The Twenty-Four Hours Run From Detention, Not From the Arrest Memo
This is immediately usable at every remand hearing, not only under the NDPS Act: counsel should take the time of interception from the panchnama, not the arrest memo, and compare it with the time of production.
Read the cover storyAlso this week
- 02 Elections: Two-Child Laws “Have Lost Their Relevance,” and Javed Goes to a Larger Bench — Mangala Bhimrao Ingle
- 03 Taxation: Seven Judges Close a 1999 Reference on Sales-Tax Surcharges and Affirm S. Kodar — Arjun Flour Mills
- 04 Bonded Labour: Rehabilitation Within Seven Days of Release, Under a Continuing Mandamus
- 05 Inter-State Disputes: A Fifteen-Year-Old Article 131 Decree Is Executed in Megawatt-Hours — State of Himachal Pradesh
- 06 Public Order: “No Site Can Be Occupied for All Times” — the Protest Docket Is Sorted, and Jantar Mantar Is Called a Road
- 07 Elections: The Form 6 Letter Goes on Record, Notice on the Commissioners’ Immunity, and No Rotation of Reserved Seats
- 08 Criminal Appeals: Tejpal Stays In — “Not a Fit Case” for Suspension of Sentence, and Goa’s Enhancement Petition Gets Leave
- 09 Contempt: A Show-Cause to Every Office-Bearer of the Kerala Congress Over the “Resign Now” Post
- 10 Contempt: Punjab’s Chief Secretary Appears in Chandigarh, and the Supreme Court Stays the Criminal Contempt — “You Got a Breather”
- 11 Family Law: A Foreign Divorce the Wife Never Joined Is No Defence to Bigamy, Nor Is a New Passport — N. Sridhar Reddy
- 12 Criminal Law: A School’s Office-Bearers Are Not Liable for a Contractor’s Pillar — “Mere Negligence” Is Not Rashness — Bhosale
- 13 Evidence: Section 106 Convicts the Husband Who Lied and Acquits the Mother-in-Law Charged Only Under Section 34 — Jadhav and Kamalbai
- 14 Constitutional Law: The National Book Trust Is “State” — a Society’s Registration Does Not Displace Pervasive Control — Abdul Gaffar
- 15 Forest Rights: A Commercial Crop Is Not a Forest Right, and a Former Chief Justice Will Supervise the Claims — A. John Kennedy
- 16 Civil Procedure: A Pre-Registration Rejection Goes in the Order IV Register, and a Balance Sheet Restarts Limitation — Pazhanivel and Yusuf
- 17 Service Law: Uncommunicated Entries Count for Compulsory Retirement, and a Pensioner Takes the Post With Its Rules — Dhruw and Bhandari
- 18 Reservations: The Creamy-Layer Judgment Is Clarified, Not Reopened — Past Selections Stand, the 2025 Batch Follows It — Rohith Nathan
- 19 Religious Endowments: The Madras Order Placing Chidambaram’s Temple Under a Board Is Stayed on the Dikshitars’ Article 26 Plea
- 20 Environment: The Firecracker Order Surfaces With a Two-Day Window, and the Chief Justice Calls the Winter Curbs “Old, Tried and Failed”
- 21 Criminal Law: “Stupid” Is Not Cruelty, and an Unexamined Handwriting Report Proves Nothing — Narlawar and Goverdhan
- 22 UAPA: “The Protectors Have Become the Predators” — Bombay Cancels Sachin Waze’s Bail on the NIA’s Appeal
- 23 Elections: Form 8 Does Not Stop for a Revision — the Goa Bench Restores Six Deleted Voters and Refuses a Stay — Paresh Salgaonkar
- 24 Local Government: Kolkata’s Civic Polls Are on Hold Over a 144-to-209 Ward Redraw Made Under an Administrator — Dipu Das
- 25 Money Laundering: “The ED Is Not a Super Cop” — a Closed Predicate Offence Closes the PMLA Case, Karnataka Holds — Y.B. Ashwathanarayan
- 26 Personality Rights: Doosra May Be Screened, With a Disclaimer That Ganguly Did Not Consent and a ₹2 Crore Guarantee
- 27 Practice: Rajasthan’s Full Bench Restores the Criminal Writ Petition and Overrules a Division Bench — Ravi Kumar
- 28 Arrest: The Grounds Given to the Accused Were Not the Grounds Shown to the Magistrate — Allahabad Orders an FIR — Mohd. Yaseen
- 29 Allahabad: The Bench Calls the Protest Criminal Contempt, the Chief Justice Skips the Bar’s Oath Ceremony, and Lawyers Block the Doors
- 30 Appointments: Justice Rajesh Bindal to Chair the NCLAT, One Bombay Judge Notified, and the Four Chief Justices Still Wait
- 31 Lawyers and Police: Rohini’s Strike Is Called Off Within a Day, and Ghaziabad’s Four Advocates Get Protection From the Supreme Court
- 32 Personal Insolvency: Venugopal Dhoot Is Declared Bankrupt on ₹12,668 Crore of Videocon Guarantees
- 33 IBC: “The Test Is Whether the Dispute Is Plausible” — the NCLAT Reverses a Second Listed-Company Admission in a Week — FTF Pharma
- 34 PMLA and IBC: Plan Approval Releases an Earlier ED Attachment, and No Special Court Finding Is Needed
- 35 Appellate Practice: No Certified-Copy Application Inside Limitation, No Appeal; and Recall Is Not a Rehearing — Technofab and Excel Arcade
- 36 Securities: The Settlement Regulations, 2026 Commence, With a Ninety-Day Window for Applications the Old Regime Turned Away
- 37 Securities: Six Circulars in Four Days — Manager-Led Accreditation, a $5 Million Cap on Unhedged Currency Positions, and Remote KYC
- 38 Securities: The Appellate Tribunal Sets Aside the ₹25 Crore Coffee Day Penalty and Orders a Fresh Probe of a ₹3,535 Crore Diversion
- 39 Payments: The UPI Merchant Charge Is “Both Lawful and Necessary,” and Merchants Cannot Pass It On, NPCI Tells the Court
- 40 Banking: Draft Priority-Sector Directions for Five Classes of Lender, a Cyber Rulebook for Payment Operators, and a Markets Committee
Welcome to this week’s issue of the Indian Legal Brief (ILB). Here are the judgments, orders, regulatory changes, and developments that matter to your practice — without the noise.
The Supreme Court sat Monday to Friday and rose for Diwali; it reopens on 16 November. The cover is a criminal-procedure ruling that will be cited at remand hearings from Monday: the twenty-four hours of Article 22(2) run from the moment a person’s liberty is curtailed, not from the time the arrest memo says, and three High Courts that had allowed a “buffer” between detention and arrest are disapproved by name. Justice Narasimha’s bench sent the 2003 ruling that upheld two-child bars on panchayat candidature to a larger bench, writing that laws penalising a third child “have lost their relevance” in a country whose fertility rate is below replacement. A seven-judge bench closed a 1999 reference on sales-tax surcharges as academic, affirming S. Kodar on the way. The Chief Justice’s bench executed a fifteen-year-old Article 131 decree between Himachal, Punjab and Haryana in megawatt-hours rather than rupees, and in the Odisha bonded-labour case gave rehabilitation a seven-day clock. The Court refused to suspend Tarun Tejpal’s sentence, served a contempt show-cause on the Kerala Congress over its “resign now” post about the Chief Justice, stayed the criminal contempt against Punjab’s Chief Secretary while telling the State it had “got a breather,” and in the protest docket told petitioners that no site can be occupied for all time. The reserved firecracker order, dated 29 October, was uploaded on Monday with a two-day window for green crackers; on Friday the Chief Justice called the winter curbs “old, tried and failed.” In the High Courts, Bombay cancelled Sachin Waze’s bail with the line “the protectors have become the predators,” the Goa Bench told the Election Commission that Form 8 does not stop for a revision, Calcutta put Kolkata’s civic polls on hold over a 144-to-209 ward redraw, and Karnataka told the Enforcement Directorate it “is not a super cop.” At the Bar, the Allahabad standoff hardened and Justice Rajesh Bindal was named Chairperson of the NCLAT. In insolvency, Venugopal Dhoot was declared bankrupt on ₹12,668 crore of Videocon guarantees, and the NCLAT set aside a second listed-company admission in a week on a pre-existing dispute. SEBI’s Settlement Regulations commenced on Saturday, and the regulator issued six circulars in the week before.
Here’s what happened this week.
Supreme Court Highlights
Arrest: The Twenty-Four Hours Run From Detention, Not From the Arrest Memo — Sujit Das v. Union of India
Bench: Justices Ujjal Bhuyan and Atul S. Chandurkar — November 5, 2026
At about two in the afternoon on 29 September 2025 a search team took the appellants into its control in Tripura; the seizure was 60.79 kilograms of methamphetamine tablets. The arrest memo recorded a “formal arrest” some twenty-one hours later, and the appellants were produced before the Magistrate at 4.45 p.m. on 30 September, within twenty-four hours of the memo and outside twenty-four hours of the detention. The Tripura High Court refused bail in April 2026. The appellants’ case was that Article 22(2) of the Constitution and Section 58 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita had been breached and that the rigours of Section 37 of the NDPS Act could not cure an unconstitutional detention.
In Sujit Das v. Union of India, 2026 INSC 1195, authored by Justice Bhuyan, the Court agreed. The twenty-four hours run “from the moment liberty is actually curtailed,” and the only time that may be excluded is the journey to the Magistrate. The Court rejected the distinction between “detention” and “arrest” on which the prosecution relied: “the Constitution does not recognize any detention dehors arrest.” It disapproved by name the Kerala High Court in Arun K. Thomas, the Madras High Court in Kannan and the Orissa High Court in Aryaman Pattnayak, each of which had allowed a period of custody before the formal arrest to fall outside the clock, and held that the NDPS Act’s search-and-seizure formalities and the 2022 Rules do not suspend it: “Creation or contemplation of such buffer zone is unconstitutional.” The production at 4.45 p.m. breached Article 22(2); the continued detention was illegal; and Section 37 “must yield.” The High Court’s order was set aside, with the appellants to be produced before the Special Court within seven days and released on bail. The judgment goes further than the facts required. Even within the twenty-four hours, the Court said, a Magistrate must ask whether the detention before production exceeded what was reasonable and may decline remand; the actual date and time of detention must be recorded. The bench also placed on record its “reservations” about State of Punjab v. Sukhwinder Singh @ Gora, decided earlier this year, which held that the right to a speedy trial operates within Section 37, noting the three-judge decision in K.A. Najeeb, but left the point for another day. The judgment is to be circulated to every Director General of Police, every High Court Registrar General and every State Judicial Academy.
“The 24-hours deadline is sacrosanct.”
Why it matters: This is immediately usable at every remand hearing, not only under the NDPS Act: counsel should take the time of interception from the panchnama, not the arrest memo, and compare it with the time of production. Three High Court lines of authority are gone, Magistrates have been told that a production within twenty-four hours is not automatically a lawful one, and the doubt recorded about Sukhwinder Singh is the first step toward a larger bench on Article 21 and Section 37.
Elections: Two-Child Laws “Have Lost Their Relevance,” and Javed Goes to a Larger Bench — Mangala Bhimrao Ingle
Bench: Justices P.S. Narasimha and Alok Aradhe — November 4, 2026
The appellant was elected Sarpanch of Kakoda Gram Panchayat in Maharashtra in 2022. Her third child was born in 2014, after the cut-off date in Section 14(1)(j-1) of the Maharashtra Village Panchayats Act, 1959, which disqualifies a person with more than two children, and the Additional Commissioner at Amravati set her election aside; the Bombay High Court affirmed. The provision’s validity was not challenged, and the appellant could not win on the statute as it stood. The Constitution Bench in Javed v. State of Haryana (2003) had upheld an identical Haryana bar as a reasonable classification serving the national objective of population control, and Rajbala had followed it.
