Time Member continued the bar on the promoter dealing in the scrip: about 99.8 per cent of five years’ consolidated revenue is alleged to be misrepresented, with the promoter’s derivative trades booked as the company’s sales and purchases, and an unverified ₹1,035 crore African mine investment; the forensic audit continues.
- Portfolio managers (SEBI, posted October 12) — the Portfolio Managers Regulations, 2026, notified on 7 October, take effect on 1 April 2027 and repeal the 2020 regulations: ₹5 crore net worth, ₹50 lakh minimum investment, chapters on co-investment and large-value accredited investors, a twenty-one-day grievance timeline. The Settlement Regulations, 2026 commence on 7 November.
- Emirates NBD into RBL (RBI, October 16) — the Bank sanctioned the amalgamation of Emirates NBD’s Indian branches into RBL Bank under Section 44A(4) of the Banking Regulation Act, effective 1 December.
- Competition Commission (October 13) — approval for GRT Jewellers’ acquisition of a majority stake in Tribhovandas Bhimji Zaveri; detailed order to follow.
- Telecom (TRAI, October 12) — the April–June performance report: 1,114 million internet subscribers, 1,087 million on broadband, 47.8 million on wireline.
- Tax — the Gujarat High Court quashed a ₹43.43 crore Section 74 IGST demand on Amul over un-cross-charged branch services, no fraud having been found (reported October 16); the tax-audit and return deadlines of 21 October and 21 November stand with no further extension; the goods-and-services-tax network enabled the annual return for the last financial year; and no notification implementing the 8 October Council decisions — the arrest power, the ₹5 crore prosecution threshold, the penalty cap — has issued, each needing a Finance Act amendment.
- Not yet — no draft of the Intermediary Rules amendment on under-18 accounts (the four-week clock from 28 September runs to about 26 October), no final mule-account directions, no monetary-policy minutes (due around 21 October), no Ministry of Corporate Affairs notification and no extension of the annual-filing dates, no notification constituting the National Tribunals Commission.
What We’re Watching Next Week
- The break — the Supreme Court rose on Friday for Dussehra and reopens on Monday, 26 October; the Kerala Chief Minister’s challenge to the FIR direction may be listed before a vacation bench earlier. On the 26th: the Connaught Place traders’ petition against the civic body’s closure of Central Park, the application over the 12 October march, and the Phoenix ARC parties before the Tribunal.
- Monday, October 19 — the Bombay High Court takes the Mumbai detentions petition and the actor Imran Khan’s “Leave India” challenge; the Madras High Court’s Advocate General is to have the route-march permissions issued.
- Tuesday, October 27 — drug pricing and the 30 per cent margin cap before Justices Nath and Mehta; the Karnataka SIR FIR matter before Justice Hegde.
- Wednesday, October 28 — the Delhi revision and Form 6 before the Chief Justice’s bench, on which the Court has said it is “thinking of passing an order”; the CAPF cadre-review contempt before Justices Misra and Bhuyan with the Home Ministry’s files; the Sohrabuddin matter; the wrestlers’ case at Rouse Avenue.
- Thursday, October 29 — the West Bengal deleted-voters appeals, the fall-back date the Chief Justice gave; Subhash Chandra’s appeals at the Appellate Tribunal (29 and 30 October); the Dharwad bench’s SIR FIR stay returns.
- Reserved or pending — Sachin Waze’s bail appeal in Bombay; the Chief Minister’s application in the Perambur election petition and the five-seat bye-election challenge in Madras; Satyam Verma’s National Security Act habeas in Allahabad; the Committee of Creditors’ power to withdraw an approved plan; anticipatory bail direct to the High Court; the law-student attendance appeal; the Sambhal survey; the Sabarimala nine-judge reference; the two-child norm; the seven-judge sales-tax surcharge reference. The UPI charge awaits a post-Diwali notification; the Intermediary Rules draft on under-18 accounts is due by about 26 October; the Section 163 petitions and the Bar’s detention petitions return on 19 November; the Shiv Sena symbol hearing has no date.
That’s all for this week. If a colleague would find this useful, forward them this page — or better yet, ask them to subscribe.
Enjoyed this issue?
Get the next one delivered straight to your inbox every Monday.