In Mangala Bhimrao Ingle v. Additional Commissioner, Amravati Division, 2026 INSC 1193, authored by Justice Narasimha, the Court held that the demographic premise of Javed “no longer holds ground.” India’s total fertility rate has fallen from about three in 2003 to about 1.9, below replacement; the fear of over-population that supplied the rational nexus “has crumbled due to demographic changes in the past few decades.” A classification whose justification has disappeared becomes an arbitrary basis for excluding citizens from political representation, and the bar impinges on reproductive autonomy under Article 21. The Court did not strike the provision down; it referred the correctness of Javed to a larger bench, stayed the High Court’s judgment, and allowed the appellant to continue as Sarpanch pending the appeal. Several States, among them Maharashtra, Gujarat, Odisha, Uttarakhand, Andhra Pradesh and Telangana, retain some form of the bar for local bodies.
“We are of the strong opinion that laws that penalise having more than two children have lost their relevance.”
Why it matters: Every pending disqualification under a two-child rule now has an interim-protection argument, and the reference will decide whether a Constitution Bench ruling can be unsettled by demographic fact rather than legal error. The Article 21 framing, reproductive autonomy applied to electoral law, is the part to watch; it is a wider principle than the panchayat statutes it was written for.
Taxation: Seven Judges Close a 1999 Reference on Sales-Tax Surcharges and Affirm S. Kodar — Arjun Flour Mills
Bench: Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justices K.V. Viswanathan, S.V.N. Bhatti, Joymalya Bagchi, N.V. Anjaria, Arun Palli and V. Mohana — November 4, 2026
The appeal was filed in 1994 and referred to seven judges in 1999. The question was whether a surcharge or additional tax computed as a percentage of a validly levied sales tax, Section 5A of the Orissa Sales Tax Act, 1947 being the example, was within the State’s competence under Entry 54 of List II, or was a tax on income or a “tax on tax.” The reference arose from a perceived conflict between Hoechst Pharmaceuticals and India Cement, the latter having treated royalty as a tax.
In Arjun Flour Mills v. State of Odisha, 2026 INSC 1192, the Chief Justice wrote for six judges and Justice Viswanathan concurred separately. The conflict, the Court held, had dissolved: the nine-judge bench in Mineral Area Development Authority (2024) overruled the premise of India Cement, and S. Kodar v. State of Kerala has governed throughout. A surcharge computed on the sales tax is an enhancement of the rate of sales tax, not a different impost: “The subject of the surcharge remains the sale or purchase of goods; the only difference lies in the arithmetical route.” With Entry 54 substituted and sales-tax regimes replaced by VAT and then GST, the question “does not survive for adjudication by a Seven Judge Bench, and the reference has been rendered academic.” Two Punjab questions were left to regular benches: the validity of Section 30-AA of the Punjab General Sales Tax Act and whether the proceeds of the cess under the Punjab Social Security Act may bypass the Consolidated Fund under Article 266. Justice Viswanathan held that Kodar “continues to be a good law and needs no reconsideration” and that India Cements “does not create any dent” on it.
“Consequently, the question referred does not survive for adjudication by a Seven Judge Bench, and the reference has been rendered academic.”
Why it matters: One of the oldest pending Constitution Bench references is closed. For the legacy sales-tax and VAT assessments still in the pipeline in Odisha, Punjab and elsewhere, Kodar is the settled law and the surcharge is simply a higher rate; the Article 266 question about earmarked cesses is the live one, and it now goes to a Division Bench.
Bonded Labour: Rehabilitation Within Seven Days of Release, Under a Continuing Mandamus — Surendra Manjhi v. Union of India
Bench: Justices Vikram Nath and Aparesh Kumar Singh — November 2, 2026
The petition under Article 32 was filed in 2022 by labourers rescued from brick kilns in Shahjahanpur, Uttar Pradesh, seventeen of whom had still not received the financial assistance due under the Central Sector Scheme for Rehabilitation of Bonded Labourers. The case became an audit of the scheme. The Court found that release certificates were issued late or in inconsistent formats, that assistance was withheld because criminal proceedings against the employers were pending, and that entitlements varied with the State a labourer happened to be rescued in.
In Surendra Manjhi v. Union of India, 2026 INSC 1185, authored by Justice Nath, the Court held that release does not discharge the State’s duty: identification, release and rehabilitation are stages of one continuing constitutional obligation under Articles 21, 23 and 24, and “rehabilitation delayed may, in substance, amount to rehabilitation denied.” The directions carry timelines. Immediate assistance is ordinarily to be paid within seven days of the release certificate and may not be withheld because a prosecution is pending; complaints are to be verified and release certificates issued ordinarily within twenty-four hours; the certificate format is to be uniform across States. Nodal officers and an inter-State coordination mechanism are to be in place in six months; the Centre, with the National Human Rights Commission, is to issue supplementary guidelines and decide in three months on revising the scheme, including higher immediate assistance and interim subsistence. State Vigilance Committees are to meet monthly, the NAVJIVAN portal is to be kept current, grievances are to be decided in thirty days, and each released labourer is to be followed up at district level for a year. Uttar Pradesh and Bihar are to jointly verify and pay the seventeen Shahjahanpur labourers. The petitions are kept pending and listed after seven months.
“The prohibition of bonded labour is among the most fundamental assurances of human dignity embodied in our Constitution.”
Why it matters: Labour, legal-aid and public-interest practitioners now have a seven-day and a twenty-four-hour yardstick to enforce, and a compliance affidavit from the Centre as the next hook. The holding that pending criminal proceedings cannot delay assistance removes the most common administrative excuse.
Inter-State Disputes: A Fifteen-Year-Old Article 131 Decree Is Executed in Megawatt-Hours — State of Himachal Pradesh
Bench: Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana — November 6, 2026
In September 2011 the Court decreed Himachal Pradesh’s original suit against the Union, Punjab and Haryana, raising its share of power from the Bhakra-Nangal and Beas projects to 7.19 per cent. The arrears for the period before the decree, 13,066 million units, were never paid; the parties could not agree a rate at which energy should be converted to money, and the execution ran for fifteen years. The Centre proposed a cashless settlement in energy.
In State of Himachal Pradesh v. Union of India, 2026 INSC 1200, authored by the Chief Justice, the Court treated the proceedings as execution and gave the dispute what it called a final quietus. Punjab and Haryana are to supply the arrears in energy over twenty lean seasons, October to March, in the ratio 58:42 for Bhakra and 60:40 for Beas; Himachal pays the Bhakra Beas Management Board’s notified charges for the year of receipt. Himachal’s own liability for capital cost was fixed at ₹420.77 crore, ₹249.23 crore to Punjab and ₹171.55 crore to Haryana, and set off against energy at ₹3.85 a unit, about 1,093 million units, leaving about 11,973 million units to be delivered. Punjab’s objections were rejected as an attempt to relitigate the 2011 decree, and its argument for valuation at the current operating cost was refused; the disbursement period was extended from fifteen years to twenty as a concession. “The present exercise is not intended to reopen matters conclusively decided by this Court.” The directions bind the parties “without reservation.”
“The present exercise is not intended to reopen matters conclusively decided by this Court.”
Why it matters: Article 131 decrees are rarely executed at all, and this one supplies a template for cashless settlement of inter-State dues in kind over a long horizon. Punjab recorded reservations, so a review or clarification application is possible; the order’s refusal to revisit the 2011 findings is what it will meet.
Public Order: “No Site Can Be Occupied for All Times” — the Protest Docket Is Sorted, and Jantar Mantar Is Called a Road
Bench: Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana — November 3, 2026
The batch arising from October’s anti-Election Commission protests returned on Tuesday. The Court divided the connected petitions into nine categories, asked counsel to propose a sequence and time estimates, and said fresh writ petitions would be entertained only if the Advocate-on-Record certified an entirely new issue; the Chief Justice rebuked lawyers who argued out of turn. On the traders’ petition over business losses, argued by Senior Advocate Mukul Rohatgi, the Court directed that the protest organisers be added as parties. On protest sites the Chief Justice said: “You can’t occupy a site for all times,” and “designated site must be given for designated period”; the Solicitor General said a July permission for Jantar Mantar had been for one day and the site was occupied for seventeen. Permissions, the Court said, must state their terms including duration, and orders granting or refusing them must give reasons.
The Delhi Police Commissioner’s affidavit on the de-notification of Jantar Mantar, filed in Swaty Singh, said the place “is not a ‘site’ as understood but is, in fact, a public road,” that its proximity to the seat of government “has ceased to be relevant and has become redundant,” that the petitioners “cannot claim any vested right to insist upon a particular site,” and that the de-notification followed a Home Ministry committee’s recommendation made before the Court’s October order; Ramlila Maidan, the CBD Ground in East Delhi and Burari were offered as alternatives. The police also produced the Section 163 BNSS orders as directed. On the Software Freedom Law Centre’s petition against facial-recognition surveillance of protesters, the Court issued notice; Justice Bagchi asked whether presence in a public place lowers the reasonable expectation of privacy, and the Court said it would examine whether police footage matched against the National Crime Records Bureau’s databases is a negative interference by the State. The Solicitor General asked: “Right to privacy in a public place? What kind of PILs are being filed?” The notice on the constitutionality of Section 172 BNSS is returnable, with the Section 163 petitions, on 19 November.
“You can’t occupy a site for all times.”
Why it matters: The Court has now said in terms that a protest permission is for a place and a period, and that the refusal must be reasoned; both halves will be cited in the next Section 163 challenge. The facial-recognition notice is the first time the Court has agreed to examine police use of biometric matching at public gatherings, and the question Justice Bagchi framed, whether privacy survives in a public place, is the one the case will turn on.
Elections: The Form 6 Letter Goes on Record, Notice on the Commissioners’ Immunity, and No Rotation of Reserved Seats
Bench: Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana — November 4–5, 2026
On 3 November the Election Commission wrote to the Chief Electoral Officers that an elector missing from a draft roll under the Special Intensive Revision may file Form 6 for inclusion in the final roll “irrespective of whether they had been enrolled previously,” that filing it in those circumstances is not of itself a false declaration, and that no action under Section 31 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950 would follow merely because the person was on an earlier roll; it relied on the Delhi High Court’s ruling in Nilotpal Datta. On Wednesday, in the Delhi revision petitions of Anjali Bhardwaj and Amrita Johri, Prashant Bhushan said the letter contradicted what the Court had observed on 28 October, that Form 6 is for a first-time elector. The bench passed no order on the merits and asked the petitioners to file an application placing the letter on record; the Commission said it would consider accepting late enumeration forms and extending the 30 October deadline. The Chief Justice: “You see how to reduce this gap of 43 lakh. We will take up after two weeks,” suggesting the Commission “publish the list telling that you are the 43 lakh persons” and have them “contact nearest BLO and fill Form 8.” The matter is listed on 19 November.
The same day the Court issued notice on petitions by Manoj Jha and Arun Agrawal against Section 16 of the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners Act, 2023, which bars proceedings against a Commissioner for acts done in office; there was no stay, the petitions were tagged with the Association for Democratic Reforms’ and Lok Prahari’s, and the batch goes to 18 December. “Our only request is that now stop filing petitions otherwise pleadings will never get complete.” In Jagdish Singh v. Union of India the Court declined to interfere with the Allahabad High Court’s decision upholding Section 9(1)(c) of the Delimitation Act, 2002, which fixes reserved constituencies without rotation: rotation is legislative policy, “we see no ground to take a different view.” On Thursday, in Sohandeb Chattopadhyay v. Speaker, West Bengal Legislative Assembly, a Trinamool legislator seeking a direction to the Speaker to decide disqualification petitions of July against ten rebel MLAs was sent to the Calcutta High Court, with a request to its Chief Justice to list the matter before a Division Bench for expeditious decision; the Court declined to entertain it merely because the High Court was on vacation until 12 November.
“You see how to reduce this gap of 43 lakh.”
Why it matters: The Form 6 question is now a dispute about a document on the record rather than an oral exchange, and the 19 November hearing will decide whether the Commission’s “no prosecution” assurance is enough or whether a separate form is required. The immunity petitions are consolidated with a December date, and the Delimitation Act order closes a rotation argument that has been run in several States.
Criminal Appeals: Tejpal Stays In — “Not a Fit Case” for Suspension of Sentence, and Goa’s Enhancement Petition Gets Leave
Bench: Justices M.M. Sundresh and Prasanna B. Varale — November 6, 2026
The Bombay High Court at Goa had reversed Tarun Tejpal’s 2021 acquittal and sentenced him to ten years for the 2013 rape of a colleague; the State has a petition for enhancement. On Tuesday the Solicitor General sought time and the bench adjourned to Thursday, with Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal pressing for release over Diwali: “If he wants to take time, he can take time. But let him come out during Diwali”; “It’s a reversal of the acquittal. He can come home for Diwali. Why should he be inside?” Goa opposed, and no interim order was made.
On Friday the Court dismissed the application for suspension of sentence and granted leave on Goa’s petition. Mr Sibal, with Siddharth Agarwal, argued that the trial court had acquitted on the evidence, that the CCTV and lift footage was with the defence, that Tejpal had spent nine months in custody during trial and was no flight risk. The Solicitor General and Additional Solicitor General S.V. Raju said the High Court had considered the evidence “in extenso” and that the case was one for enhancement. The bench said that on a prima facie view it was “not inclined to grant suspension of sentence,” that “we cannot say that there was a motive on the part of the prosecutrix to implicate the applicant,” she having worked under him with the families known to each other, and that the prosecution witnesses read with “the apology emails and text message(s)” sustained the conviction at this stage. Asked when the appeals would be heard, the bench said: “We can’t give a stage now.” They will be listed in due course.
“On prima facie view we are not inclined to grant suspension of sentence.”
Why it matters: A reversal of acquittal by a High Court does not by itself earn suspension of sentence pending appeal, and the Court has said so on facts where the defence had its strongest procedural points. The grant of leave on the State’s petition means the appeal will be heard with enhancement on the table.
Contempt: A Show-Cause to Every Office-Bearer of the Kerala Congress Over the “Resign Now” Post — Vineet Jindal v. KPCC
Bench: Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M. Pancholi — November 6, 2026
On 12 October the Kerala Pradesh Congress Committee’s handle posted: “Dear Surya Kant, If law and order is not your domain, resign now. We will find your replacement who can handle it.” An advocate’s letter complaining of it was registered by the Registry as a suo motu writ petition on 30 October. On Friday the Court issued a show-cause notice to all office-bearers of the Committee, including its president, asking why proceedings under the Contempt of Courts Act and Article 129 should not be initiated; personal appearance was exempted. Counsel for the Committee said the post had gone up without the office-bearers’ approval, had been deleted, and that an unconditional apology had been published. Justice Aravind Kumar said the Court would see “whether it has come from the pen or heart.” The Court asked the Attorney General to assist and indicated that an amicus would be appointed; Senior Advocates Arvind Datar and Siddharth Agarwal were named as possibilities.
“Authority of the court doesn’t require political endorsement; it rests on the rule of law.”
The bench added that “judicial restraint must never be mistaken for institutional weakness,” that “any attempt to undermine the authority of the Court needs to be dealt with an iron hand,” and that “tomorrow it may happen to every profession. We operate within the parameters of the Constitution.”
Why it matters: This is the first contempt notice to a political party’s office-bearers over a social-media post about the Chief Justice personally, and the Court has said an apology will be tested rather than accepted. With the Sanjay Raut matter listed on 17 November, the Court has two cases in which it will define what a party may say about a sitting judge.
Contempt: Punjab’s Chief Secretary Appears in Chandigarh, and the Supreme Court Stays the Criminal Contempt — “You Got a Breather”
Bench: Justices B.V. Nagarathna and R. Mahadevan — November 5, 2026
On Tuesday Chief Secretary K.A.P. Sinha appeared in person before Justice Harsh Bunger of the Punjab and Haryana High Court in Nirmal Singh Dhanoa v. K.A.P. Sinha, the contempt arising from a Division Bench’s August 2026 direction to pay dearness allowance arrears to employees and pensioners. He accepted notice to show cause. The Court rejected both defences: a Special Leave Petition filed in September and refiled in October but never listed, without a stay, “cannot furnish a justification for continued non-compliance”; and the six per cent interest the Division Bench had attached to delayed payment “was intended to operate as a compensatory measure,” not an alternative to paying. The State’s 30 October filing was a status report, the Court said, not a compliance report. A reply was ordered by 13 November and the matter listed on 17 November at noon with the Chief Secretary’s presence required.
On Thursday the Supreme Court stayed the criminal contempt, which arose from the High Court’s October finding that the State had misrepresented the position of its petition, “until further orders,” barred coercive steps in the civil contempt, and asked Punjab to come back with a concrete plan to clear the arrears by March 2027. The bench told the State’s counsel: “You got a breather. Come up with a positive response. How much will you release.” It was also pointed about the High Court’s method: “We don’t appreciate this arm twisting.” The matter is in December.
“We don’t appreciate this arm twisting.”
Why it matters: The State has protection from the criminal contempt and from arrest or costs in the civil one, but only against a roadmap it has not yet produced; the High Court’s 17 November date is now of uncertain effect. The Supreme Court’s remark about the High Court’s approach will be quoted in every contempt against a serving officer, and so will Justice Bunger’s holding that an unlisted petition is no answer to a decree.
Family Law: A Foreign Divorce the Wife Never Joined Is No Defence to Bigamy, Nor Is a New Passport — N. Sridhar Reddy
Bench: Justices Prashant Kumar Mishra and Shree Chandrashekhar — November 3, 2026
The husband obtained a divorce in the United Kingdom on the ground of irretrievable breakdown, a ground the Hindu Marriage Act does not recognise, in proceedings the wife did not submit to. He then married again abroad and acquired British citizenship. The wife prosecuted him and his family under Section 494 of the Penal Code; the Andhra Pradesh High Court declined to quash.
In N. Sridhar Reddy v. State of A.P., 2026 INSC 1191, authored by Justice Mishra, the Court sustained the prosecution of the husband. Under Section 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure a foreign decree on a ground unavailable under the law of the marriage, obtained without the other spouse’s submission, “cannot automatically be accorded recognition in India,” following the Court’s decision earlier this year in Kishorekumar Mohan Kale v. Kashmira Kale. The enquiry into bigamy is not confined to the place of the second marriage, and “legal consequences flowing from the subsisting marriage cannot be defeated by a subsequent change in the nationality.” The proceedings against the husband’s parents and the second wife were quashed for want of any overt act attributed to them.
“Such a decree cannot automatically be accorded recognition in India.”
Why it matters: For the non-resident matrimonial bar this is a direct answer: a foreign no-fault decree remains vulnerable in India unless the other spouse participated, and the criminal exposure under Section 494, now Section 82 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, survives both the decree and a change of passport. The quashing against the family is the usual limit; the offence needs an act, not a relationship.
Criminal Law: A School’s Office-Bearers Are Not Liable for a Contractor’s Pillar — “Mere Negligence” Is Not Rashness — Bhosale
Bench: Justices J.B. Pardiwala and Manmohan — November 2, 2026
A twelve-year-old pupil at an Adivasi ashram school in Amravati district died when a pillar under construction collapsed. The President and Superintendent of the society running the school were charge-sheeted under Sections 304 and 304A of the Penal Code, read with Section 34, for failing to supervise the work. The Bombay High Court declined to quash.
In Matin Shankarrao Bhosale v. State of Maharashtra, 2026 INSC 1198, authored by Justice Pardiwala, the Court quashed the proceedings against the two office-bearers while leaving the trial to proceed against the others. There was no material of intention or knowledge to sustain Section 304. Under Section 304A the accused’s act must be the causa causans of the death; an alleged failure to supervise was at most a causa sine qua non, and the contractor’s conduct was the intervening and proximate cause. Rashness and negligence are distinct, and a negligence that founds civil liability does not become criminal for being grave in its consequence: “Mere negligence cannot be construed to mean rashness.” The Court recorded that “dictating this order was a very painful experience.”
“Mere negligence cannot be construed to mean rashness.”
Why it matters: This is a clean restatement of the proximate-cause test under Section 304A, now Section 106 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, for institutional defendants: managers, trustees and hospital administrators are prosecuted for a contractor’s or an employee’s act only where their own omission is the operative cause. It will be the first citation in quashing petitions after construction and hospital deaths.
Evidence: Section 106 Convicts the Husband Who Lied and Acquits the Mother-in-Law Charged Only Under Section 34 — Jadhav and Kamalbai
Bench: Justices Sandeep Mehta and Devendra Kumar Upadhyaya (November 2) and Justices Ujjal Bhuyan and Atul S. Chandurkar (November 5), 2026
Two judgments this week fix the limits of Section 106 of the Evidence Act in matrimonial-home deaths. In Ramkishan Digambar Jadhav v. State of Maharashtra, 2026 INSC 1187, authored by Justice Mehta, the wife died in the exclusive company of her husband; his explanation was an accidental death after an epileptic seizure during intercourse, which the medical and post-mortem evidence contradicted. The Bombay High Court had reversed his acquittal under Section 302 and the Court upheld it. The inmates of the house bore the burden to “offer a cogent, credible, and satisfactory explanation regarding the circumstances culminating into her death,” and a false explanation became an additional link in the chain, applying Trimukh Maroti Kirkan; the presumption under Section 113B was not rebutted and the convictions of the in-laws under Sections 498A and 304B stood.
In Sau. Kamalbai Waman Patil v. State of Maharashtra, 2026 INSC 1196, authored by Justice Chandurkar, the same High Court had reversed the acquittal of a mother-in-law alone under Section 302 in a 2005 burning, while affirming the acquittal of three co-accused charged with her under Section 302 read with Section 34. The Court restored the acquittal. Where the only charge was Section 302 read with 34, convicting one accused alone without an independent Section 302 charge is a new accusation and prejudicial, following Krishna Govind Patil; the third and inconsistent dying declaration needed corroboration and the doctor who recorded it was never examined; the High Court heard no one on sentence under Section 386(a). And on Section 106: “It is only when the prosecution has led evidence, which if believed would sustain a conviction that the absence of a plausible explanation by the accused could be a factor against such accused.”
“It is only when the prosecution has led evidence, which if believed would sustain a conviction that the absence of a plausible explanation by the accused could be a factor against such accused.”
Why it matters: Read together, the two judgments are the current statement of the rule: silence or a false account from the household completes a chain the prosecution has already built, and cannot start one. The Kamalbai point on Section 34 is a trap for appellate courts reversing acquittals; where the charge was common intention, the acquittal of the others takes the sole survivor’s conviction with it.
Constitutional Law: The National Book Trust Is “State” — a Society’s Registration Does Not Displace Pervasive Control — Abdul Gaffar
Bench: Justices Prashant Kumar Mishra and Augustine George Masih — November 6, 2026
The Trust was created by Government resolutions of 1957 and 1962 and registered as a society. A Full Bench of the Delhi High Court held in 2012 that it was “State”; the Trust appealed, and Senior Advocate Sanjay Jain assisted as amicus.
In The Chairman, National Book Trust v. A.R. Abdul Gaffar, 2026 INSC 1202, authored by Justice Mishra, the Court applied the cumulative test of Ajay Hasia and Pradeep Kumar Biswas and dismissed the appeal. The Government controls the Trust’s composition, appoints its Chairman, funds it, audits it, receives its reports and approves its governing framework; the control is financial, functional and administrative, “particular to the Trust and pervasive in character,” and “not the limited or general regulatory supervision” that falls short. Registration as a society and the existence of independent income do not displace that. The Court added the usual caveat: the finding does not make the Trust a Government department or its staff civil servants with the protection of Part XIV.
“This is not the limited or general regulatory supervision.”
Why it matters: Writ jurisdiction over the Trust, and by parity over the cultural and educational bodies the Union set up by executive resolution in the same period, is confirmed; their employees’ service disputes go to the High Court under Article 226. The caveat on Part XIV is the limit employers will cite back.
Forest Rights: A Commercial Crop Is Not a Forest Right, and a Former Chief Justice Will Supervise the Claims — A. John Kennedy
Bench: Justices Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta — November 6, 2026
The appeals and a contempt petition in the 1995 forest-encroachment writ concern occupants of forest land in the Agasthyamalai and Megamalai landscape of Tamil Nadu, within the Srivilliputhur–Megamalai Tiger Reserve, who claim rights under the Forest Rights Act, 2006 as forest-dwelling Scheduled Tribes or other traditional forest dwellers; many cultivate silk cotton, ilavam panju, as a plantation crop.
In A. John Kennedy v. State of Tamil Nadu, 2026 INSC 1204, the Court held that claims must be decided under Section 6 of the Act and the Rules, “not merely on the basis of present occupation.” On the crop, its prima facie view was that minor forest produce must be naturally occurring, and that “planned cultivation of commercial crop is totally contrary to the very concept of a naturally occurring minor forest produce”; the Central Empowered Committee is to opine. Occupants in temporary residence and those outside the forest boundary are excluded from consideration under the Act. The State is to constitute the remaining Gram Sabhas within thirty days and adjudicate about 1,600 claims from some forty Gram Sabhas within five months. A Special Committee headed by Justice B.R. Gavai, the former Chief Justice of India, is to supervise the exercise and report in sealed cover; the National Highways Authority’s application on NH-744 goes to the Central Empowered Committee, and monitoring moves to the State’s Environment, Climate Change and Forests Department. The matter is part-heard and listed on 1 February 2027.
“Planned cultivation of commercial crop is totally contrary to the very concept of a naturally occurring minor forest produce.”
Why it matters: This is the Court’s first articulation that a commercial plantation cannot be bootstrapped into a forest right, and the first time a former Chief Justice has been asked to supervise a claims process. The thirty-day and five-month clocks will be the test of whether the Forest Rights Act machinery in Tamil Nadu can be made to work at all.
Civil Procedure: A Pre-Registration Rejection Goes in the Order IV Register, and a Balance Sheet Restarts Limitation — Pazhanivel and Yusuf
Bench: Justices Ujjal Bhuyan and Atul S. Chandurkar (November 5) and Justices Vikram Nath, Augustine George Masih and Sandeep Mehta (November 6), 2026
In G. Pazhanivel v. S. Thilagavathy, 2026 INSC 1197, authored by Justice Chandurkar, the Principal District Judge at Cuddalore had rejected a plaint at the pre-registration stage, treating a suit for declaration, redemption and injunction, in which a sale deed was alleged to be security for a ₹25 lakh loan, as a bare redemption suit, and the Madras High Court had affirmed. The Court held that a plaint may be rejected under Order VII Rule 11 before registration, but only on a ground the Rule provides, and the trial court had identified none; the plaint disclosed a cause of action and “likelihood of a suit being dismissed after trial does not furnish a ground.” The rule of practice is the holding: a pre-registration rejection “shall be duly recorded in a register maintained for such purpose” under Order IV Rule 2, and where a Civil Manual makes no provision the High Court may act under Section 122. The plaint was restored for registration and the judgment is to be circulated to every Registrar General and State Judicial Academy.
In Yusuf v. Vigyapan Loke Delhi Advertising CGHS Ltd., 2026 INSC 1207, authored by Justice Nath, a summary suit for ₹11.16 lakh of running bills from 2000 to 2003 had been dismissed as time-barred by the Delhi High Court in revision. The Court revived it. Following ARC (India) v. Bishal Jaiswal and Axis Bank v. Naren Sheth, entries in the society’s balance sheets from 2004 to 2013, read with the notes and the auditor’s report, can be an acknowledgment under Section 18 of the Limitation Act; the acknowledgment need not be addressed to the creditor or take a fixed form, but must show a subsisting jural relationship. Whether the entries cover the whole claim is for trial; “a fresh period of limitation would automatically run from each subsequent date of acknowledgment,” and no condonation application is needed.
“Likelihood of a suit being dismissed after trial does not furnish a ground.”
Why it matters: Pre-registration rejections have been invisible on the record, which is why they have been hard to appeal; the Order IV register closes that gap. The balance-sheet rule, developed under the Insolvency Code, now runs squarely in ordinary civil recovery against societies and companies.
Service Law: Uncommunicated Entries Count for Compulsory Retirement, and a Pensioner Takes the Post With Its Rules — Dhruw and Bhandari
Bench: Justices Manmohan and Shree Chandrashekhar (November 6) and Justices N.V. Anjaria and S.V.N. Bhatti (November 4), 2026
In Chatur Singh Dhruw v. State of Chhattisgarh, 2026 INSC 1205, authored by Justice Manmohan, two Assistant Grade-III clerks, former peons promoted in 2012 and 2013 and regularised in 2015, were compulsorily retired under a 2017 State circular. The Court upheld the orders. Compulsory retirement “is neither punitive nor stigmatic in character,” so Article 311(2) and natural justice do not apply; judicial review asks only whether material existed, was considered, and was reasonably acted on; and uncommunicated adverse entries may be considered under Baikuntha Nath Das. Dev Dutt and Sukhdev Singh, which require communication of below-benchmark entries, are promotion-context rulings and do not govern. Promotion does not wash away later adverse entries, and regularisation is not a judgment on merit.
In State of Uttarakhand v. M.C. Bhandari, 2026 INSC 1194, authored by Justice Anjaria, the Court upheld Regulation 7(2) of the Uttarakhand Public Service Commission (Conditions of Service) Regulations, 2004, under which a retired government servant appointed Chairman or Member has his pension deducted from salary for the tenure. The pension is withheld, not withdrawn, and revives when the term ends; “equal pay for equal work” has no application; the Governor’s determination need not precede the appointment; and an appointee who accepted the post knowing the Regulations is estopped: “One who participates in a game, cannot later challenge the rules of the game.”
“One who participates in a game, cannot later challenge the rules of the game.”
Why it matters: Dhruw confines Dev Dutt to promotions, which strengthens every State’s periodic-screening regime and weakens the most common ground on which compulsory retirements have been set aside. Bhandari governs re-employed pensioners on constitutional and statutory commissions wherever a similar rule exists.
Reservations: The Creamy-Layer Judgment Is Clarified, Not Reopened — Past Selections Stand, the 2025 Batch Follows It — Rohith Nathan
Bench: Justices P.S. Narasimha and R. Mahadevan — November 6, 2026
In March this year the Court decided how a parent’s salary is to be treated in computing creamy-layer status under the 1993 Office Memorandum and the 2004 letter of the Department of Personnel and Training. The Union and others filed miscellaneous applications asking, in substance, for the ruling to be revisited and for time to fix post equivalence across services.
In Union of India v. Rohith Nathan, 2026 INSC 1201, the Court entertained the applications only to clarify scope and temporal operation: “miscellaneous applications cannot be employed as a means to seek a rehearing of matters already decided.” The March judgment binds the parties and does not reopen concluded selections, appointments, seniority or allocations; paragraphs addressed to intervenors concern intervenors alone; the Government may accommodate eligible parties through supernumerary posts; similarly placed persons may pursue their own claims on merits before the competent forum; and selections and roster allotments made after 11 March 2026 must follow the Memorandum as interpreted. No timeline was imposed for post equivalence or policy. The one forward-looking direction is specific: the service allocation of OBC candidates from the 2025 Civil Services Examination “shall be governed by” the creamy-layer principle as the Court interpreted it. The time for compliance was extended by two months.
“Miscellaneous applications cannot be employed as a means to seek a rehearing of matters already decided.”
Why it matters: The uncertainty over the 2025 batch’s allocation is over, past batches are protected from challenge, and the Union’s request for two years to fix equivalence was neither granted nor refused, only left to the executive. The procedural holding, that a miscellaneous application is not a review, will be cited well beyond reservation law.
Religious Endowments: The Madras Order Placing Chidambaram’s Temple Under a Board Is Stayed on the Dikshitars’ Article 26 Plea
Bench: Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M. Pancholi — November 4, 2026
Reported in this journal last week, the Madras High Court’s 30 October order had constituted a Board of Management for the Sri Sabanayagar temple at Chidambaram headed by two former judges, displacing the Podhu Dikshitars, the hereditary priestly community whose right to administer the temple the Supreme Court recognised in 2014 under Article 26. The Dikshitars moved the Supreme Court. On Wednesday the bench stayed the High Court’s order and issued notice on the petition.
Why it matters: The 2014 judgment held that the Dikshitars are a religious denomination entitled to administer their temple; the stay signals that the Court will test the High Court’s board against that holding before any takeover proceeds. For the State’s endowments department the practical position is unchanged from before 30 October.
Environment: The Firecracker Order Surfaces With a Two-Day Window, and the Chief Justice Calls the Winter Curbs “Old, Tried and Failed”
Bench: Justices M.M. Sundresh and Prasanna B. Varale (order dated October 29, uploaded November 2) and Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana (November 6), 2026
The order in Arjun Gopal v. Union of India, 2026 INSC 1181, reserved on 29 October and reported last week as awaited, carries that date and was uploaded on Monday. It permits only CSIR-NEERI-certified green crackers in Delhi-NCR on 7 and 8 November, between 6 and 7 in the morning and 8 and 10 at night, with the complete ban restored from 9 November. Cancelled traders’ licences were restored for 4 to 6 November only; only crackers uploaded to the NEERI site between 2 and 6 November may be manufactured; ladis and barium crackers remain banned; boxes must be sealed with product-specific QR codes; sale is only at designated locations, with no online sale; and nothing may be burst within 300 metres of a hospital, nursing home, health centre, old-age home, educational institution or silence zone. The pollution boards are to file daily air-quality reports for the pre-Diwali, Diwali and post-Diwali periods, affidavits are due by 14 December and the matter is listed on 16 December. The reasoning is candid: “Though imposition of a blanket ban seems to be the ideal solution,” the Court was “short of adequate data to decide whether or not a complete ban would be the best solution”; the complete ban “had not yielded the desired results”; and on the earlier directions, “the State has utterly failed in complying with the directions thereunder.” Public figures were asked “to lend their voice and influence through a voluntary public-awareness campaign.” On Tuesday the Court flagged a report of open sale of firecrackers in Delhi markets and asked the Centre to ensure compliance.
On Friday the Chief Justice’s bench heard M.C. Mehta with Senior Advocate Aparajita Singh as amicus and Additional Solicitor General Aishwarya Bhati for the Union, and passed no directions, saying it would. The Chief Justice called the vehicle restrictions under the Graded Response Action Plan “old, tried and failed measures,” noted bumper-to-bumper traffic across the region, and said: “Even if a vehicle enters Delhi for just two hours and then leaves, those two hours are enough to cause damage.” On stubble he suggested procurement at a rate notified in advance, machinery to gram panchayats and storage by the Food Corporation, and asked the Additional Solicitor General to carry the suggestions to the Agriculture Ministry. “We keep talking, sometimes make statements and suggestions, but the point is that AQI is already touching 400.” The amicus said breathing the city’s air “is like smoking 30 cigarettes a day.” The matter is listed on 16 November.
“We keep talking, sometimes make statements and suggestions, but the point is that AQI is already touching 400.”
Why it matters: The firecracker order is, by its own account, a decision taken without the data to decide, and its compliance machinery, QR codes, licence windows, daily AQI reports, is the record on which December’s hearing will be fought. The Friday remarks are the first time the Chief Justice has described the GRAP vehicle curbs as a failure from the bench; what replaces them is the question for 16 November.
Criminal Law: “Stupid” Is Not Cruelty, and an Unexamined Handwriting Report Proves Nothing — Narlawar and Goverdhan
Bench: Justices B.V. Nagarathna and Manmohan (November 2) and Justices Sandeep Mehta and Devendra Kumar Upadhyaya (November 3), 2026
In Piyush Narlawar v. State of Maharashtra, 2026 INSC 1183, marked non-reportable, a wife had died by suicide in Toronto and the husband and his family were charged under Sections 304B, 498A and 323 of the Penal Code and the Dowry Prohibition Act. The Court, through Justice Nagarathna, quashed the FIR. There was no nexus between any demand and the death; wedding and Diwali gifts are not dowry absent a demand; the suicide note named none of the accused; and calling a wife “stupid” or “useless” reflects temperament and is neither cruelty nor criminal intimidation. “The term ‘cruelty’ cannot be established without specific instances of commission or omission,” and courts “have to be extremely careful and cautious in dealing with such complaints.”
In Goverdhan v. State of Rajasthan, 2026 INSC 1190, authored by Justice Mehta, a husband’s concurrent conviction for abetting his wife’s suicide rested on four letters. The handwriting expert was never examined, no specimen writing was taken by the investigating officer, and the comparison writings were not proved to be his; even on their own terms the letters, abusive but seeking reconciliation, written to a wife living separately for two years and litigating against him, were not instigation under Section 107. The complaint had been lodged fifteen days after the death without explanation. He was acquitted: “The prosecution has failed to establish the charge beyond all manner of doubt.”
“The term ‘cruelty’ cannot be established without specific instances of commission or omission.”
Why it matters: Narlawar adds to the Nagarathna bench’s line of quashings in vague Section 498A and 304B complaints, with “festival gifts are not dowry” as the usable sentence. Goverdhan is authority that a handwriting report is inadmissible proof of authorship unless the expert is examined, a point that reaches well beyond suicide cases.
Other Notable SC Orders This Week
- Waqf (Amendment) Act, 2025 (November 3) — Justices Sundresh and Varale lifted the cap of five writ petitions, allowed applicants whose petitions had been converted to interventions to file their own within two weeks, directed pleadings to be completed by 31 December and posted the final hearing to January 2027; the interim arrangement continues.
- Municipal contempt (November 3–4) — The Chief Justice’s bench stopped the salary of the Brihanmumbai Municipal Commissioner and his personal staff and imposed ₹5 lakh in costs for failure to remove encroachments in Parag Construction; on Wednesday the Corporation reported that the encroachments had been removed.
- PMLA (November 5) — Azam Khan’s challenge to his arrest by the Enforcement Directorate on 31 October, minutes after his release on bail in another case, was transferred by the Chief Justice and Justice Bagchi to the Allahabad High Court, which is to consider interim relief on 16 November; Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal alleged political persecution and the Court expressed no view on the merits.
- Liberty (November 4) — In Saddam v. State of U.P., Justices Pardiwala and Manmohan found a man still in jail six weeks after bail was granted on 28 September, called it “unusual and disturbing,” ordered immediate release and asked the State why compensation should not be awarded.
- Prisons (November 3) — Justices Sundresh and Varale deferred Jagtar Singh Hawara’s plea for transfer from Tihar to a Punjab jail after the Intelligence Bureau’s report, placed through the Additional Solicitor General, said the move could affect the Punjab elections; Senior Advocate S. Muralidhar said Tihar could not be called more secure than any jail in Punjab.
- Judicial appointments (November 2) — Justice P.S. Narasimha recused from Lok Prahari’s petition to finalise the Memorandum of Procedure and open Collegium minutes, having appeared as Additional Solicitor General in the NJAC case; the matter goes to the Chief Justice for listing.
- Judges’ perks (November 4) — In Pratik Vira v. Union of India, a petition against post-resignation perks for constitutional functionaries who resign to avoid removal, the Solicitor General told the Chief Justice’s bench that “the petitioner seems to have a case”; the Union is to file a counter.
- Tirupati (November 5) — The Chief Justice’s bench refused to transfer the trial in the laddu ghee adulteration case out of Andhra Pradesh; the witnesses are local and the investigation was by a Court-constituted team.
- Preventive detention (November 2) — In A. Arun v. Varsha Sharma, 2026 INSC 1186, a three-judge bench of Justices Vikram Nath, R. Mahadevan and Aparesh Kumar Singh accepted a Chennai police officer’s apology and expunged the Madras High Court’s remarks on him while leaving the quashing of the detention intact: “the tendering of an apology cannot be regarded as a substitute for due care in the exercise of powers affecting the liberty of a person.”
- Judicial officers (November 2) — In In Re: XXX, a Judicial Officer, 2026 INSC 1188, Justices Mehta and Upadhyaya expunged the Rajasthan High Court’s strictures on a Special Judge at Jhunjhunu, including a remark that a judgment was “cut, copy and paste,” recorded without hearing the officer: concerns about a judge belong on the administrative side, not in a judicial order.
- Anti-corruption (November 2) — In State of Bihar v. Phulpari Kumari, Justices Viswanathan and Palli restored cognizance against a former child development officer whom the Patna High Court had discharged because her gold was within the Income-tax circulars’ limits: “merely showing certain press release and circulars permitting the holding of gold to a certain extent will not amount to accounting for the possession of the said assets.”
- Criminal appeals (November 3) — In Shekappa v. State of Karnataka, 2026 INSC 1189, Justices Viswanathan and Palli upheld the Karnataka High Court’s reversal of an acquittal in a 2001 double murder: an inference from digestion timing cannot displace credible eyewitnesses, the absence of their names from an inquest report under Section 174 is not significant, and “merely because a witness is a related witness, that witness need not be an interested or a partisan witness.”
- Hindu succession (November 6) — In J. Rajesh v. M. Kumaran, 2026 INSC 1208, Justices Sunita Agarwal and Masih held that a grandson born after his grandfather’s death takes nothing by birth in property the grandfather left: succession opened under Section 8 of the 1956 Act, the father’s share became his separate property, and “a son’s son is not mentioned as an heir under Class I of the Schedule.”
- Judicial service (November 3) — The Chief Justice’s bench issued notice to the Allahabad High Court’s administration and to an Additional District Judge posted as a POCSO Special Judge while a 2022 rape FIR against him is pending, on a petition by the complainant; the Court said it would not itself relieve the officer but would see that the complaint reached “a logical conclusion.” December.
- Advocates’ safety (November 3) — In A. Deepa v. State of U.P., the Chief Justice’s bench sought a status report from the Uttar Pradesh Police on the alleged assault on four advocates in Ghaziabad on 22 October, directed that no harm come to them, and declined to stay the cross-FIR unheard.
- Senior designation (November 6) — Justices Narasimha and Aradhe declined to interfere with the Allahabad High Court’s 2019 senior designations, leaving the petitioner free to reapply under Jitendra Kalla.
- Competition (November 4) — In Keshav Bihani v. Competition Commission of India, Justices Mishra and Chandrashekhar dismissed appeals against the NCLAT’s affirmation of penalties on a railway-tender cartel exposed by a leniency applicant.
- Media (November 3) — Abhishek Banerjee’s petition against reporting of the investigations against him was sent to the Calcutta High Court, which reopens on 16 November, with a request that it consider interim relief.
- PMLA (November 6) — Notice was issued on the Enforcement Directorate’s petition against the Delhi High Court’s quashing of the FIR and the money-laundering case against NewsClick and Prabir Purkayastha.
- Somnath (November 6) — The Court declined to stay the Gujarat High Court’s order on the ban on non-vegetarian food near the Somnath temple and asked the High Court to decide the pending appeals.
- Environment (November 3) — Notice to the Centre and Assam on Oil India’s petition against the rejection of its proposal to drill at a national park.
- Election petitions (November 3) — Bhupesh Baghel’s petition against the Chhattisgarh High Court’s order in the election petition against him was rejected; the trial must proceed.
- Higher education (November 5) — The Centre told the Court that a committee is considering a revisit of the University Grants Commission’s Equity Regulations, 2026.
- Filed, not yet listed — Umar Khalid and Sharjeel Imam filed fresh bail petitions in the Delhi riots conspiracy case as the one-year embargo in the January order approaches its end; the reserved judgments in the Enforcement Directorate’s petition against Mamata Banerjee and on drug trade margins had not been pronounced by the close of the week.
From the High Courts
UAPA: “The Protectors Have Become the Predators” — Bombay Cancels Sachin Waze’s Bail on the NIA’s Appeal
Bench: Justices Girish Kulkarni and Neela Gokhale — November 5, 2026
The special court had released the dismissed police officer on 29 September in the Antilia explosives and Mansukh Hiran murder case, five years into his custody. The National Investigation Agency appealed, and the Division Bench reserved on 16 October. On Thursday it allowed the appeal and quashed the bail. There was prima facie material connecting Waze to the Scorpio, including a witness who said he directed its placement; allegations of a hundred-night hotel booking on a forged Aadhaar, payment to a witness to stay silent, and CCTV and electronic evidence dumped in the Mithi river; and, given his standing in the force, a real risk of tampering. The special judge’s view that a lower threshold of satisfaction applies at the stage of framing charge was “absolute legal perversity.” Five years in custody does not displace the bar in Section 43D(5) of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act; the remedy is an expedited trial, which the Court directed. The maxim that bail is the rule and jail the exception, the Court said, has no place in a UAPA bail application.
“The protectors have become the predators.”
Why it matters: The judgment reads Section 43D(5) strictly against a defendant whose principal argument was delay, and it rejects the proposition that the charge-framing stage lowers the prosecution’s burden on bail. An appeal to the Supreme Court is likely; the K.A. Najeeb line on long incarceration is the ground it will have to be argued on.
Elections: Form 8 Does Not Stop for a Revision — the Goa Bench Restores Six Deleted Voters and Refuses a Stay — Paresh Salgaonkar
Bench: Justices Valmiki Menezes and Amit Jamsandekar — November 5, 2026
Six members of a family who had moved house within Goa found their names deleted from the final roll after the Special Intensive Revision; the Commission’s position was that they should apply afresh as first-time electors in Form 6. The Division Bench held that Section 22 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950 and Rule 13 of the Registration of Electors Rules “are never suspended” by a revision; an existing elector who has shifted “can only file an application in Form 8” and cannot be made to declare as a first-time applicant; and deletion without a hearing “would amount to denial of the citizen’s right to vote.” The names are to be restored within ten days. The Commission’s requests to defer the matter pending the Supreme Court’s revision batch and to stay the order for two weeks were both refused. From the bench, Justice Menezes asked the Commission’s counsel: “Can you compel the person to make a false declaration?”
“Can you compel the person to make a false declaration?”
Why it matters: This is the first High Court judgment on the Form 6 question that the Supreme Court has been circling since October, and it answers it in terms: a revision does not convert an existing elector into a new one. The order is directly in point for the 19 November hearing in the Delhi matter and for every State roll now in revision.
Local Government: Kolkata’s Civic Polls Are on Hold Over a 144-to-209 Ward Redraw Made Under an Administrator — Dipu Das
Bench: Justices Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya and Arjun Ray Mukherjee — November 6, 2026
The State redrew the Kolkata Municipal Corporation’s wards from 144 to 209 while the Corporation was under an administrator, the elected board’s term having ended. A writ challenged the delimitation on the ground that the recommendatory role the statute gives the elected board could not be exercised by the administrator. The single judge refused interim relief on 29 October. On 4 November the vacation Division Bench restrained the State Election Commission from notifying the polls until 6 November and reserved; on Friday it barred the Commission from notifying elections on the redrawn wards until the single judge decides the writ. The State has said it will move the Supreme Court; the Howrah polls may be affected by the same reasoning.
Why it matters: The question is whether a statutory function vested in an elected body can be performed by a stop-gap administrator, and it recurs wherever municipal terms have lapsed. An appeal to the Supreme Court before 16 November is likely; until then, the city’s election timetable is governed by a writ.
Money Laundering: “The ED Is Not a Super Cop” — a Closed Predicate Offence Closes the PMLA Case, Karnataka Holds — Y.B. Ashwathanarayan
Bench: Justice M.I. Arun — reported November 8, 2026
The Directorate had continued proceedings under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act after the police closed the predicate case, and, where the police declined to act on information it shared under Section 66(2) of the Act, had filed a private complaint under Section 200 of the Code to generate a scheduled offence. The Court quashed the proceedings against K.Y. Nanje Gowda and others. Once the predicate offence is closed, whether on merits or on a technicality, the Directorate’s jurisdiction, which is derivative, ends with it; and the Directorate cannot itself supply the scheduled offence by complaint when the agency with jurisdiction has declined. “The ED is not a super cop to investigate anything and everything which comes into its notice.”
“The ED is not a super cop to investigate anything and everything which comes into its notice.”
Why it matters: Vijay Madanlal Choudhary made the money-laundering case dependent on the predicate offence; this judgment applies that to the Directorate’s workaround of filing its own complaint, and says it cannot. Expect the Directorate to appeal, and expect the judgment to be cited in every quashing petition where the police have closed the underlying case.
Personality Rights: Doosra May Be Screened, With a Disclaimer That Ganguly Did Not Consent and a ₹2 Crore Guarantee
Bench: Justice Tejas Karia — November 6, 2026
The film about the 2001 Kolkata Test was released in October after a vacation judge declined to stay it; Sourav Ganguly’s suit, with Luv Films as co-plaintiff, came on for interim relief on Monday and was decided on Friday. The Court found a prima facie case of infringement: the film “goes beyond depicting” the events of 2001 and uses Ganguly’s identity to generate commercial interest. But “selective deletion of the scenes is not a workable alternative” and “the balance of convenience does not lie in restraining the viewing of film by public.” Within two days the producers are to add a disclaimer at the start and end, in English and Hindi and in large type, stating that the film is not intended to infringe Ganguly’s rights and that “the use of Ganguly’s name in the movie shall not be construed as an acknowledgement or consent to such use,” and to furnish an unconditional bank guarantee of ₹2 crore to the Registrar General pending the suit.
“The balance of convenience does not lie in restraining the viewing of film by public.”
Why it matters: The order separates the finding of infringement from the remedy: a biographical film that trades on a living person’s identity infringes, but once released the court will secure damages rather than pull it. The disclaimer-plus-guarantee template is likely to be the standard interim order in the personality-rights suits now pending in Delhi.
Practice: Rajasthan’s Full Bench Restores the Criminal Writ Petition and Overrules a Division Bench — Ravi Kumar
Bench: Chief Justice Sanjay K. Agrawal and Justices Sameer Jain and Anuroop Singhi — November 2, 2026
A Division Bench in July had held that writ petitions arising from criminal matters were to be registered as civil writs, ending the separate “criminal writ petition” category. The Full Bench held that Rule 315(1)(h) of the Rajasthan High Court Rules requires such petitions to be registered as criminal writ petitions, declared the July ruling in Jiya v. Government of Rajasthan per incuriam, and directed the Registry to reclassify the pending matters within two weeks.
Why it matters: The classification decides the roster and the bench a liberty petition reaches, and the Registry’s two-week clock means pending matters will move. Practitioners who filed under the July ruling should check their numbers.
Arrest: The Grounds Given to the Accused Were Not the Grounds Shown to the Magistrate — Allahabad Orders an FIR — Mohd. Yaseen
Bench: Justices Atul Sreedharan and Achal Sachdev — November 4, 2026
In an abetment-of-suicide case the copy of the “reasons for arrest” handed to the accused mentioned only Section 108 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, while the version placed before the remand Magistrate and the bail court carried additional particulars. “The only inescapable inference,” the Division Bench held, was that the investigating officer inserted them later. The arrest was unlawful and the petitioner was ordered released at once; the Superintendent of Police, Farrukhabad, is to register a First Information Report against the officer under Chapter XIV of the Sanhita and report compliance in seven days. The matter is listed on 16 November. The judgment is reported as 2026 LiveLaw (AB) 927.
“The only inescapable inference.”
Why it matters: The grounds-of-arrest cases from Pankaj Bansal onward have turned on whether grounds were furnished; this one turns on whether the grounds furnished were the grounds relied on, and treats a discrepancy as fabrication. Defence counsel should compare the accused’s copy with the remand file as a matter of routine.
Other Notable High Court Orders
- Bombay — Imran Khan (November 2) — The actor’s “Leave India” notice under the Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025 remains in abeyance until the Foreigners Regional Registration Office hears him on his reply; the Court required an unconditional apology, not an undertaking, for his participation in the 10 October protest, observed that Overseas Citizen of India cardholders are not on a par with citizens in the right to protest, and listed the matter on 7 December.
- Bombay — Dia Mirza video (November 3) — Justices Kulkarni and Gokhale, in the suo motu matter on festive noise and air pollution, directed the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation to restore the actor’s pro bono “lights not noise” appeal that it had taken down after political objections, calling the objections “really unfortunate” and the communal turn they gave the issue out of keeping with the Constitution’s secular character.
- Bombay — Bail cancellation (reported November 6) — Justice Milind Jadhav quashed a sessions court’s cancellation of a former legislator’s bail in a 2023 murder conspiracy: with no fresh material after the High Court had itself declined cancellation, an apprehension of witness intimidation “must be supported by cogent material and cannot rest merely on general allegations.”
- Bombay — Customs order on invented judgments (reported November 7) — Justices M.S. Karnik and Sandesh Patil quashed a Commissioner of Customs’ order that relied on two Supreme Court judgments which “did not exist in any database”; the department consented and a fresh hearing was directed.
- Delhi — Vehicles (November 2 and 7) — Justice Amit Mahajan refused to stay the winter ban on pre-BS VI vehicles registered outside Delhi, listing the challenge on 27 November, and on Saturday exempted advocates and court staff commuting from the National Capital Region on the Delhi High Court Bar Association’s petition, cars with a bar association parking sticker being allowed in on court working days: “the function of assisting the Court for discharge of judicial work is also an essential duty.”
- Delhi — Qadeemi Masjid (November 3) — In the matter of the mosque within the Krishi Bhawan compound, the Land and Development Office told Justice Anish Dayal that the structure is “incompatible with the secular character of government property” and will be removed under the Central Vista redevelopment; the Court asked whether any rule bars a prayer space for any community on government land. 23 November.
- Delhi — LinkedIn (November 2) — Justice Amit Mahajan held that LinkedIn performs no public function and that a restriction of an account is not amenable to Article 226, following the Court’s rulings on Meta and X; the remedy is a civil suit.
- Karnataka — Contempt over a courtroom protest (November 3) — Chief Justice Vibhu Bakhru and Justice K.S. Hemalekha initiated suo motu contempt after advocates protesting violence against lawyers entered the Chief Justice’s court hall; the Registry is to identify them from CCTV, notice went to the Advocates’ Association, Bengaluru, and any apology must be on affidavit. 19 November.
- Kerala — Munnar (November 5) — Justices Devan Ramachandran and Basant Balaji named the Special Task Force on encroachments and forged title in Munnar and Vagamon, headed by V.R. Vinod of the Public Works Department, and directed a protocol for action by 10 December: “We will not go against any genuine land owner but we cannot sit over this for a century.” 12 November.
- Kerala — SNDP microfinance (November 6) — Justice A. Badharudeen held, as an interim finding, that no sanction under the Prevention of Corruption Act is needed to proceed against Vellappally Natesan and others in the ₹15.85 crore case, the Yogam not being a nodal agency of the State. 17 November.
- Kerala — Thachankary (November 2 and 6) — Justice Badharudeen called for the jail hospitalisation records of the former Director General of Police, asking how a man “seriously ill” in custody was fit to work abroad, and on Friday warned that his bail could be cancelled; the travel plea is pending.
- Calcutta — Evictions and deportation (reported November 6) — The vacation bench held that tea-garden occupants cannot be evicted for a land-port project without due process, whatever their title (“You cannot bring a bulldozer to a dharna”), and in a habeas petition restrained the deportation of an Indian passport holder detained as a suspected foreigner while travelling to Bangladesh on a valid visa, until 24 December.
- Madras — Policing (reported November 3) — Granting anticipatory bail to a DMK councillor over a speech against the Chief Minister, Justice N. Ramesh said the police must act even-handedly between ruling party and opposition, and, on the dawn pick-up of an economist over a fake-account post, that “an apology, however high its source, is not accountability” and “a remedy that depends on the Chief Minister’s personal intervention is not a remedy at all.”
- Allahabad — NOIDA (reported November 6) — Justice Rohit Ranjan Agarwal held that the New Okhla Industrial Development Authority, though “State” under Article 12, is neither a State nor the Central Government, so no notice under Section 80(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure is needed before suing it; a trial court’s refusal to register the suit was set aside.
- Telangana — “Rubber-stamp” cognizance (reported November 8) — Justice J. Sreenivas Rao set aside a Magistrate’s order taking cognizance of the accused rather than the offence and issuing summons without a dated cognizance order, recorded that the Court has set aside more than five hundred such orders since January, and directed the Registrar (Judicial) and the State Judicial Academy to train Magistrates.
- Punjab and Haryana — Assisted reproduction (reported November 8) — Justice Tribhuvan Dahiya held that the age limits in the Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Act apply on the day a service is availed, so a woman over fifty cannot undergo embryo transfer even if the embryos were frozen while she was eligible; the limits apply to each spouse separately.
- Karnataka — Legal education (reported November 6) — The Chief Justice’s bench held that a recognised first degree satisfies the eligibility rule for the three-year law course and that the 10+2 qualification has no independent relevance once the degree is valid.
- Gujarat — Recusal (November 6) — Justice Sanjeev Thaker recused from journalist Ravi Nair’s anticipatory bail petition in the forgery case arising from reporting on the Adani group; the matter goes to another bench.
At the Bar
Allahabad: The Bench Calls the Protest Criminal Contempt, the Chief Justice Skips the Bar’s Oath Ceremony, and Lawyers Block the Doors
Allahabad High Court — November 2–4, 2026
The order of 29 October in the matter that began with an advocate allegedly being sent to custody from Court 49, reported on Monday, recommended First Information Reports against the lawyers who vandalised the courtroom on 28 October, found their conduct prima facie criminal contempt, rejected the Bar Association’s letter as containing “false imputations” and “provocative language,” and asked the Chief Justice to consider action against those who circulated “false” posts on social media, which it called a “Goebbilian institution” that “had a field day”: “There is no justice for judges who are prey to such social media propaganda.” On Tuesday the Association’s new office-bearers took oath without the Chief Justice, who had been named special guest, or the Governor of Telangana, who had been named chief guest; no reason was given, and the Association’s own election committee boycotted the ceremony, writing that its presence would be “neither ‘proper’ nor ‘desirable’ in the prevailing circumstances.” On Wednesday the same Division Bench recorded that lawyers had blocked the entrances to the courtroom and stopped staff using the main gate, directed staff to use the judges’ door, and noted that the State’s law officers were absent: “The Court proceedings cannot stand paralyzed on account of lawyers who are deliberately absenting themselves from duty.” Justice Deshwal’s contempt against the sloganeering advocates remains listed on 19 November; no Full Court response has been reported.
“There is no justice for judges who are prey to such social media propaganda.”
Why it matters: The dispute has moved from a complaint about one judge to a confrontation between the Bar and the Court as an institution, with FIRs recommended, a boycott under way and the Chief Justice absent from the Bar’s own ceremony. The 19 November contempt date is the next formal step; whether the Full Court or the Bar Council of Uttar Pradesh acts before it is the question.
Appointments: Justice Rajesh Bindal to Chair the NCLAT, One Bombay Judge Notified, and the Four Chief Justices Still Wait
The Supreme Court Collegium and the Union Law Ministry — November 2–6, 2026
Justice Rajesh Bindal, who retired from the Supreme Court in April after serving as Chief Justice of the Allahabad High Court, confirmed on Thursday that he has been appointed Chairperson of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal. The post has been vacant since Justice Ashok Bhushan’s term ended on 4 July, with Justice Yogesh Khanna officiating; the appointment comes a week after the Chief Justice’s bench said the Ministry of Corporate Affairs had “hijacked” the tribunals’ staffing and asked the two tribunal heads for proposals within four weeks. The same day the Centre notified Ajay Sharma, a Judicial Member of the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal, as an Additional Judge of the Bombay High Court for two years; Vaibhav Sugdare, recommended with him on 26 October, was not notified. Nor, by the close of the week, were the four Chief Justices the Collegium recommended on 26 October for Delhi, Gujarat, Telangana and Uttarakhand, or the thirty-one High Court judges recommended for Madhya Pradesh, Bombay, Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh, and Chhattisgarh; the Delhi High Court’s cause lists still show an Acting Chief Justice. No new Collegium resolution was reported. On Monday Justice P.S. Narasimha recused from Lok Prahari’s petition on the Memorandum of Procedure, and on Wednesday, at the Supreme Court Bar Association’s felicitation of Justices Sunita Agarwal and Aparesh Kumar Singh, the Chief Justice described one of his criteria for elevation: “One of the factors which at least I have always kept in mind is how you are going to perform as a team member,” because the Court “is virtually now playing a T20 match with this much filing.”
“One of the factors which at least I have always kept in mind is how you are going to perform as a team member.”
Why it matters: The NCLAT has a regular head for the first time in four months, which matters for the Subhash Chandra and other large matters listed this month. The Centre’s selective notification, one Bombay name and not the other, and its silence on four Chief Justices twelve days after the recommendation, is the pattern to watch when the Court reopens.
Lawyers and Police: Rohini’s Strike Is Called Off Within a Day, and Ghaziabad’s Four Advocates Get Protection From the Supreme Court
Rohini Courts and the Supreme Court — November 3, 2026
The Rohini Court Bar Association withdrew its call to abstain from work on Tuesday, the day it took effect, after the Home Ministry suspended an Assistant Commissioner of Police who had joined a police protest outside headquarters against the transfers that followed the 28 October confrontation between lawyers and the Shahdara police. The same day, in A. Deepa v. State of U.P., the Chief Justice’s bench heard four advocates who say they were assaulted on 22 October in a Ghaziabad housing complex and then named in a cross-FIR three days later. Senior Advocate Vikas Singh called the police response “shocking” and alleged that the investigating officer had told a young woman advocate she was too young to be a lawyer at all. The Court called for a status report from the Uttar Pradesh Police and directed that “no harm is caused to the life and property of the petitioners,” but declined to stay the cross-FIR without hearing the State.
Why it matters: Two episodes in a week in which the Bar’s leverage was tested against the police, one resolved by the executive within hours and one taken up by the Supreme Court on its first listing. The status report will show whether the Court is prepared to supervise a district investigation into an attack on lawyers.
Other Notable at the Bar
- Senior mentioning (November 2) — The bar on oral mentioning by Senior Advocates under the Registry’s circular of 27 October took effect on Monday; no incident, modification or statement from the Supreme Court Bar Association or the Advocates-on-Record Association was reported during the week.
- The Chief Justice’s week — In Ranchi on Monday, inaugurating the Jharkhand High Court’s data centre: “Technology is only a means to an end,” and digital services “must widen access to justice rather than exclude those who are already disadvantaged.” At the Rouse Avenue courts on Thursday: “a person meets the judicial system for the first time at the District Court.” At the SC, ST and OBC Advocates’ Association’s conference on Friday: “a right that she cannot reach, understand, or afford to claim remains a right only on paper.”
- Justice Kaul’s memoir (November 4) — A further excerpt from Without Fear or Favour, on the obscenity prosecutions of M.F. Husain: “That’s not legitimate outrage – that’s organised harassment masquerading as religious sentiment.” The launch is scheduled for 25 November.
- Retirement (November 4–5) — Justice K. Natarajan demitted office at the Kerala High Court, eight years after his appointment to the Karnataka High Court: “We must therefore hear the advocates patiently, treat them courteously and determine the rights in accordance with law.”
- Court safety (November 7) — At the Jharigaon Magistrate’s court in Odisha a litigant struck the Assistant Public Prosecutor and the court’s police officer on the head with a concealed iron rod and injured the Magistrate who intervened; all three were treated and discharged.
- Intellectual property (November 7) — Justice Prathiba M. Singh of the Delhi High Court, at a conference on the legal architecture of 2047: “I have no doubt in my mind that we need to create uniform IP courts across the country.”
Insolvency & Corporate
Personal Insolvency: Venugopal Dhoot Is Declared Bankrupt on ₹12,668 Crore of Videocon Guarantees — SBI v. Dhoot
NCLT Mumbai: Vinay Goel (Judicial) and Charanjeet Singh Gulati (Technical) — November 5, 2026
The Videocon promoter was admitted to a personal insolvency resolution process in April as guarantor for Videocon Industries. His repayment plan, ₹600 crore over thirty-six months, under half of one per cent of the debt with nothing up front, was rejected under Section 114 of the Code in July and the process terminated. The State Bank of India filed for bankruptcy under Section 123 in September, within the three-month window in Section 121(2). On Thursday the Tribunal found the petition in order, “satisfied that the Petition complies with all the requirements prescribed in Section 123 of the Code,” and passed a bankruptcy order under Section 126 on a default computed at ₹12,668 crore as of 30 September. Asish Narayan was appointed bankruptcy trustee; the estate vests in him; the disqualifications in Sections 140 and 141 apply until discharge under Section 138; the Bank is to pay a ₹2 lakh ad hoc fee and a preliminary report is due in ninety days.
“We are satisfied that the Petition complies with all the requirements prescribed in Section 123 of the Code.”
Why it matters: This is the largest personal bankruptcy order under Part III of the Code and the first against a promoter of this scale to run the full course from admission through a rejected plan to a trustee. The route, admission, plan rejection, Section 123 within three months, is now mapped for every lender holding a large personal guarantee.
IBC: “The Test Is Whether the Dispute Is Plausible” — the NCLAT Reverses a Second Listed-Company Admission in a Week — FTF Pharma
NCLAT New Delhi: Justice Mohd. Faiz Alam Khan (Judicial) and Naresh Salecha (Technical) — November 4, 2026
The Ahmedabad bench had admitted an operational creditor’s petition against FTF Pharma, a subsidiary of Shilpa Medicare, in September on ₹2.18 crore of invoices under a 2022 technology-transfer agreement. The debtor had disputed the invoices in writing from July 2023 to August 2024, before the demand notice of October 2024. The Appellate Tribunal held that the bench had applied the wrong standard, weighing the strength of the dispute rather than its plausibility and straying into the merits: “The Adjudicating Authority is not meant to hold a trial at the admission stage.” The process was closed, the moratorium lifted, the interim professional discharged and the board restored; the creditor, whose claim had meanwhile been settled, did not oppose. It follows the Appellate Tribunal’s reversal on 30 October of the admission against Polycab on a ₹2.78 crore claim, on the same ground.
“The test is whether the dispute is plausible. It is not whether it is significant.”
Why it matters: Two admissions of listed companies set aside in six days on pre-existing disputes is a signal to the benches that Mobilox is being applied too loosely at the Section 9 stage. For operational creditors the lesson is the converse: a documented pre-notice dispute, however weak, is likely to defeat admission.
PMLA and IBC: Plan Approval Releases an Earlier ED Attachment, and No Special Court Finding Is Needed — Dash Exports v. ED
Delhi High Court: Justices Navin Chawla and Arun Bhardwaj — November 6, 2026
The corporate debtor’s insolvency began in February 2020; a plan was approved by the Tribunal in September 2021 with the backing of over 99 per cent of the committee. Between the two dates the Directorate provisionally attached the debtor’s property, and confirmed the attachment in 2022; the Appellate Tribunal under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act dismissed the debtor’s appeal in 2025, holding that a Special Court had first to find that the acquirer was outside the exceptions in Section 32A of the Insolvency Code. The Division Bench disagreed. Section 32A operates to release attached property once a plan is approved and its conditions are met; the Appellate Tribunal erred in demanding a finding from the Special Court on an exception the Directorate had never invoked: “the Special Court is not to give an academic finding or a finding in vacuum.” A fixed deposit of ₹3.01 crore is to be released within two weeks.
“The Special Court is not to give an academic finding or a finding in vacuum.”
Why it matters: Resolution applicants have been told since Manish Kumar that Section 32A protects them; this is the first High Court judgment to say the protection operates against an attachment that predates the plan, and without a detour to the Special Court unless the Directorate pleads an exception. It will be cited in every pending appeal before the PMLA Appellate Tribunal involving a resolved debtor.
Appellate Practice: No Certified-Copy Application Inside Limitation, No Appeal; and Recall Is Not a Rehearing — Technofab and Excel Arcade
NCLAT Principal Bench: Justice Yogesh Khanna (Officiating Chairperson), Barun Mitra and Ajai Das Mehrotra (Technical) — November 2 and 4, 2026
In Anil Khandelwal v. Committee of Creditors of Technofab Engineering, an appeal against the rejection of a resolution plan was e-filed on the forty-fourth day, within the outer limit of Section 61, with a plea for condonation and an exemption from filing the certified copy; the certified copy was applied for only on the sixty-sixth day. The exemption, the Tribunal held, is discretionary, and the failure to apply for the copy within limitation goes to the root of appellate jurisdiction: the appeal “is not merely a defective appeal but it is an incompetent appeal.” It applied the Supreme Court’s ruling of 14 October in Sreenivasa Rao Ravinuthala, 2026 INSC 1121, that limitation under Section 62 runs from pronouncement. In Excel Arcade v. Unity Small Finance Bank, a party whose condonation plea had been dismissed in May sought recall, citing glitches in the Registry’s e-filing portal in January. Relying on Budhia Swain v. Gopinath Deb, the bench held that recall lies only on recognised grounds and that the application was a review in disguise, which the Tribunal has no power to grant; holidays are no excuse when e-filing runs around the clock. “The power of recall is not the power to rehear the case to find out any apparent error in the judgment.”
“The appeal is not merely a defective appeal but it is an incompetent appeal.”
Why it matters: Together with the Supreme Court’s October ruling, the certified-copy decision makes the forty-fifth day an absolute wall for Section 61 appeals, and an exemption application a gamble rather than a routine. Counsel should apply for the certified copy on the day of pronouncement.
Other Notable Insolvency Orders
- IBBI — Disciplinary (November 3) — The Disciplinary Committee suspended the registration of P.R. Raman, resolution professional of Hallmark Infrastructure, for two years on a homebuyers’ complaint: no valuers for securities or financial assets, no methodology meeting with the committee, no avoidance-transaction determination while diamonds worth about ₹8 crore were written off, Form G seventy days late and a belated expression of interest treated as a substitution. “The subsequent approval of a resolution plan by the CoC also does not cure the non-compliance.” He may not continue existing assignments.
- MCA — Overseas listing (November 3) — The Companies (Listing of Equity Instruments in Permissible Jurisdictions) Amendment Rules, 2026 widen the 2024 direct-listing framework from shares to “equity instruments,” including convertible debentures and preference shares, bring unlisted public companies in the GIFT City jurisdiction within scope, allow a company with negative net worth to list if three-quarters of the net offer goes to qualified institutional buyers, cut the default look-back from two years to six months, and prescribe a new Form LEAP-1.
- NCLT Mumbai — Quadrant Televentures (November 3) — Fastway’s ₹231.5 crore plan was approved against admitted claims of ₹2,815 crore, with the Department of Telecommunications’ demand for a ₹416 crore escrow for licence dues rejected: “the licence terms cannot prevail over the terms of the Resolution Plan,” and the spectrum-trust ruling does not apply to a licensee holding no spectrum.
- NCLT Mumbai — West Gujarat Expressway (November 2) — The IL&FS road subsidiary’s own petition under Section 10 was admitted on a default of about ₹227 crore; dues acknowledged in audited financials extend limitation, and a pending Serious Fraud Investigation Office inquiry is no bar to admission.
- NCLT Mumbai — Withdrawal refused (reported November 7) — In Tata Capital Housing Finance v. Dharan Infra-EPC, settlement with the petitioning creditor alone, before the committee was constituted, did not justify withdrawal over the objection of six other lenders with claims of about ₹600 crore: settlement with one creditor “does not, by itself, establish the Corporate Debtor’s ability to resolve its financial distress.”
- NCLAT — Personal guarantors (reported November 5) — In Vinod Doulatani v. IIFL One Value Fund, the Principal Bench held, following Dilip B. Jiwrajka, that a creditor’s locus to initiate proceedings against a personal guarantor cannot be decided before the Section 100 stage; the resolution professional’s report is recommendatory.
- NCLAT — MSME framework (reported November 6) — In Jadabendra Pradhan v. Canara Bank, a suspended director’s challenge to admission failed where the company had lost MSME status in 2021, never answered the SARFAESI notice or approached the stressed-MSME committee, and had acknowledged the debt and offered settlements.
- Open threads — No movement was reported in the Subhash Chandra personal insolvency ahead of the five-member bench on 19 November, and the Securities Appellate Tribunal’s order on Jane Street’s disclosure application, reserved on 21 October, had not been pronounced.
Legislative & Regulatory Watch
Securities: The Settlement Regulations, 2026 Commence, With a Ninety-Day Window for Applications the Old Regime Turned Away
SEBI Press Release 70/2026 — November 6, 2026 (commencement November 7)
The Securities and Exchange Board of India announced on Friday that the Settlement of Administrative and Civil Proceedings Regulations, 2026, notified on 8 October, “shall come into force on 07.11.2026,” repealing the 2018 Settlement Proceedings Regulations subject to transitional provisions. With them come an online application facility, a settlement-amount calculator with an explanatory video, frequently asked questions and a help desk. Under the new framework an application in a proceeding pending before the Board must be filed within ninety days of the show-cause notice or any supplementary notice, whichever is later; the limit does not apply to proceedings before the Appellate Tribunal or the Supreme Court. Regulation 4(3) opens a ninety-day window from commencement, to early February 2027, for applicants whose applications under the 2018 regime were rejected, returned or withdrawn, or who never filed; an uplift of twenty per cent applies to re-filing after a withdrawal or rejection. The 6 November date that appeared in some reports is that of the press release, not the commencement.
“Settlement Regulations, 2026 shall come into force on 07.11.2026.”
Why it matters: For respondents with stale or rejected settlement applications the ninety-day window is a one-time reopening, and the calculator makes the settlement amount predictable before the application is filed. The ninety-day limit from the show-cause notice means the settlement decision now has to be taken at the start of a proceeding, not at its end.
Securities: Six Circulars in Four Days — Manager-Led Accreditation, a $5 Million Cap on Unhedged Currency Positions, and Remote KYC
SEBI circulars — November 2–5, 2026
The week before Diwali was a busy one at the Board. On 2 November it permitted real-estate and infrastructure investment trusts and their selling unitholders to issue foreign-currency depository receipts on their units, listed on the exchanges at GIFT City, with a merchant banker, a three-quarters unitholder approval for fresh issues and a floor at the domestic price; and it cut the cooling-off period for offers for sale of illiquid units of privately listed infrastructure trusts from twelve weeks to eight. On 4 November it rewrote the know-your-client process for non-resident Indians, overseas citizens and foreign nationals in jurisdictions compliant with the Financial Action Task Force, removing the requirement of physical presence in India for digital onboarding and allowing DigiLocker documents, Aadhaar authentication or attested copies, with effect from 3 December. On 5 November it reviewed the accredited-investor framework to add an optional “manager-led” route, under which the manager of an alternative investment fund, the asset manager of a specialised investment fund or a portfolio manager may itself determine and record an investor’s accredited status, valid for three years: “Manager led accreditation is an additional and optional route.” The same day it capped currency-derivative positions held without underlying exposure at a single aggregate of USD 5 million across all rupee pairs and all exchanges, for domestic clients and foreign portfolio investors alike, following the Reserve Bank’s October measures and replacing a limit of USD 100 million that dated from 2018; and it permitted net settlement of funds for a mutual fund scheme’s cash-market trades within a settlement cycle, at scheme level and for outright transactions only, from 1 April 2027. The Board also constituted an eighteen-member working group, co-chaired by Srini Srinivasan of the Indian Venture and Alternate Capital Association and Prashanth Prakash of Accel, to review the Innovators Growth Platform, and signed an agreement with the Digital India Bhashini Division for regional-language versions of its services.
“Manager led accreditation is an additional and optional route.”
Why it matters: The currency-derivative cap is the one with teeth: a position without underlying exposure above USD 5 million now needs the Reserve Bank’s hedging framework, a twenty-fold cut that lands in the middle of the rupee’s defence. Manager-led accreditation removes a structural bottleneck for funds, and the remote-KYC circular ends the oddity of requiring a non-resident to fly in to open an account.
Securities: The Appellate Tribunal Sets Aside the ₹25 Crore Coffee Day Penalty and Orders a Fresh Probe of a ₹3,535 Crore Diversion
Securities Appellate Tribunal — November 5, 2026
By a majority the Tribunal set aside the Board’s order against Coffee Day Enterprises: the penalty of ₹25 crore under Section 15HA of the SEBI Act fell, and the penalty under Section 15HB was reduced to ₹50 lakh, the members differing on the second point. The Tribunal then directed the Board to investigate afresh the diversion of about ₹3,535 crore from the listed company to the promoters’ entities, to trace the ultimate beneficiaries, to consider disgorgement and restitution to public shareholders, and to examine whether there was insider trading.
Why it matters: The Tribunal has rarely set aside a penalty and in the same breath ordered a wider investigation; the order treats the Board’s original case as both too much and too little. The restitution direction, if it is acted on, is the outcome minority shareholders have sought since 2019.
Payments: The UPI Merchant Charge Is “Both Lawful and Necessary,” and Merchants Cannot Pass It On, NPCI Tells the Court
Counter-affidavit in the Supreme Court — November 3, 2026
In the public-interest petition against the merchant discount rate on person-to-merchant Unified Payments Interface transactions above ₹2,000, the Corporation’s affidavit, filed on Tuesday and reported on Friday, defends a charge capped at 0.4 per cent. Person-to-person payments and small merchants, those with up to ₹1 lakh of monthly UPI receipts, are exempt, and about 96 per cent of merchant transactions are unaffected. Merchants and payment applications are barred from passing the charge to customers, a prohibition the Corporation calls “binding and not merely a policy assurance,” enforced through service-level agreements and the loss of UPI membership, and application providers may not levy platform fees. The affidavit says the amendment to Section 10A of the Payment and Settlement Systems Act lists exempt modes rather than imposing a charge, relies on the Corporation’s 2016 authorisation from the Reserve Bank, denies that it is “State” under Article 12, and puts the industry’s cost of running the system at ₹20,700 crore against ₹2,000 crore of government support. The rollout, deferred in October to a date after Diwali, remains without a date.
“Both lawful and necessary.”
Why it matters: This is the first time the Corporation has put its legal basis for the charge on the record of a court, and the no-pass-through rule is now a sworn position rather than a press line. Whether a body that denies being “State” can be made to honour it in a writ is the question the petition will now turn on.
Banking: Draft Priority-Sector Directions for Five Classes of Lender, a Cyber Rulebook for Payment Operators, and a Markets Committee
Reserve Bank of India — November 4–5, 2026
On Wednesday the Reserve Bank constituted the Technical Consultative Committee for Financial Markets promised in October’s policy statement, chaired by the Deputy Governor in charge of markets regulation with seven external members including Ridham Desai and the former SEBI member Ananth Narayan, to meet at least quarterly on the money, government-securities, foreign-exchange and derivatives markets. On Thursday it published five separate draft Priority Sector Lending Directions, one each for commercial banks, small finance banks, local area banks, regional rural banks and urban co-operative banks, consolidating the instructions regulator-by-regulatee with the forty per cent target, the agriculture and weaker-section sub-targets and the district weighting retained through the current year; comments are due by 26 November. The same day it issued the Master Directions on Cyber Resilience and Digital Payment Security Controls for non-bank payment system operators, 2026, consolidating the 2024 directions and the earlier controls for ATM switches and system audits into one instrument, with six-hour incident reporting retained and small operators given until April 2028 to comply. Three urban co-operative banks under Section 35A directions had them extended, and the Reserve Bank published no penalty on a bank or finance company during the week.
Why it matters: The priority-sector drafts are a re-codification rather than a policy change, but five separate instruments mean five separate compliance maps, and the comment window is short. The cyber-resilience directions are the operative rulebook for every wallet, gateway and card network from now on.
Other Notable Regulatory Moves
- Fast-track courts (November 4) — The Union Cabinet extended the centrally sponsored scheme for Fast Track Special Courts for rape and POCSO cases to 31 March 2031 with an outlay of ₹3,788 crore, and approved an increase in the number of courts from 779 to 850, each with a dedicated judge, a special public prosecutor and six staff.
- Telecom (November 2–5) — The Telecom Regulatory Authority notified the Telecom Consumers Complaint Redressal (Fourth Amendment) Regulations, requiring round-the-clock complaint centres with a human agent available at least sixteen hours a day alongside any AI assistant, cutting the appeal window from thirty days to fifteen, and applying the regime to internet providers with more than 10,000 subscribers; the Interconnection (Third Amendment) Regulations move interconnection to the licensed-service-area level and to IP from 1 January 2027; and on Thursday the Authority recommended a separate authorisation for satellite network providers, with the condition that they “prevent direct communication between two or more user terminals through one or more satellites” and route no Indian traffic through foreign gateways.
- Insurance (November 2–3) — The Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority issued a Master Circular on registration, capital structure, transfer of shares and amalgamation, cutting the share-transfer processing fee from ₹50 lakh to ₹10 lakh, and an exposure draft of regulations on subsidiary instructions and consultative committees under the new Sections 114B and 114C of the Insurance Act, with comments by 23 November.
- Income tax (November 4) — Notification 141/2026 exempts dividends paid between aircraft-leasing units in the International Financial Services Centre from deduction at source on a declaration in Form 1(N), deemed effective from 1 April 2026; the 21 November due date for audited returns stands.
- Foreign exchange (November 2) — The Foreign Exchange Management (Export and Import of Goods and Services) (Second Amendment) Regulations, 2026 deem the export declaration filed for individual service exporters, and for companies on remittances up to ₹10 lakh, once payment details reach the authorised dealer.
- Aviation (reported November 2–4) — The Bharatiya Vayuyan Niyam, 2026, two hundred and twenty rules under the 2024 Act, replace the Aircraft Rules, 1937 from 1 January 2027.
- Goods and services tax (November 1–2) — The Network’s advisories implementing the 1 November changes: amendments to a registration other than the principal place of business are auto-approved on validation, the registration form adds a one-person-company category, and the composition form carries the new Section 10(2A) category. No Board instrument was issued during the week.
- Drug pricing (from November 9) — The revised prices under the thirty per cent cap on trade margins for 137 non-scheduled anti-cancer drugs apply from Monday; the Court’s reserved order on margins beyond cancer drugs was not pronounced.
- Data protection (from November 13) — Rule 4 of the Digital Personal Data Protection Rules, on the registration of consent managers, commences on Thursday; the general obligations follow in May 2027.
What We’re Watching Next Week
- The Supreme Court is closed for Diwali from Monday, 9 November, to Saturday, 14 November, and reopens on Monday, 16 November: M.C. Mehta on Delhi’s air before the Chief Justice’s bench, the Delhi-NCR rapes suo motu matter, Azam Khan’s petition before the Allahabad High Court, and Ashish Mishra’s return to custody after his Diwali visit are all on 16 November.
- Tuesday, 17 November — The Opposition’s petitions against the Election Commission and the plea to suspend the Chief Election Commissioner; Sanjay Raut’s appearance in person in the Bar Association’s contempt petition; Punjab’s Chief Secretary before Justice Bunger, with the Supreme Court’s stay in place; the SNDP microfinance case in Kerala.
- Wednesday, 18 November — The final hearing in Kannan Tiruvengadam on whether an insolvency professional’s suspension removes him from all assignments.
- Thursday, 19 November — The Delhi revision and the Commission’s Form 6 letter; the Section 163 and 172 BNSS petitions from the protest docket; Justice Deshwal’s contempt in Allahabad and the Karnataka High Court’s contempt over the courtroom protest; the five-member bench on Subhash Chandra’s plan; Sona Bansal and the NCLAT’s “requests are directions” notice.
- Also this week — Kerala’s Munnar task force on 12 November; consent-manager registration under the data-protection rules from 13 November; the Reserve Bank’s priority-sector drafts open for comment to 26 November.
- Reserved — The Enforcement Directorate’s petition against Mamata Banerjee; drug margins beyond cancer drugs; Jane Street’s disclosure application at the Appellate Tribunal; Satyam Verma in Allahabad; the Madras bye-election challenge; and at the Supreme Court the Sabarimala nine-judge reference, the Sambhal survey, the PMLA Adjudicating Authority’s composition, anticipatory bail direct to the High Court, and now the larger-bench references on the two-child norm and, if it is made, on Article 21 and Section 37 of the NDPS Act.
That’s all for this week. If a colleague would find this useful, forward them this page — or better yet, ask them to subscribe.
Enjoyed this issue?
Get the next one delivered straight to your inbox every Monday.